1. You write your motion 2. You file your motion with the court clerk 3. The court clerk inserts the date and time your motion will be heard by the judge
Full Answer
In some jurisdictions, the trial judge can order a new trial without a defendant asking. If the judge denies a motion for a new trial, the defendant can file an appeal asking a higher court to overrule the trial judge. The prosecution cannot make a motion for a new trial because the principle of double jeopardy applies upon an acquittal. But in some instances the prosecution can appeal a …
For example, California requires that you first file a notice of intent of move for a new trial within 15 days of notice of entry of judgment in the case. After you file your notice, you have up to 10 days ...
If the judge denies your motion for a new trial, you may still have other options available to challenge the trial court's judgment, such as filing an appeal. You may be able to assert similar arguments on appeal that you asserted in your motion for a new trial.
If any of the reasons you've listed include reference to facts outside the trial itself, you must get affidavits from witnesses attesting to those facts. For example, one of the grounds for which a trial court may order a new trial is improper conduct by counsel or jury misconduct. [12]
Create your caption. The caption of your motion should be identical to all other documents filed in the case. If you want to request a hearing on your motion, you typically must include a statement such as "oral argument requested" or "hearing requested" in your caption, below the case number.
If forms were not available, you should check with the clerk to find out if you have to request a hearing. Keep in mind that the parties don't change when you file a motion for a new trial. If you were a defendant in the original trial, you will still be listed in the motion's caption as the defendant.
If you cannot find a fill-in-the-blank form, you may want to ask the clerk for other new trial motions that were filed in the same court. You can use those motions as guides to craft your own, although you should be careful about copying the language in them verbatim.
State rules often list specific grounds for which a motion for a new trial may be granted. To properly review what happened at trial and reference it in your motion, you may need to request a trial transcript. You will be charged a fee for the transcript.
How It Works. Defendants typically make motions for new trials after guilty verdicts. In some jurisdictions, the trial judge can order a new trial without a defendant asking. If the judge denies a motion for a new trial, the defendant can file an appeal asking a higher court to overrule the trial judge. The prosecution cannot make a motion ...
Courts may also grant new trial motions when certain kinds of new evidence have been discovered after conviction. But small, slightly helpful facts aren't enough. The new evidence generally must:
In short, new trial grants generally require that some kind of error prevented the defendant from receiving a fair trial.
After a criminal trial ends in a conviction, the defendant can file a motion for a new trial. Courts grant these—though rarely—to correct significant errors that happened during trial or if substantial new evidence of innocence comes to light. A court may also grant a motion for a new trial if there has been a "miscarriage of justice.".
An example is a judge having wrongly excluded evidence that would have made a difference to the outcome of the trial. An erroneous exclusion of evidence might occur if a judge ruled that certain testimony should be excluded because of the hearsay rule, but the ruling was erroneous because an exception to the rule applied.
A judge may also order a new trial if doing so could fix an injustice associated with the first trial. For example, in a 2013 federal case, a judge granted a motion for a new trial for two Mexican restaurant owners who had been convicted of harboring undocumented aliens for profit.
The prosecution cannot make a motion for a new trial because the principle of double jeopardy applies upon an acquittal. But in some instances the prosecution can appeal a trial judge's grant of a new trial, and it can usually appeal a new trial order by an appellate court.