what kind of lawyer handles hoa discrimination

by Betsy Lueilwitz 9 min read

Full Answer

What does An Hoa attorney do?

What does an HOA attorney do? Every homeowners association needs legal counsel for a sundry of issues. An HOA attorney can serve as general legal counsel when it comes to management concerns, such as disputes or accusations of discriminatory behavior.

What kind of discrimination can An Hoa do?

In addition to (perhaps inadvertently) discriminating based on disability or familial status, an HOA might discriminate based on race, national origin, gender, and religion. The law related to housing discrimination is complicated.

Do I need an attorney for my HOA board dispute?

Nevertheless, situations can arise where an HOA board member needs an expert opinion, particularly if it involves a dispute with a homeowner or allegations of unlawful behavior such as discrimination. An attorney can help decipher the language of the relevant documents and explain the HOA's obligations under state and federal law.

Who is the law firm that represents homeowners associations in California?

Sandra L. Gottlieb, Esq. is the managing partner and head of the transactional division of SwedelsonGottlieb, a law firm that exclusively represents homeowners’ association’s throughout California. Nicholas Marfori, Esq. is an associate with SwedelsonGottlieb working with its Association clients on transactional and litigation matters.

image

How do you argue against an HOA?

If you do not wish to have a hearing or are better at writing than speaking, you (or an attorney you hire to do this) can write a letter to your Board and your property management company stating why you believe the violation letter, fine or other action they want you to take is improper, arbitrary, discriminatory or ...

How do I deal with an abusive HOA?

If you have experienced HOA board harassment, here are necessary steps you need to take:Write a Letter. The first step should be to write a letter to the offending homeowner. ... Call in a Restraining Order. Some homeowners will not be stopped by a formal letter and imposed sanctions. ... Call the Police.

Can HOA discriminate based on credit score?

The Association's Decision Cannot Be Discriminatory According to the Department of Housing and Urban Development, the Act prohibits discrimination in housing based on race, religion, color, sex, age, disability, familial status, and national origin.

Who oversees HOA in Florida?

§720.302(2). The Office of the Condominium Ombudsman is a government agency established to regulate residential communities in Florida and oversee, among other things, education, complaint resolution, mediation and arbitration, and developer disclosure.

Can a HOA board of directors take down a neighborhood Facebook page?

No. But it's a way to fine someone and enforce that restriction against the homeowner in court.

How do I get around HOA rules?

Here are six ways to effectively fight with your homeowners, co-op or condo association:Know the rules. You should have read all the government documents, including the rules and regulations, before you closed on your purchase. ... Respond in writing. ... Don't argue the rule. ... Know the penalties.

Can HOA evict owner Florida?

Fortunately, Florida does allow HOAs to take action against tenants, up to and including eviction, but only in specific circumstances. There are procedures that must be followed in order for the process to be legal.

Can HOA restrict felons in Florida?

"In Florida, we have a similar law that precludes convicted felons from serving on the board unless they've had their civil rights restored for at least five years," says Lisa Magill, of counsel at Kaye, Bender & Rembaum in Pompano Beach, Fla., who advises Florida community associations.

Can HOA enter my property Florida?

Florida law gives your association the irrevocable right of access to your unit. However, this does not mean that the board can enter your at any time, for any reason.

How do I file a complaint against a HOA in Florida?

You may file a written complaint with the Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares, and Mobile Homes. To request a Condominium/Cooperative Complaint Form (PDF), you may call 1.800. 226.9101 (from within Florida only) or 850.488. 1122, or download a printable copy from this page.

How do I sue an HOA in Florida?

In most cases, homeowners cannot simply sue their HOA. Florida state law generally requires disputes involving property owners and HOAs to move forward through the dispute resolution process. Instead of beginning with traditional litigation, this generally requires the homeowner to seek a resolution through mediation.

Does Florida state law supersede HOA rules?

Let's start with that first question. The simple answer is NO. HOA rules cannot override state law.

What does an attorney do for a HOA?

Your attorney can also keep you informed of changes in the laws and give you advice on how to handle matters as they come up. HOA's have responsibilities to maintain the common areas of your community and make repairs, but they don't have the rights to infringe on your freedom and personal life.

How to resolve a dispute with a HOA?

Hire an Attorney. If you are involved in a dispute with your HOA, you should hire an HOA attorney to assist you. HOA matters can become heated and emotional, so it is best to have an experienced attorney handle the negotiations and resolve the dispute for you.

What to do if you are fined by your homeowners association?

If you have been cited, fined, want to sue your homeowners' association or your homeowners' association has filed a lawsuit against you, then you should contact a HOA attorney. While it is unpleasant to be in a dispute with your association, it is quite common. The attorney is knowledgeable about HOA dispute matters and state laws.

What is an association in a condominium?

The association is a governing body that runs your planned community or condominium building. They association has a board of directors. Residents are elected to serve in positions such as President, Secretary and Chief Financial Offer or Treasurer.

