what to say and not to say to doctor, tequested by employers lawyer

by Clay Harber 8 min read

Can an employer ask for a doctor’s note?

An employer can also request a doctor’s note if the employee asks for reasonable accommodations because of a disability. Employers can request a doctor’s note as long as it does not affect the employee’s rights for freedom from discrimination and privacy.

Can an employer ask for proof of medical condition?

Then, employers are allowed to ask for documentation to verify the existence or severity of your health issue. If an employer suspects that you’re suffering from a condition that might cause you to be unable to perform your job, or might cause you to be unsafe on the job.

What should I not tell my workers'comp Doctor?

To recap, here are three things not to tell your workers' comp doctor: 1 Don't exaggerate your symptoms 2 Don't be rude or negative 3 Don't lie More ...

Can my employer force me to take a medical exam?

Generally, you cannot be made to take a medical exam or otherwise prove that you’re fit to work unless your employer has reason to believe that you’re a safety risk or has reason to believe that you can no longer perform the essential tasks involved with your job.

Is it against Hipaa for an employer to ask for a doctors note?

Under HIPAA's Privacy Rule, an employer can ask employees for a doctor's note and other health information if the information is needed for “sick leave, workers' compensation, wellness programs or health insurance.”

Can employers call your doctor?

HIPAA's Privacy Rule makes it so that an employer can ask you for a doctor's note or health information for health insurance, workers' compensation, sick leave, or other programs. However, the employer cannot call a doctor or healthcare provider directly for information about you.

Do employers verify doctors notes?

Your employer has the right to verify that the note was written by the doctor's office, but they cannot ask for any additional information. A doctor's office that receives a phone call asking for more details about the note would be legally required to deny the request.

Do I have to disclose my medical condition to my employer?

Employers cannot request that an employee discloses information about any health conditions that arise during employment. Employees might choose to volunteer information, and if they do then the employer is required to make reasonable adjustments to support the employee in their work.

What questions can an employer ask about your health?

When you come in for a job interview, your employer can ask whether you are physically able to do the job, but they cannot ask if you have a specific condition that could impede work. If you are a woman, they cannot ask if you are or plan to become pregnant.

What happens if you get caught faking a doctors note?

You can get in legal trouble for faking a doctor's note by being charged with forgery, identity theft, and fraud charges. The legal trouble for faking a doctor's notes can range from a fine up to $25000 and jail time up to 8 years. Faking a doctor's note is, without a doubt, illegal.

Can an employer ask for proof of medical appointment?

Your employer has no right to know the diagnosis of the illness for which you are visiting the doctor. It does, however, have the right to ask for proof only that your reason for taking time off is real.

Can you get a disciplinary for being off sick with a doctor's note?

Pretending to be ill when you are not would be misconduct and if discovered, is likely to have disciplinary consequences. Even if all your sickness absences are genuine and certificated, you can still be given a formal warning because of high levels of sickness absence.

How to communicate that you are taking your claim seriously?

The first way to communicate that you are taking your claim seriously is to show up early to your appointments. If you arrive late (or not at all), this may send the impression that you are not actually injured.

What is the job of a doctor?

Your doctor’s job is to assess and treat your workplace injury, not to change the safety conditions at your job. While you should be as honest as possible when explaining how your injury occurred, keep your emotions out of it.

What is a workers comp doctor?

Your workers comp doctor is trained to spot inconsistencies in your story and has a vast deal of medical experience. They will be able to compare your story against your injury and tell if you are lying.

Do you get workers comp insurance if you are injured?

If you’ve been injured at work, you’re probably very grateful for your employer’s workers’ comp insurance. Being able to receive free medical care without having to chip away at your own savings can be a lifeline for most Florida workers.

What happens if you don't tell your doctor your story?

If they discover that you haven't told the full story, or have withheld vital details, this discrepancy may jeopardize your claim's chance of success.

What does a doctor decide on during a physical evaluation?

The doctor's evaluation will decide on any physical work restrictions, recommendations for time off work, or perhaps returning to work on light duty (work that can be completed without interfering with your injury).

What to do during IME?

The most important thing you can do during your IME is to be honest. Insurance companies are skilled at finding inconsistencies in your statements and symptoms and will use those inconsistencies to destroy your workers' comp claim. Avoid raising any red flags in your claim process by following three simple rules.

Do you have to go to a doctor for workers comp?

Yes, you want to make sure your symptoms don't go unnoticed by your doctor. But at the same measure, workers' comp doctors are usually well-trained to spot exaggerated claims and false displays of suffering.

Does workers compensation have a final decision?

That way, the workers' compensation insurance company will have a better understanding of the cause, the extent, and restrictions of your injuries and be able to make a final decision on your compensation claim.

Why do employers violate the law?

Others simply make mistakes because they don’t keep up when the rules change, their companies grow to a size that makes them subject to the FMLA, or they are too lax about paperwork and notice requirements. No matter what your employer’s motivations, ...

What happens if you don't give 30 days notice?

If you need leave for a foreseeable reason and you fail to give the legally-required 30 days’ notice, your employer may postpone the start of your leave. An employer may also ask you to make reasonable efforts to schedule foreseeable leave for planned medical treatment in a way that doesn’t unduly disrupt the company’s operations.

Do you have to reinstate your FMLA?

Although employers don’t have to continue other types of benefits (like life insurance), they must reinstate those benefits immediately when the employee’s leave is over, with no waiting period or extra hurdles for the employee. Even after your FMLA leave is up, other laws might give you the right to additional time off.

Can an employer fire an employee for FMLA?

