as lawyer, what to do with diminished capacity clients

Regarding a lawyer’s duty of competence when a client shows signs of diminished capacity, the lawyer may be required to make judgments concerning the client’s capacity or consult with a more qualified lawyer to make that determination.

Full Answer

How do attorneys represent a client with diminished capacity?

Attorneys representing a client with diminished capacity should constantly evaluate whether the client is capable of acting in his or her own interest, and adjust representation accordingly. We are in a position to help people who trust us and seek us out for advice regardless of a particular client’s mental or physical state.

Is diminished capacity legal malpractice?

Legal malpractice on capacity questions has become a frequent result of not properly recognizing a diminished capacity client. A client with sporadic diminution of capacity can still have “sound mind” for testamentary or other actions during lucid periods.

How to determine if a client lacks capacity to perform tasks?

Determining whether the client lacks capacity to perform a task, typically involves assessing whether the client is able to effectively communicate and understand the decision and its consequences. When questions of capacity arise, the attorney must properly assess and document the client’s capacity.

What is a lawyer’s responsibility to a disabled client?

One bar has explained that an attorney for a disabled client will be held to a higher standard of responsibility: “As the difficulty of the situation increases, so too does the lawyer’s responsibility.

What ethical issues arise when a client has diminished capacity?

What is a client lawyer relationship?

What is the presumption of a lawyer?

Can an attorney reveal confidential information?

Do attorneys have to be licensed?

Can a client with diminished capacity give informed consent?

See more

About this website

When may an attorney reveal information normally protected by Rule 1.6 when the client may have diminished mental capacity?

For example, raising the question of diminished capacity could, in some circumstances, lead to proceedings for involuntary commitment. Information relating to the representation is protected by Rule 1.6. Therefore, unless authorized to do so, the lawyer may not disclose such information.

What is it called when a lawyer drops a client?

Withdrawal from representation, in United States law, occurs where an attorney terminates a relationship of representing a client.

Who has diminished capacity?

Penal 125.15(1). The diminished capacity plea is based in the belief that certain people, because of mental impairment or disease, are simply incapable of reaching the mental state required to commit a particular crime.

What happens if a lawyer loses a case?

If the attorney loses the case, the client is still responsible for legal fees as stipulated in the original retainer contract. Some attorneys may agree to withhold billing until the end of a case, but they will still expect payment regardless of how the case ends.

Why do lawyers drop clients?

Lawyers can withdraw based on the fact their client refuses to be truthful, refuses to follow the attorney's advice, demands to pursue an unethical course of action, demands unrealistic results, desires to mislead the Court, refuses to cooperate with their counsel as well as countless other reasons.

How do you calculate diminished capacity?

Under California Probate Code section 811, the contestant must prove a material functional impairment by offering evidence of a mental function deficit that “significantly impairs the person's ability to understand and appreciate the consequences of his or her actions with regard to the type of act or decision in ...

What kind of defense is diminished capacity?

In criminal law, diminished responsibility (or diminished capacity) is a potential defense by excuse by which defendants argue that although they broke the law, they should not be held fully criminally liable for doing so, as their mental functions were "diminished" or impaired.

How is diminished responsibility determined?

“Diminished responsibility” is a defence to murder. The burden of proof is on the defendant to show that is more likely than not that he suffered from such abnormality of the mind that, having unlawfully killed another person, his conviction ought to be for manslaughter as opposed to murder.

Can a mentally incapacitated person enter into a lending or ... - Avvo

I don't disagree with Lu Ann Trevino's answer, but a few additional points occur to me. It's important for any lawyer advising you to know the exact status of the mentally handicapped individual.

Rule 1.14 Client With Diminished Capacity - Comment

The normal client-lawyer relationship is based on the assumption that the client, when properly advised and assisted, is capable of making decisions about important matters. When the client is a minor or suffers from a diminished mental capacity, however, maintaining the ordinary client-lawyer relationship may not be possible

If a person with Dementia/Vascular dementia be deposed? If…

If a person with Dementia/Vascular dementia be deposed? If the plaintiff request his Person which has the Full Power of - Answered by a verified Lawyer

Deposing persons w/mental illness & are medicated during deposition ...

I don't know what your interest is in this case. Yes, a person with illnesses can be deposed and if the person is not of sound mind then that person's attorney could/should make some type of objection as to the use and admissibility of the deposition.

Deposing An Incapacitated Person - Law Office of David M. Garten, Esq.

LAW OFFICE OF DAVID M. GARTEN, ESQ. 400 Columbia Drive, Suite 100 West Palm Beach, FL 33409 Phone: 561-689-0054 Fax: 561-687-8103

What happens after an attorney meets with a client?

After the initial meeting with a client, an attorney may not meet with that client again for some time. Clients face many obstacles in the time between these meetings. Often, aging clients begin to struggle with mental faculties over time. A once-competent client may no longer have the requisite level of capacity to modify or begin new legal tasks after years since the last interaction between client and attorney. The prospect of a potential elder-client poses additional concerns. Unlike with existing clients, the attorney works to establish competency without the baseline of that of someone they have worked with over time.

What is the common theme between requisite capacity and various legal tasks?

A common theme between requisite capacity and various legal tasks is twofold: the client’s ability to understand the task, and their ability to appreciate the consequences of the actions taken. Many red flags can be identified through the typical series of interactions with the client.

What can elder law attorneys do to protect themselves?

There are steps that elder law and estate planning attorneys can take to protect themselves – and the client – when concerns of diminished capacity arise. The bottom line is that a diligent attorney will use common sense and established rules of assessments and conduct to decide whether their client is cognizant enough to utilize their services, ...

Why is it important to keep doctor's opinions?

Retaining doctor’s opinions on capacity, meeting notes, and even video records of meetings are helpful in establishing the reasonable belief that a client is capable of executing their own wishes.