Can you sue a homeowner association without giving notice?

Although some homeowners associations have been known to file a lawsuit without giving notice to the homeowner accused of violations.

Why do HOAs hire an attorney?

HOAs at times hire an attorney to collect outstanding fees and assessments from homeowners who are not responding to the HOA's enforcement efforts. Having an attorney enforce collections increases the likelihood of success, since a lawyer will know the procedures for obtaining court judgments and liens based on nonpayment.

Who is the governing board of a HOA?

The HOA's governing board is usually made up of volunteers from within the community, who are doing their best to interpret the rules, and not always successfully. To help HOA board members with such interpretation and enforcement tasks, and to resolve legal disputes with or affecting individual homeowners, the HOA might retain an attorney.

What is the HOA written in?

In theory, the HOA's governing documents are written in plain English, so that anyone can understand their meaning. Nevertheless, situations can arise where an HOA board member needs an expert opinion, particularly if it involves a dispute with a homeowner or allegations of unlawful behavior such as discrimination.

What is a HOA in 2021?

Updated: Jun 18th, 2021. Homeowners' associations ( HOAs) exist for the benefit of residents in a condominium, townhome, or other planned community or development. This benefit can sometimes feel like an obligation, however, when the HOA enforces community rules. And the list of rules is often long!

What is the purpose of a HOA?

When an HOA is formed, a variety of legal documents must be drafted so as to comply with state law and to set guidelines for the ongoing operations and management of the community. The most important of these are the HOA's articles of corporation, bylaws, covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs), and perhaps less formal rules and regulations.

Do homeowners associations need an attorney?

If not, however, when these defects affect a development's common areas, the homeowners' association should hire an attorney to assist in taking legal action against the developer .

Does HOA pay for attorney?

If the defects concern parts of the property that you own individually, it's possible that the HOA will refuse to pay for an attorney for you, in which case you will need to hire one yourself. (Your insurance is unlikely to pay for construction defects.)

What can a lawyer do for a HOA?

An HOA lawyer can also help with making changes to the governing documents to modify everything from architectural guidelines to increase the number of board members. Amending the HOA governing documents is no small act. The process can take some time and a great deal of work.

What does a HOA attorney do?

An HOA attorney can serve as general legal counsel when it comes to management concerns , such as disputes or accusations of discriminatory behavior.

Why is a HOA attorney important?

Why an HOA Attorney Is So Important. Any organization, whether for profit or not, can benefit from the aid of an attorney. That’s why so many companies have attorneys on retainer or even hire their own corporate counsel. Attorneys protect organizations, that’s just the way it is. And a homeowners association is no different.

What happens if a HOA board is not upholding its responsibilities?

If a board is found to not be upholding these responsibilities or acting neglectfully, homeowners within the association may take legal action. The board of directors would then need legal representation, and in many cases, a lawyer they have already retained will be able to assist.

What do HOAs do?

Most HOA boards do everything they can to collect delinquent dues, including imposing late fees and even revoking privileges. If the board chooses to take further action, such as file a lawsuit or place a lien on the property, it will need the help of HOA attorneys.

What is important to know about having an attorney?

Just as important as having an attorney, though, is finding the right one. Make sure to look at credentials, testimonies, and expertise when evaluating prospects. Beyond that, ensure that the attorney you ultimately select shares the same ideals as your association and works well with your board.

Is real estate the same as HOA?

However, real estate law pertains to homeownership and disputes, not necessarily the same matters an HOA deals with. HOA governing documents function more as contracts. As such, an attorney who specializes in business or contractual law is a better option for matters involving governing documents.

What to do if your HOA is out of line?

Last Resort: Legal Action Against the HOA. If you have a major dispute and believe your HOA is out of line, you can take legal action. For example, the HOA might be asking that you take some action (or refrain from some action) that isn't officially covered in the CC&Rs.

What happens if you notify your HOA of a problem?

If you notify your HOA that you're having a problem with its rules or with another homeowner, the HOA might (depending on your state's law) be obligated to arrange for mediation or arbitration. You might then be able to work out a compromise or initiate an amendment to the rules.

Does a developer enforce HOA rules?

The property developer usually sets up the HOA and its rules, but it doesn't stick around to enforce them. The community residents, however, will later be expected to volunteer to join the HOA board and will either enforce or amend the rules (depending on procedures set forth in the community's bylaws).

Can you file a lawsuit against a HOA?

Before protesting any HOA action against you, make sure to review the CC&Rs and see whether your own actions were allowable. Because an HOA is a legal entity, you can file a lawsuit against it and ask a court to get involved. A judge can order the HOA to obey its own rules.

Can you take further action with your HOA?

Alternatively, for minor issues, you might agree to simply follow the rule. Taking further action can create a negative relationship with your HOA and fellow homeowners. You don't want to get into a downward spiral such that you feel your only option is to sell your home and move.

