what questions to as a lawyer for a criminal appeal case at federal level

Seek a federal appeals attorney who has experience with federal criminal appeals. Your federal appeals lawyer will need to review the court record for the case, find potential errors in the trial proceedings, and write a compelling argument as to why those errors impact the final judgment that you would like overturned.

Full Answer

What questions should I ask when hiring a criminal defense attorney?

 · Questions to Ask Criminal Appeal Lawyer: The Attorney’s Experience 5. Does your practice focus mainly or exclusively on criminal law? Many firms take cases for which they are not experts. Even if your particular attorney handles only criminal law or appeals, they won’t have the resources of an experienced team if it isn’t the firm’s main focus.

What happens during a Federal Criminal Appeal?

Federal appeals require academic rigor and fanatical attention to detail. Federal appeals are complex, multi-faceted, and require expertise, time, and considerable skill to handle. In many cases, the lawyer who handled your trial may not be the right person to handle post-conviction proceedings. Once a judgment of conviction has been received ...

How much does it cost to appeal a federal criminal case?

 · 1. Talk to your client. Does your client really want this appeal? The conviction may be reversed, affirmed, or remanded for a new trial. A new trial resets matters, but depending on the reason for a remand, a new trial could result in a better plea offer or a dismissal. 2. If you did not try the case, talk to the trial lawyer as soon as possible.

How are cases handled during an appeal?

 · #2 Question to Ask a Criminal Defense Attorney: Can I speak to your last three clients? Doesn’t that seem logical? At our company, if someone is thinking of retaining us, I’ll ask the prospect, “Would you like to speak with several recent clients?” Do your own vetting. It’s in my interest to say, “Well, I think we’re awesome and great.”

What would a federal appeals court do when considering a case?

The appellate courts do not retry cases or hear new evidence. They do not hear witnesses testify. There is no jury. Appellate courts review the procedures and the decisions in the trial court to make sure that the proceedings were fair and that the proper law was applied correctly.

What are the 3 choices for the US Court of Appeals when deciding on a case?

After reviewing the case, the appellate court can choose to:Affirm (uphold) the lower court's judgment,Reverse the lower court's judgment entirely and remand (return) the case to the lower court for a new trial, or.More items...

What are the 4 steps in the appeal process?

Step 1: File the Notice of Appeal. ... Step 2: Pay the filing fee. ... Step 3: Determine if/when additional information must be provided to the appeals court as part of opening your case. ... Step 4: Order the trial transcripts. ... Step 5: Confirm that the record has been transferred to the appellate court.More items...•

What is the most common grounds for criminal appeal?

The most common grounds for appeal of a criminal conviction are improper admission or exclusion of evidence, insufficient evidence, ineffective assistance of counsel, prosecutorial misconduct, jury misconduct and/or abuse of discretion by the judge.

What is a good sentence for appeal?

The mayor made an appeal to the people of the city to stay calm. We made a donation during the school's annual appeal. She helped to organize an appeal on behalf of the homeless. My lawyer said the court's decision wasn't correct and that we should file for an appeal.

How do you win a court appeal?

The key to winning an appeal is to plan for one from the outset of the case. Some appeals still may succeed in spite of lack of attention during the trial stage, but do not count on that. Let opposing counsel be the one surprised when the time to appeal arrives.

What is a successful appeal?

Odds of a Successful Appeal To win an appeal, you must adequately demonstrate an error of law or wrongdoing committed by the court during the trial proceedings. The appellate court typically assumes judges and legal professionals follow applicable rules and laws during a case.

What are the five basic outcomes of an appeal?

What are the possible outcomes of an appeal?Affirm the decision of the trial court, in which case the verdict at trial stands.Reverse the decision to the trial court, in which case a new trial may be ordered.Remand the case to the trial court.

What happens if you lose an appeal?

But what does it mean to lose an appeal? Losing an appeal means that the judge of the appellate court agrees with the judgment of the lower court. An appeal will only be granted if the appellate court finds that there was a legal mistake in the court trial that affected the judge's decision.

What are the levels of burden of proof?

There are three burdens of proof that exist for most cases: proof beyond a reasonable doubt, clear and convincing evidence, and preponderance of the evidence.

Under what conditions can an appeal be made from a lower court to the higher court?

In criminal cases, an appeal lies to the Supreme Court if the High Court (a) has on appeal reversed an order of acquittal of an accused person and sentenced him to death or to imprisonment for life or for a period of not less than 10 years, or (b) has withdrawn for trial before itself any case from any Court ...

Can a prosecutor appeal a not guilty verdict?

The prosecution can't appeal against a not guilty verdict when the trial was heard by a jury. If the trial was heard by a judge alone, the prosecution may be able to appeal against an acquittal, but only in very limited circumstances.

What is federal appeal?

Federal appeals are complex, multi-faceted, and require expertise, time, and considerable skill to handle. In many cases, the lawyer who handled your trial may not be the right person to handle post-conviction proceedings. Once a judgment of conviction has been received, you must act quickly to retain the right lawyer to protect your rights. If you have been convicted of a federal crime, call our team for a free and confidential consultation. No case is too hopeless to find relief.

