ethically how does a criminal defense lawyer use ethics

by Prof. Beth Stoltenberg II 10 min read

Just like law enforcement officers, criminal defense attorneys and prosecutors must comply with their profession’s ethical standards. Prosecutors, for example, must display the following behaviors: Ensure that the accused has been advised of his or her rights and has had a reasonable opportunity to secure counsel.

The defense lawyer's duty to represent the defendant's interests is balanced by his duty to act in an ethical and professional manner. The defense lawyer must not intentionally misrepresent matters of facts or law to the court.Sep 26, 2012

Full Answer

What are the ethical obligations of a defense attorney?

What are the ethical obligations of a defense attorney? The defense lawyer has a duty to provide effective representation to the defendant at all times….Lawyers Duties to Client The defense lawyer serves as the defendant’s counselor and advocate and should strive to render effective, quality, representation. The defense lawyer should strive to avoid conflicts of ]

What are the requirements for a criminal defense lawyer?

Like all attorneys, criminal defense attorneys must:

  • Earn a bachelor's degree
  • Complete three years of law school, specializing in criminal defense
  • Take the state bar exam

Who is the best criminal defense lawyer?

Top 7 Best US Criminal Defense Lawyer In The World.

  1. M.Gerald Schwartzbach. In the list of Top 7 Best US Criminal Defense Lawyer In The World, M. ...
  2. Mark Geragos. In the list of Top 7 Best US Criminal Defense Lawyer In The World Mark Geragos is at no 2. ...
  3. Alan Dershowitz. In the list of Top 7 Best US Criminal Defense Lawyer In The World Alan Dershowitz is at no 3. ...
  4. Gloria Allred. ...
  5. Leslie Abramson. ...
  6. Anne Bremner. ...
  7. F. ...

What is the job description of a criminal lawyer?

The following tasks are characteristic of a criminal lawyer’s occupation:

  • Interviewing witnesses
  • Performing legal research
  • Creating exhibits for demonstrations in court
  • Accruing additional evidence in support of their case or for arguments against the prosecution’s charges
  • Examining the crime scene
  • Gathering expert witnesses to testify in court

How is ethics used as a lawyer?

Attorney ethics describe a set of state codes and rules the regulates the conduct of lawyers. These codes ensure lawyers follow the law, pursue justice, and zealously advocate their client's best interests.

What are the ethical duties of a defense attorney?

The primary duties that defense counsel owe to their clients, to the administration of justice, and as officers of the court, are to serve as their clients' counselor and advocate with courage and devotion; to ensure that constitutional and other legal rights of their clients are protected; and to render effective, ...

Why is ethics important to the defense of criminal defendants?

Ethics are actually the very foundation of the criminal justice system. They're what helped us, as a society, develop the moral reasoning we use, define criminal activity, and deem acceptable as punishment.

What are ethics best defined as?

ethics, also called moral philosophy, the discipline concerned with what is morally good and bad and morally right and wrong. The term is also applied to any system or theory of moral values or principles.

What is the role of defence lawyer in criminal justice system?

A criminal defence attorney is responsible for putting together an effective defence and developing a winning strategy for their clients. As the accused's advocate and drafter, he must prepare, file, and argue on their behalf. Negotiating a plea bargain with the prosecution is part of a lawyer's job description.

What is an example of ethics in criminal justice?

Common ethical issues in criminal justice include ensuring impartiality, avoiding profiling, protecting citizens' rights, determining a necessary amount of force to use to restrain arrested suspects, and ensuring that public servants maintain a principled lifestyle outside of work.

What are ethics in criminal justice?

Ethics can be defined as a system of moral values that distinguish rules for behavior based on an individual's or groups' ideas of what is good and bad. Police ethics are the rules for behavior that guide law enforcement officials based on what society deems as right and wrong.

What is the importance of ethics in law enforcement?

Importance of Ethics in Law Enforcement Ethics in Law Enforcement is extremely important. The public puts their trust in to law enforcement agencies to be able to perform their jobs in a responsible, ethical and effective way. This is essential to effective crime control and policing communities.

How long was Glenn Ford on death row?

The innocent man in question, Glenn Ford, spent three decades on death row before being released after his conviction was quashed. To make matters worse, after being released, Ford was diagnosed with terminal cancer and was denied compensation for his time in prison.

What percentage of lawyers prefer to make decisions based on detached objectivity?

They concluded that 78% of lawyers (link) prefer to make decisions based on detached objectivity rather than taking into account personal feelings or values. This might seem the most reasonable approach to take to ensure a fair and effective justice system. After all, everybody is entitled to receive a fair trial.

Did Stroud provide evidence to the defense?

In the original case, Stroud failed to provide evidence to the defense that would have helped Ford’s case. Stroud now says that he was more interested in winning than justice. Stroud has since apologized and intimated that he feels haunted by his part in Ford’s conviction.

Do lawyers have barriers to representing themselves?