What is the comment 4 of the Model Rules?

When the client has been appointed a representative, comment 4 of the Model Rules states that the lawyer should look to that representative for direction.

When is a lawyer required to seek out the aid of others?

Second, if diminished capacity is reasonably certain , the lawyer is permitted, but not required, to seek out the aid of others, or seek appointment of a guardian, to protect the client and their interests. Third, the lawyer is protected by Rule 1.6 when taking reasonable action to seek out others for the protection of that client.

Can a client have donative capacity?

A client may have the capacity to enter into a contract, but not donative capacity. Capacity thresholds are different for amending a trust versus making informed health care decisions. Check your state’s specific rules for the particular tasks the client seeks to accomplish.

What should an attorney consider when determining if a client has a mental illness?

Once an attorney determines whether a client has a mental illness and takes the proper legal precautions, the attorney should also consider his or her behavior toward the client as the representation continues. For any client, effective representation goes far beyond the bare minimum legal and ethical requirements.

What happens if a client cannot act in his or her own interest?

If the client cannot act in his or her own interest, then an attorney “may take reasonably necessary protective action, including consulting with individuals or entities that have the ability to take action to protect the client and, in appropriate cases, seeking the appointment of guardian ad litem, conservator or guardian.”

What is the ABA model rule of professional conduct?

For lawyers in this position, they need to know ABA Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.14, which addresses client-lawyer relationships where the client suffers from a mental illness or diminished capacity. Rule 1.14, a version of which has been adopted in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, states, “the lawyer shall, as far as reasonably possible, maintain a normal client-lawyer relationship with the client.”

Why is it not a good idea to seek a guardian?

A lawyer is not to seek a guardian for a client because the client displays bad judgment, makes imprudent choices, or disagrees with the attorney’s assessment of his or her best interest.

Can a lawyer be a guardian?

The ethics rules adopted in most states provide that a lawyer may seek a guardian for a client under a disability, “or take other protective action with respect to a client, only when the lawyer reasonably believes that the client cannot adequately act in the client’s own interest.”. Model Rule 1.14 (b).

Do attorneys have to be aware of mental health?

Attorneys should be aware of mental health symptoms to spot a mental illness when representation commences. This, again, may be easier said than done. After all, most attorneys are not trained in mental health assessment. And the younger or less experienced the attorney, the more difficult it can be for the attorney to determine if their client is suffering from a mental illness that affects their capacity to such a degree that the client is unable to understand the lawyer’s advice or make informed decisions.

Is mental capacity easy to assess?

Capacity is not easy to assess. Capacity can be temporary, situational, reversible, and task specific. Legal mental capacity is different from mental or physical capacity. Cal. Prob. Code §§ 810 (b) and 811 (d) (Deering 2017). A client with dementia or Alzheimer’s disease may still have sufficient legal mental capacity depending upon the severity of the client’s mental state and the nature of the proposed services. In general, lawyers are not trained to ascertain mental capacity and there is no single indicator of diminished legal mental capacity. Accordingly, a lawyer’s awareness of capacity issues, and the ability to spot red flags, can assist a lawyer to better help, or decline to help, a prospective client, while protecting his or her law practice from claims of negligence by third party conservators or beneficiaries.

Does a lawyer have a duty to beneficiaries under a will?

To date, the courts have been reluctant to determine liability because of the lack of privity of contract, thereby holding that the lawyer does not have a duty to beneficiaries under a will to determine the testamentary capacity of a client seeking to amend an estate plan. Moore v. Anderson, 109 Cal. App. 4th 1287, 1298 (2003). However, the principle of privity has been eroding over the years.

What ethical issues arise when a client has diminished capacity?

The ethical issue of representing a client with diminished capacity frequently arises in estate and probate practice. Oftentimes, an adult child will bring a parent to an attorney’s office to prepare and execute estate plan documents, because the parent has recently been diagnosed with dementia or “is not doing well.” These are the last-minute preparers. Sometimes the parent has an estate plan, but now the adult child brings the parent into the attorney’s office to make changes. Beside the obvious question of undue influence, there is the question of capacity to execute legal documents. Finally, there are the parents with an estate plan appointing an adult child or children to act as personal representatives of the parents and their estates, and other family members raise claims of mismanagement or abuses of power against the representative. The attorney faced with these situations must ask herself whether the client lacks capacity to make any legal decisions, whether the attorney may represent or continue to represent the client, and/or whether the attorney is authorized to notify others of the client’s risk of harm.

What is a client lawyer relationship?

The “normal client-lawyer relationship” involves communicating with the client, informing the client of the progress of his or her case, and maintaining the client’s confidences. How is the attorney to continue representation with a client who cannot effectively communicate with the attorney and/or is unable to understand ...

What is the presumption of a lawyer?

The basic presumption is that a person is of sound mind and, therefore, legally competent to make his or her own decisions, which includes the capacity to execute legal documents. Depending on the circumstance, the attorney must review the applicable capacity standards when representing a client. For instance, if the client is brought to ...

Can an attorney reveal confidential information?

Otherwise, the attorney may not reveal any confidential information, without the client’s informed written consent. Usually, a client with diminished capacity could not give such informed consent.

Do attorneys have to be licensed?

Although attorneys are not typically licensed physicians, the criteria set forth in the code provide the basic framework for the attorney to assess the client’s capacity. Similarly, the American Bar Association, in conjunction with the American Psychological Association, has published a handbook for attorneys to refer to when making similar ...

Can a client with diminished capacity give informed consent?

Usually, a client with diminished capacity could not give such informed consent. Thus, the California attorney may have violated her ethical duties if a report is made to third parties, even if the report is made for the client’s protection. The important thing for all attorneys representing clients with diminished capacity to remember is ...