why would a lawyer want you to disclose the limits of your insurance

by Devin Prosacco 8 min read

A demand for policy limits information often occurs shortly after an accident or "occurrence" in which someone suffers harm, blames another, and seeks compensation. Usually, an attorney or public adjuster contacts the insurance company asking for policy limits. Persons experienced at the process ask for all policies, including umbrella and excess.

To disclose insurance policy limits
First and foremost, it may prevent the entire litigation process — saving you time and money. Likewise, because your insurance policy limit is an essential component of evaluating a personal injury case, disclosing the limit facilitates productive settlement discussions.
Oct 12, 2021

Full Answer

Can my insurance company disclose my policy limits to my attorney?

Feb 18, 2013 · It is in your interest to disclose your policy limits. Your insurance company is obligated to attempt to settle the claim within the policy limits to protect you from an excess judgment. Disclosure of the policy limits does not mean that your insurance company will pay the limits to settle the claim but it may prevent you from being sued.

How do I get policy limits from the insurance company?

The short answer to the question of when/how a liability insurance carrier operating in California must disclose policy limits information to a claimant pre-litigation is that whenever a California claimant makes a pre-litigation request for policy limits information, a carrier must make a prompt written inquiry to its California insured whether or not to release policy limits information.

What happens if an insurer refuses to settle a claim?

Why didn't Amex consult the insured before determining policy limits?

image

What is a policy limits settlement?

The policy limit caps how much compensation or benefits an insurance company will pay in the event of a claim payout. For example, if you get into a car accident and have a $1 million policy limit, then they will only pay that much for you damages (property damage, lost wages, hospital bills, etc.)Nov 29, 2021

When referring to insurance what does limits mean?

A limit is the highest amount your insurer will pay for a claim that your insurance policy covers. Think of it this way: It's like filling up a fishbowl. If you file a covered claim, your insurance policy will pay up to a certain amount. You're responsible for any expenses that exceed the limit.

Are insurance policies confidential?

For example, in California, the terms of an insurance policy are confidential and proprietary between the insurer and insured.

What is the reason for insurer limitations on coverage amounts?

In order to keep costs reasonable, your insurance company will set insurance limits of liability. The coverage limit by definition is the maximum amount that the insurance company will pay out for a single incident or claim. In general, higher limits will result in a more expensive policy.May 8, 2018

What is a claim limit?

The claim limit is the maximum amount that your GAP Insurance will pay in the event of a valid claim.

How is policy limit determined?

If your business has a covered loss, your insurer will cap how much it will pay to settle your claim. These caps are known as policy limits (or limit of liability). Their size depends on how much insurance you decided to purchase.

What does a policy holder have to disclose to an insurance company?

the law requires disclosure in the financial statements or annual reports of payment by the policyholder of a premium in respect of a contract insuring persons against a liability; we consent in writing to disclosure of the existence and/or terms of this policy; or. the insured is compelled by order of a court to do so ...Feb 4, 2021

When must a disclosure take place in insurance?

Before your policy is placed, at renewal, and when varying or extending the policy, you have a duty under the Insurance Act 2015 to make a “fair presentation” of the risk and you must disclose to your insurer all information, facts, and circumstances which are, or ought to be, known to you and which are material to the ...

What is a confidential guarantor?

Guarantor Confidential Information means information solely and directly about Guarantor or any of its Affiliates (other than the Acquired Companies) received by Purchaser or any of its Affiliates that is not otherwise related to, connected with, or arising out of the transactions contemplated hereby, the Acquired ...

How do insurance companies determine how much you should pay for your insurance coverage?

Some common factors insurance companies evaluate when calculating your insurance premiums is your age, medical history, life history, and credit score. Insurance companies also hire actuaries or statisticians to get a better idea of the number of insurance premiums they should charge a particular client.

David B Pittman

The requirement of having disclose coverage is governed by state statute. You should consult a lawyer in your area to see if you need to.