In many cases, there are no barriers to stop people representing themselves when, for example, a lawyer knows beyond a shadow of a doubt that they are guilty of a crime. This raises some interesting ethical questions for defense lawyers: Does representing somebody a lawyer suspects to be guilty of horrific crimes raise any ethical difficulties ...

Can a lawyer defend a person they believe to be guilty?

And recusing oneself from a case in which a defense lawyer no longer believes they can defend a person they believe to be guilty may be, depending on how one looks at the result, simply pushing the problem on to the shoulders of another defense lawyer.

Can a lawyer suspect a defendant is guilty of mass murder?

There are certain cases that hit you on a human level. But we’re trained to shake it off and deal with it clinically and unemotionally.”. A lawyer might strongly suspect that a defendant is guilty of premeditated mass murder, for example, but they are obligated to help the accused and not their potential victims.

Is everyone entitled to a fair trial?

After all, everybody is entitled to receive a fair trial . There are many heroic defense lawyers out there doing tremendous work; there will be many ethical and unethical prosecutors as well. Take, for example, Marty Stroud, who prosecuted an innocent black man in the 1980s and sought the death penalty for him too.

Attorney-client privilege

This is where the thorniest ethical issues can start. Communication between the defense lawyer and the accused is guaranteed confidentiality. The lawyer can’t reveal any information communicated; the court can’t demand its release. That includes even a private admission by the defendant that yes, they are guilty as charged.

Who to defend?

Attorney-client privilege is pretty cut-and-dried. What’s less black and white is the decision to take a particular case to begin with. After all, just because a gunman who opened fire on a school bus full of children is entitled to a fair trial, doesn’t mean they’re entitled to representation by a specific defense attorney.

A zealous defense

That brings us to the final obligation of the defense attorney (or any lawyer for that matter): to zealously represent the interests of their client.

A necessary role

The rights to a free and fair trial are superficial if not accompanied by a defense attorney who is competent and zealously fights for their clients. Though, the general public can be skeptical of this in high-profile cases.

Why was Jeffrey Feldman disbarred?

A few years ago, Fox TV commentator Bill O’Reilly led a campaign to get California criminal lawyer Jeffrey Feldman disbarred because leaked plea bargaining sessions showed that he knew his client, child killer David Westerfield, was guilty of murder while Feldman was vigorously disputing his guilt in court. O’Reilly pronounced Feldman a liar.

What was Feldman's ethical duty?

Feldman was meeting his ethical duty to point out to the jury that the prosecution’s argument was not as conclusive as it claimed. Again, his job was to make the prosecution prove its case. Feldman did his job, and the prosecution and jury did theirs: David Westerfield was convicted.

Why do defense lawyers set out to convince themselves of a defendant's innocence?

And many defense lawyers set out to convince themselves of a defendant’s innocence, no matter how unlikely, because such a mindset helps them make sure that they won’t subconsciously do a sub-par job out of sympathy for the victims or revulsion for their client.

What is the ideal of keeping the government honest?

Achieving this ideal means keeping the government honest: no convictions based on false or planted evidence, unreliable or lying witnesses, or confessions extracted from the accused by torture, beatings, or other forms of duress even if the accused is, in fact guilty. All that is essential for the system to work.

Is the Simpson trial a fault?

Arguably every componant of the Simpson trial except the defense performed badly, and some aspects of the trial might support arguments for reform, but the failings of the rest are not the fault or the responsibility of Simpson’s defense attorneys.

Do defense attorneys get satisfaction when they see their clients go free?

It doesn’t produce satisfaction or joy when defense attorneys see their guilty criminal clients go free, guaranteed by the Constitutional prohibition against “double jeopardy” never to have to suffer punishment for terrible crimes.

Attorney-Client Privilege

Image
This is where the thorniest ethical issues can start. Communication between the defense lawyer and the accused is guaranteed confidentiality. The lawyer can’t reveal any information communicated; the court can’t demand its release. That includes even a private admission by the defendant that yes, they are guilty as ch…
See more on lawteryx.com

Who to Defend?

  • Attorney-client privilege is pretty cut-and-dried. What’s less black and white is the decision to take a particular case to begin with. After all, just because a gunman who opened fire on a school bus full of children is entitled to a fair trial, doesn’t mean they’re entitled to representation by a specific defense attorney. Unless a lawyer is a public defender, they can pick and choose their clients. W…
See more on lawteryx.com

A Zealous Defense

  • That brings us to the final obligation of the defense attorney (or any lawyer for that matter): to zealously represent the interests of their client. This often means doing unpopular things. The aggressive questioning of a murder victim’s family member on their alibi for the night of the crime is going to go over poorly in the court of public opinion. But a rigorous defense of the accused m…
See more on lawteryx.com

A Necessary Role

  • The rights to a free and fair trial are superficial if not accompanied by a defense attorney who is competent and zealously fights for their clients. Though, the general public can be skeptical of this in high-profile cases. Admittedly, hearing a defense lawyer solemnly intone about their duty to the system can seem empty when you hear reports about the huge fees they make for their servi…
See more on lawteryx.com