Of course, employers may not fire employees for exercising their rights under the FMLA (although some do just that). However, more often, employers get into trouble when they discipline or otherwise punish employees for FMLA-related absences. For example, an employer might count an employee’s FMLA leave as an “unexcused” absence or as a point in a no-fault absence policy. Or, an employer might improperly count an employee’s protected time off against the employee in calculating seniority or discipline an employee for taking longer to complete work due to the employee’s protected leave.

Can I take FMLA if I have dental surgery?

Other than these exceptions, however, you have the right to take FMLA leave when you need it. If your doctor says you need dental surgery this week, your employer can’t force you to postpone the surgery or deny your leave request because it’s inconvenient.

Can an employer require more notice for FMLA?

When it comes to unpaid FMLA-protected leave, the employer can’t require more notice than the law allows. This issue often comes up when an employee needs FMLA leave for an emergency health issue ...

Do you have to say FMLA?

Employees don’t have to say they need “FMLA leave” or use any other legal phrase. Instead, they need only give the employer enough information to realize that the request for time off is covered by the FMLA. For example, employers should realize that an employee who asks for time off to spend with a new child or to care for a spouse during cancer treatment has almost certainly provided a qualifying reason for taking job-protected FMLA leave. This means the employee must not only receive all of the required notices and paperwork, but must also be able to continue health insurance while on leave and be reinstated after the leave is over.

What to do if you are forced to disclose a medical condition?

If you’ve been forced to disclose a medical condition, or discriminated against because of one, it’s a good idea to speak to an attorney with experience fighting for workers’ rights.

What does it mean when an employer asks for documentation?

Then, employers are allowed to ask for documentation to verify the existence or severity of your health issue. If an employer suspects that you’re suffering from a condition that might cause you to be unable to perform your job, or might cause you to be unsafe on the job.

Why do you have to take a medical exam after an offer is extended?

After an employer extends a conditional job offer, they may require you to take a medical exam to ensure that you can perform the tasks required of the job. It’s important to note, though, that you may only be asked to take a medical exam if everyone who is applying for that position is required to pass a medical exam.

Why does my boss ask probing questions?

However, it’s another story if a boss asks probing questions in order to determine if you’re pregnant, diabetic, or suffering from some kind of serious health condition.

Can you be made to take a medical exam?

Generally, you cannot be made to take a medical exam or otherwise prove that you’re fit to work unless your employer has reason to believe that you’re a safety risk or has reason to believe that you can no longer perform the essential tasks involved with your job.

Can employers ask about serious health conditions?

The law only allows employers to ask about serious health conditions under a few circumstances. Those are: If you’ve already disclosed that you have a medical condition and you are seeking a job accommodation under the ADA, or you are requesting medical leave.

HIPAA Privacy Laws

HIPAA is a federal act that protects the privacy of medical records for people. HIPAA laws require an employee’s medical information to be kept separate from an employee’s personnel file.

FMLA Protection

The law says that the employee’s testimony and doctor’s note are sufficient evidence to prove that their absence was because of a serious health condition. The FMLA law protects employees from retaliation because of the absence.

How Can Employers Protect Themselves In Relation to FMLA Leave

Employers need to have a policy in place for handling doctor’s notes. The policy should leave sick leave in the hands of HR instead of managers or supervisors who may retaliate against employees because of increased workload. The employer is the one who has to comply with FMLA leave, even if the employee has not requested FMLA leave.

Legal Considerations

The employee’s medical details are protected by FMLA and HIPAA laws. Employers may not request information about their medical conditions or copies of medical records. However, an employer can ask for certifications of the condition and call the doctor to confirm the information on the doctor’s note.

Severe Injuries

Often, if the medical condition is visible, the employer may not ask for a doctor’s note. Some employers may make the decision to lay off an employee who has a severe injury that hampers their ability to perform their duties. In these cases, a doctor’s note may not affect the decision at all.

How to Terminate an Employee

California is an at-will employment state so an employer may fire an employee who provided a doctor’s note as long as they can prove the decision was not based on discrimination. Employers may not fire employees who file for workers’ compensation or those who have become disabled by can perform their duties with reasonable accommodations.

Why is it illegal to talk about your employer on social media?

That's because trying to curtail worker communications can be seen as an illegal attempt to prevent them from unionizing or organizing.

What can't a boss do?

What's more, state laws can vary. However, generally, here are 13 things your boss can't legally do: Ask prohibited questions on job applications. Require employees to sign broad non-compete agreements. Forbid you from discussing your salary with co-workers. Not pay you overtime or minimum wage.

What is the obligation of an employer to ensure its workplace is a safe environment?

An employer has an obligation to ensure its workplace is a safe environment and that worker complaints are handled in an appropriate manner. Some states also require companies to provide sexual harassment training to workers or supervisors.

Why is it bad to prohibit salary discussions?

That's because there is no way for employees to gauge wage equality with co-workers if they can't discuss their compensation.

Do all workplace laws apply to every business?

Not all workplace laws apply to every business and employee. For instance, some small businesses may be exempt from certain requirements, and managers may not have all the same wage protections as hourly workers. What's more, state laws can vary.

Can you work off the clock for Nonexempt?

Nonexempt employees who are covered by the Fair Labor Standards Act can't be asked to do work off the clock. For instance, workers can't be required to do prep work or clean up outside their paid shifts.

Can employers get in hot water for not paying payroll taxes?

Employers can get in hot water for failing to withhold payroll taxes, and they could also be on the hook for other penalties if the employee files a complaint saying they weren't properly compensated. [. READ: How to Professionally Handle an Uncomfortable Situation in the Workplace.