Can you request a hearing for an HOA?

If you're already the subject of an enforcement action, it's likely the HOA will schedule a hearing at which you can present your case. If not, read the rules for what procedures to follow to request a formal hearing or attention to your grievance. Also, asking for an exception to the rules might be possible.

What are the issues that can arise from discrimination?

Discrimination in the United States can arise in many settings and involve a wide range of issues, including: Workplace discrimination/employment law/employment discrimination. Failure to make reasonable accommodations. Failure to grant medical leave or recognize a medical condition. Wrongful termination and layoffs.

What to do if you feel discriminated against?

If you feel you were discriminated against or given unequal treatment based on race, gender (or gender identity), disability, national origin, age, sexual orientation, religion, or some other protected class, a discrimination lawyer can help. Don't wait to talk to a discrimination attorney and find out how federal law and state law can be used ...

How to file a complaint against HUD?

If you are the victim of prohibited discrimination, you may file a complaint with your state’s fair housing agency, local Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity (FHEO), or HUD three different ways: Call the HUD case managers toll-free (800) 669-9777 or TTY (800) 927-9275.

How long does it take to file a lawsuit against a homeowners association?

The lawsuit must be filed within two (2) years of the most recent date of the alleged discriminatory action at the aggrieved person's expense.

How long can an aggrieved person file a complaint with HUD?

Under 42 U.S.C. § 3610 (a), an "aggrieved person may, not later than one year after an alleged discriminatory housing practice has occurred or terminated, file a complaint with the Secretary alleging such discriminatory housing practice.". Call the HUD case managers toll-free (800) 669-9777 or TTY (800) 927-9275.

What is reasonable accommodations and modifications for people with disabilities?

Under Section 804 of the FHA and the Americans with Disabilities Act, community associations are required to allow reasonable accommodations or modifications for a person with a disability to have an equal opportunity to use and enjoy a dwelling.

What is a reasonable accommodation?

The Department of Justice provides the following definitions: Reasonable accommodation - A change, exception, or adjustment to a rule, policy, practice, or service. Reasonable modification - Structural changes to interiors and exteriors of dwellings and common and public use areas.

Does the FHA protect people who are a direct threat to the health or safety of others?

The law does not protect a person who is a direct threat to the health or safety of others or who currently uses illicit substances or illegal drugs. Additionally, because the FHA does not protect people that pose a “direct threat” to other residents, juvenile and sex offenders are exceptions to the prohibition.

Does FHA apply to all corporations?

Yes. The FHA applies to all corporations, associations, and others involved in the provision of housing and residential lending, including property owners, housing managers, homeowners, and condominium associations, lenders, real estate agents, and brokerage services. What is considered discrimination? It is against the law to discriminate ...

What is the HOA liability?

Title VIII of the Civil Rights of 1968, also known as the Fair Housing Act (“FHA”), is a federal law which prohibits discrimination in housing and housing-related services due to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability, and familial status.

Is neighbor to neighbor discrimination?

However, what action is appropriate is a fact specific question. Most neighbor-to-neighbor disputes do not really involve “discrimination,” at least not the kind of discrimination that we usually associate with Fair Housing complaints. But determining what is or is not “discrimination” is not always that easy.

Can a HOA be held liable for racial slurs?

For instance, an HOA can be held liable where its security guard utters racial slurs at black and Hispanic residents, or where a Board member requires a Muslim condo owner to leave his backpack outside before attending the annual meeting of the members.

image

Common Disputes Against Hoa's

Common Disputes by Hoa's Against Homeowners

  • The following are common HOA disputes that occur between HOA's and homeowners: 1. Failing to pay HOA dues or assessments on time 2. Not maintaining your home in accordance with the 3. Parking in authorized areas 4. Violating use and zoning ordinances 5. Ban on certain types, sizes, and number of pets Being a member of a homeowners' association isn't for everybody. So befor…
See more on realestatelawyers.com

How Association's Work?

  • The association is a governing body that runs your planned community or condominium building. They association has a board of directors. Residents are elected to serve in positions such as President, Secretary and Chief Financial Offer or Treasurer. The association's bylaws and CC&R's set forth the rules and regulations. The association documents must comply with state and loca…
See more on realestatelawyers.com

Complaints About Associations

  • People who live in communities governed by associations frequently complain about the fact that the board of directors do not follow through on comments and complaints made by the homeowners that they represent. Other big complaints are mismanagement of HOA funds and lack of enforcement of common area rules and regulations. By hiring an HOA lawyer, you have t…
See more on realestatelawyers.com

Hire An Attorney

  • If you are involved in a dispute with your HOA, you should hire an HOA attorney to assist you. HOA matters can become heated and emotional, so it is best to have an experienced attorney handle the negotiations and resolve the dispute for you. The attorney is an expert in HOA and state laws, and can explain them to you and advise of your legal right...
See more on realestatelawyers.com