The Central Park Five Case: Where the racist cops and prosecutors are now Linda Fairstein, Manhattan D.A. Sex Crimes Unit Head Elizabeth Lederer, Lead Prosecutor Tim Clements, Assistant District Attorney Eric Reynolds, NYPD Central Park Precinct Robert Morgenthau, N.Y. District Attorney Michael Sheehan, NYPD Detective
Richardson and Wise were sentenced in a separate trial to 5 to 10 years and 5 to 15 years, respectively. Wise was the only one of the group that went to adult prisons having been arrested at 16. Ironically, Galligan was also the trial judge in the murder and rape case of Reyes, whose admission overturned the conviction of the Central Park Five.
On May 8, 2002, the District Attorney’s Office was notified that Reyes’ DNA matched the DNA taken from the sock that had been found at the Central Park crime scene.” The Manhattan D.A.’s office, seeing the new evidence vacated the convictions, exonerating all five.
Credit... Elizabeth Lederer, the lead prosecutor in the Central Park jogger case, which resulted in the wrongful conviction of five black and Latino boys, said on Wednesday that she would not return as a lecturer at Columbia Law School. Her decision was the latest fallout from a recent Netflix mini-series about the case.
The prosecutor Elizabeth Lederer leaving criminal court at the lunch break, after presenting her summation in the Central Park jogger case. Credit... Nancy Siesel/The New York Times. Elizabeth Lederer, the lead prosecutor in the Central Park jogger case, which resulted in the wrongful conviction of five black and Latino boys, ...
In an email to Columbia Law students on Wednesday evening, Gillian Lester, the dean of the school, said Ms.
The boys, who came to be known as the “Central Park Five,” admitted on video to aiding in the Meili's rape, but later said their confessions were coerced by investigators who took advantage of their age. There was also no DNA evidence tying them to the scene of the crime.
According to that article, Lederer played a big role in the videotaped confessions that the boys made, which appear to show them confused and struggling to make up the story that investigators wanted , all so they could go home. She can be heard sternly asking Wise questions on his videotaped confession.
Elizabeth Lederer was the lead attorney on the prosecution team working on the Central Park jogger case in 1989; she worked to prosecute and then convict the Central Park Five, whose wrongful convictions and eventual exoneration is the topic of the new Netflix series, When They See Us.
To The New York Times at the time, Chi said, “It snowballed. It really hit a nerve.”. As The Times noted, Lederer has a lengthy legal hisory of unchallenged cases, despite the fact that she’s largely known for her involvement in the Central Park Five’s case.
Lederer is no longer discussing the case in public; she did not comment on the petition in 2013. Though Lederer has made virtually no public comments on her role in the case since the trial ended, archived articles show the trial was an emotionally charged affair, for obvious reasons.
It wasn't until 2002 that Matias Reyes, a murderer and serial rapist who was serving a life sentence for a different crime, confessed to being the actual perpetrator of the Central Park Jogger rape. DNA evidence backed up his confession, and the Central Park Five were exonerated.
And under the supervision of Linda, five black and Latino teen boys — Korey Wise, Yusef Salaam, Antron McCray, Raymond Santana, and Kevin Richardson — were interrogated until they confessed to the crime. Linda Fairstein and fellow prosecutor Elizabeth Lederer are escorted from the court during the first Central Park Jogger trial in August 1990.
In March 2020, Linda sued both Ava and Netflix for defamation over the way she was portrayed in When They See Us, claiming that the series makes her out to be a "racist, unethical villain who is determined to jail innocent children of color at any cost.". Netflix, however, has fought back.
While heading up the sex crimes unit, Linda prosecuted a number of controversial (and widely publicized) cases in Manhattan, including the so-called "Preppy Murder" case in 1986 and the later-overturned People vs. Jovanovic case in 1998.
By 2002, she had left her job at the D.A.'s office to pursue her career as an author full-time. Linda Fairstein attends the 12th Annual Authors in Kind Literary Luncheon in April 2015. Getty Images.