Charles A. Donahue

The injured party is going to get it one way or the other. I'm from the school it is fine to give the other side what they'll get down the road any way. The case is worth what it's worth no matter how big or small your policy is. Ask your insurance company and/or lawyer what the pros and cons of doing so.

David Lee Fiol

Keep in mind that most if not all of the attorneys who answer questions on this web site represent plaintiffs, so our answers will be influenced by our background. Also, focus on the answers from California lawyers - out of state attorneys will not be familiar with our laws. All that said, as my colleague Mr.

Lars A. Lundeen

I would recommend disclosing your policy limits. Many states, such as Florida and Vermont, require disclosure by statute. Refusing to disclose may only encourage the plaintiff to file suit against you.

Donald Steven Sjaarda

It is in your interest to disclose your policy limits. Your insurance company is obligated to attempt to settle the claim within the policy limits to protect you from an excess judgment. Disclosure of the policy limits does not mean that your insurance company will pay the limits to settle the claim but it may prevent you from being sued.

Charles William Franklin

Whether or not your insurance company is required to disclose coverage (s) is generally governed by state law. If you are served with a lawsuit immediately contact your insurance carrier as in every state of the Union, insurance companies are required to hire attorneys to defend their policyholders.

Kevin Coluccio

I handle claims only on behalf of injured persons. I always require the disclosure of limits prior to settling a claim. Frankly, I don't think disclosing the amount is a disadvantage to the policy holder, but, my viewpoint is based upon my practice.

SUMMARY & ANALYSIS

In Aguilar v. Gostischef (2013) 220 Cal.App.4th 475, and in Reid v.

CONCLUSION

Depending on the circumstances presented, liability insurers operating in California should carefully review any existing policy of not revealing the amount of policy limits in response to a claimant’s pre-litigation request for that information.

image

Why Insurers Need to Be Careful Responding to Policy Limits Requests

Image
A demand for policy limits information often occurs shortly after anaccident or "occurrence" in which someone suffers harm, blamesanother, and seeks compensation. Usually, an attorney or public adjustercontacts the insurance company asking for policy limits. Persons experienced atthe process ask for all p…
See more on irmi.com

Policy Limits Demands and Settlement Demands

  • A demand for policy limits is not a settlement demand; rather, it is whatthe plaintiff asserts she must have to settle a case. If the settlement demandis within policy limits, the insurer rejects the demand, litigates the case,experiences a judgment in excess of policy limits but refuses to indemnify itsown insured for the full judgment, the insurer invites a lawsuit for bad faithrefusal t…
See more on irmi.com

Powell v. Prudential

  • First, in Powell, an auto insured by Prudential and driven byPowell's daughter struck two pedestrians, one of whom was seriouslyinjured. Shortly after the accident, the victim's attorney sent a letter toPrudential asking for policy limits. Getting no response, he sent a secondletter, certified this time, and informing Prudential: Prudential did not respond, so the attorney sent a th…
See more on irmi.com

Boicourt v. Amex

  • In Boicourt, decided 9 years later, following an accident, aninjured passenger in a vehicle sought policy limits information from theinsurer, Amex. Despite a California law requiring an insurer to contact theinsured and get permission to disclose policy limits when demanded by aclaimant, Amex never consulted its insured during three attempts over a 5-monthperiod by the injured part…
See more on irmi.com

Lessons Learned

  • Insurers deal with policy demands and other aspects of claim administrationdaily. This day-to-day experience teaches that many claimants cannot affordattorneys to litigate on their behalf to force disclosure of the information;consequently, their claims may settle for substantially less than their truevalue, thereby benefiting the insurer. On the other hand, some claimants whocan afford it m…
See more on irmi.com

Conclusion

  • An insurer's failure to reveal policy limits at the pre-litigation stagecan serve as a basis for bad faith actions. Moreover, while insurers maygenerally anticipate such actions from third parties, and since failure todisclose policy limits may be construed as resolving a conflict of interestfavoring the insurance company's economic interests over those of itspolicyholders, an i…
See more on irmi.com