How long does an appellant have to file a brief?

Legal Brief. Although courts have the power to shorten the time limits, the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure generally provide that an appellant has forty days after the record is filed to file his or her opening brief. Fed. R. Crim. P. 31. Failure to file the brief on time will likely result in the appeal being dismissed. The government, or appellee, has thirty days after service of the appellant’s brief to file its brief in response. The appellant then may, but is not required to, file a reply brief to the appellee’s brief within fourteen days after the appellee’s brief was filed. Id.

What is the point of an appeal?

Review of Legal Errors. While the point of a trial is to determine the facts, the point of an appeal is to see if the law has been properly applied. Thus it is often said that after a conviction, the focus shifts from the facts to the law. It is not appropriate to bring up facts on appeal that were not presented to the trial court, unless these facts are newly discovered or the appeal is based on ineffective assistance of counsel. Instead, the court of appeals will look to see if the factual evidence as presented was sufficient to sustain a conviction under the Constitution, or whether the verdict was against the manifest weight of the evidence. The court of appeals will also review claimed legal or procedural errors made in the trial court. For example, did the trial court err in allowing certain evidence to be presented to the jury? Were there pretrial motions (such as a motion to suppress evidence seized from the defendant) that were not decided correctly as a matter of law? Did the prosecution commit misconduct, such as vouching for government witnesses, improperly commenting on a defendant’s decision not to testify, or making misstatements in their closing argument? These types of arguments, as well as others that often turn on a very narrow legal point, are those that are considered and decided on a criminal appeal.

Is an appeal a new trial?

An Appeal Is Not a New Trial. For laypeople, there are many surprises about the appellate process. The most important, and most unexpected for many people, is that an appeal is not about the facts of the case, except in the broadest sense. Appellate courts do not hear from witnesses, do not take evidence, and do not re-try the case. Instead, the job of the appellate court is to review the testimony and documents presented in the trial court to discern whether or not a legal error has been committed.

How are appeals decided?

Panel of Judges. Every appeal is decided by a panel of three circuit court judges, who are randomly assigned to the appeals as they are filed . Most appeals are decided “on the briefs,” which means that oral arguments are not held for most of the appeals that are filed. However, oral argument will usually be requested in every case – it is up to the judges whether or not oral argument will be granted. Once the briefs are filed, and any oral argument ordered is held, the parties must wait for the court to rule either for or against them.

How long does it take to file a notice of appeal?

Notice of Appeal. Many people confuse the filing of the notice of appeal with filing the appeal itself and panic when they realize they only have 14 days to file. Note that the notice of appeal is a brief, one-page document that merely notifies the court of the defendant’s desire to appeal his conviction and/or sentencing, and can be prepared quickly. Nonetheless, the fourteen-day deadline means that you should retain the best appellate lawyer to represent you on appeal as soon as possible after the trial court enters the judgment of conviction, if you have not already done so. An appellate lawyer will need time to check for conflicts, review the case, and prepare and file the notice making sure that no deadline has been missed.

How long does a notice of appeal have to be filed?

Rule 4. Under the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure, the defendant’s notice of appeal must be filed within fourteen days of the entry of judgment or of the order being appealed. Fed. R. Crim. P. 4 (b). If a timely motion under Rule 29, 33, or 34 has been made, this period will be extended until 14 days after all such motions have been disposed of, or 14 days after the entry of judgment of conviction, whichever is later. Id. Notably, a judgment of conviction is not entered by a federal court until after sentencing has been announced, when the judge will enter a final order disposing of the case. Any notice of appeal filed prior to this time will be treated as if it were filed upon the entry of the judgment and commitment order. Id. Once a notice of appeal becomes effective, the trial court loses jurisdiction over the case and cannot make any more orders regarding the judgment or the sentence. The notice of appeal shifts jurisdiction to the Court of Appeals.

How to appeal a conviction?

1. Talk to your client. Does your client really want this appeal? The conviction may be reversed, affirmed, or remanded for a new trial. A new trial resets matters, but depending on the reason for a remand, a new trial could result in a better plea offer or a dismissal. 2.

What to do if the government does not file a brief in opposition?

If the government does not file a brief in opposition or has failed to adequately respond to your brief and the trial court’s error remain s obvious, file a motion for summary reversal. Though such motions are rarely granted, you should file it if the circumstances warrant. 7.

What is a federal criminal appeal?

A federal criminal appeal, or specifically a “direct appeal” is a legal proceeding in which the judgment or order of the court (usually a district court) is attacked on some legal ground or grounds. As stated above, a federal criminal appeal is not a retrial or a rehearing of the evidence received in the district court.

How long does it take to appeal a federal case?

Generally, federal criminal appeals take many months, if not a year or more. Why? The federal courts are crowded, and the process of an appeal is, by its nature, slow. The courts, for the most part, consider each case and each legal claim individually, which takes time. Technology has helped speed up parts of the process in recent years. Many courts now accept briefs electronically, and legal research is primarily performed on computer rather than in the law library.