On the night of April 19, 1989, the body of a 28-year-old female jogger was discovered in a ravine in Central Park. The "Central Park Jogger," as she would become known, had been brutally beaten, raped, and left for dead.
Linda is played by Felicity Huffman in the series and, as the woman who supervised the interrogation and trial of the five boys, ...
Following their clear exoneration, the Central Park Five filed a civil lawsuit against the City of New York for, among other things, malicious and wrongful prosecution. For more than a decade, the New York officials refused to settle the claim.
In the immediate aftermath of the crime, officers from the New York City Police Department (NYPD) put the focus on six African American and Hispanic American teenagers: Antron McCray, Kevin Richardson, Yusef Salaam, Raymond Santana, and Korey Wise.
In the Spring of 1989, Trisha Meili, a 28-year-old woman, was jogging in a secluded area of the park. Around 9:30 PM, she was assaulted and raped — suffering severe injuries that left her comatose for nearly two weeks.
Raymond Santana, Yusef Salaam and Kevin Richardson (l-r) three of the five men wrongfully convicted of raping a woman in Central Park in 1989, settled with New York City for approximately $40 million dollars (Photo by Andrew Burton/Getty Images)
In Chicago, they started putting public defenders in police precincts for this very reason because that’s where violations of constitutional rights begins.
There was a rush to find out who committed this crime because of the media attention, but the political climate always plays a significant role in how they choose to proceed with a case.
Korey Wise , Antron McCray, Kevin Richardson, Raymond Santana, and Yusef Salaam ( L-R). (Photo by D Dipa supil/Getty Images) The team of prosecutors had the ability to stop this thing in its tracks. There were many instances where it should have been clear they were barking up the wrong tree.
Nonetheless, collectively everyone believes the prosecuting team bears some responsibility for overzealously pursuing the conviction they ultimately were granted, but pursued at the cost of true justice. Here’s what they had to say.
“The key lesson here is that when you’re dealing with children as defendants, you can’t interrogate them them as you would adults. Young people will lie if they are afraid or forced. Prosecutors should know that.”—
Williams noted the recent release of the Netflix miniseries “When They See Us” in his letter to Vance, calling it a “new opportunity to seek justice.”
The release of “When They See Us” has sparked widespread backlash against both Fairstein and Lederer.
Wise was the only one of the group that went to adult prisons having been arrested at 16. Ironically, Galligan was also the trial judge in the murder and rape case of Reyes, whose admission overturned the conviction of the Central Park Five.
Once evidence surfaced exonerating the Central Park Five, Fairstein railed against the development. She maintained that although the DNA may have made Reyes the main culprit, the teens were participants and their confessions (which they maintained were coerced) proved it.
Clements left the Manhattan D.A.’s office in 1991 and hasn’t been able to speak about the Central Park Five because he was advised not to as their civil suit moved forward. The outcome of which was a $41 million settlement with New York City, which he vehemently disagrees with.
WHAT HE DID: No surprise here that former NYPD Det. Michael Sheehan believes the investigation was handled correctly by experienced detectives. However, he also agrees with the others that Reyes’ confession turned the entire case on its head despite the work done by the department to place the five teens at the scene of the crime and that their own words should have prevented their full exoneration.
She assigned Elizabeth Lederer to the Central Park Jogger case almost immediately (replacing assistant district attorney Nancy Ryan ) and assembled a team determined to respond to a fear-based citywide demand to get a handle on youth crime.
WHAT HE DID: In his tenure as Manhattan D.A., from 1975 to 2009, Robert Morgenthau had seen some of the nation’s most high-profile cases ranging from the murder of John Lennon to “subway vigilante” Bernard Goetz to the Tupac Shakur sexual abuse case.
In a turn of events, Ryan still became a determining factor in exonerating the Central Park Five. When Matias Reyes confessed that he and he alone was responsible for what happened to Meili, it sent Morganthau’s office in a new direction to see if this had in fact been a master class in railroading.