What is the appellee's duty?

Like the appellant, the appellee is also obligated to support factual assertions with citations to the transcript or other evidence and to support legal arguments with citations to cases . Finally, in most courts, the appellant has the opportunity to file a reply brief to answer the appellee’s responsive arguments.

What is the response brief in a criminal case?

After the opening brief is filed, the responding party, called the appellee (in a criminal case the appellee is typically the government) files a responsive brief, which contains a statement of the facts (presumably objectively written as well) and answers to each argument asserted in the opening brief.

What is a brief in court?

A brief, or more specifically an opening brief or principal brief, is a written document filed by the appellant (the party appealing) that provides the court with an objective (non-argumentative, evenhanded) rendition of the facts of the case, followed by a persuasive (argumentative, subjective) argument of the specific legal errors that are alleged to have been committed in the district court. Each factual assertion in the brief must be followed by an exact citation to either the transcript of the proceedings or a piece of evidence that was admitted in court, and each legal argument must be supported by a citation to a previous case, statute, or constitution that provides authority for that argument.

What percentage of federal appellate cases were resolved without oral argument in 2007?

According to the U.S. Courts’ statistics, 74 percent of federal appellate cases nationwide were resolved without oral argument in 2007. In other words, ¾ of the cases in the federal appellate system were resolved “on the briefs.” So, the brief is likely the most important part of the appeal. But what is a brief?

What was the median time for appeals in 2007?

In 2007, the Fourth Circuit’s median time for the “life” of an appeal (from notice of appeal to decision) was 8.8 months . The slowest of the 12 federal circuits in 2007 was the Ninth Circuit, which covers California, Nevada, Washington, Oregon, Idaho and Montana, where the median time for resolution was 17.4 months. 4.

What to say when you're going through a divorce?

I don’t need them to have tons of empathy and sympathy, but you want them to care. You want them to be passionate . As a criminal defendant , I was freaked out. I was scared to death. I didn’t know what to do. If you’re going through a divorce or a civil issue, you’re suing or being sued, it’s a very big deal.

Do civil lawyers do the same thing?

A number of civil lawyers will do absolutely the same thing. It’s nice to fix and lock the fee. It’s nice to know what it’s going to cost. The downside at times to an inclusive fee is you may not feel as if they’re doing all of the work, because they’ve already been paid.

Do you have to scratch a bankruptcy check?

If you hire bankruptcy, civil, criminal, whatever type of lawyer it may be, and they say it’s 50,000, 100,000, 200,000, you don’t need to scratch them a check at once. They haven’t done any of the work.

Who is entitled to appeal a federal court decision?

Appeals. The losing party in a decision by a trial court in the federal courts normally is entitled to appeal the decision to a federal court of appeals.

How are appeals decided?

Appeals are decided by panels of three judges working together. The appellant presents legal arguments to the panel, in writing, in a document called a "brief.". In the brief, the appellant tries to persuade the judges that the trial court made an error, and that its decision should be reversed.

What is a federal administrative review?

A litigant who is not satisfied with a decision made by a federal administrative agency usually may file a petition for review of the agency decision by a court of appeals. Judicial review in cases involving certain federal agencies or programs — for example, disputes over Social Security benefits — may be obtained first in a district court rather than a court of appeals.

Does the Supreme Court hear appeals?

There are also a small number of special circumstances in which the Supreme Court is required by law to hear an appeal. Different types of cases are handled differently during an appeal.

Does the Supreme Court have to review a case?

The Supreme Court, however, does not have to grant review. The Court typically will agree to hear a case only when it involves an unusually important legal principle, or when two or more federal appellate courts have interpreted a law differently.

Can a federal court grant certiorari?

The Supreme Court, however, does not have to grant review.

Is an appeal final?

Most appeals are final. The court of appeals decision usually will be the final word in the case, unless it sends the case back to the trial court for additional proceedings, or the parties ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case.

1. Expertise

Appellate law is different. While a trial lawyer lays facts before the jury and judge, an appeal lawyer emphasizes legal errors in the trial records and presents them before the appellate judge. A trial lawyer’s talent lies in appealing to the jury, examining and cross-examining witnesses, and presenting the case.

2. Experience

An inexperienced appellate attorney won’t know what to look for when analyzing a trial record. A lawyer specializing in appellate advocacy understands the local rules related to deadlines and other specific requirements for appellate fillings.

3. Excellent Analytical Skills

A significant part of appellate law concerns analyzing and reviewing trial records to look for errors and using them when writing briefs. The lawyer must be good at understanding legal developments and exploring their implications on a current case. Explaining legal principles is an essential talent that’s useful for appellate litigation.

4. Objectivity

Appellate attorneys take an objective approach to their practice and are seldom driven by emotion. This objectivity allows them to bring a fresh perspective to the case and see the bigger picture during an appeal. Their logical thinking helps them make independent judgments about the merits and weaknesses of their client’s position.