why would a lawyer not file a lawsuit but serve papers

by Ms. Candice Nikolaus 9 min read

The best reason to not pursue a strategy of avoiding being served with legal documents is that it can cause you to forfeit your legal rights, creating consequences potentially much worse than the lawsuits themselves.

This is called service of process, and no lawsuit is complete without it. The reason you must serve the other side is obvious: Defendants in a case need to know about any claims against them and must be notified of the day, time, and place that they can show up to defend themselves.

Full Answer

Can I serve my own papers to the defendant?

However, many states require that this person be approved by the court. A mailbox isn't personal enough. No matter who serves the papers, if personal service is used, the claim and a summons must be handed to the defendant. You can't simply leave the paper at the defendant's job or home or in the mailbox.

What happens if you are not served court papers?

Trespassing 4. Breaking & Entering 5. Using Force What Happens if you are not Served Court Papers? 1. Substituted Service 2. Default Judgments When a lawsuit is filed, process servers complete an important duty by ensuring that all other parties to the suit receive timely notice and that legal action is pending against them.

What happens if a lawyer fails to file a case?

Sometimes courts will relieve clients of any harsh consequences arising from the lawyer’s failure to file on time. However, sometimes the law requires that the prescribed sanctions for the lawyer’s failure to file be imposed on the client.

Do I need an attorney to file a lawsuit?

An attorney will know how to navigate the legal system, will know the substantive considerations for your lawsuit, and will take a significant amount of work off of your plate. However, if you cannot afford an attorney or, for other reasons, absolutely must file and prosecute your lawsuit on your own it is possible.

image

What does it mean to be served?

What Does It Mean To Be Served? Being served with process means that the due process and statutory requirements for giving notice to a defendant about a legal action have been met. Each state and type of action can have slightly different requirements, but it's common to require personal service to be attempted first.

Can someone sue you without you being served?

Can you be sued without being served? To lawfully file a lawsuit, the plaintiff must serve the defendant (you) with a Summons and a copy of the Petition or Complaint. If the defendant fails to render service of such documents, the case will be dropped or continued until the service of process has taken place.

How do you know if a case is filed against you?

Case Status : Search by FIR numberSelect the Police Station from the select box.In the FIR Number box, enter the FIR Number of the case.In the Year box, enter the FIR Year.Click on either the Pending or Disposed option button, according to the status of the Case.More items...

How can you find out if someone is suing you?

Visit the court clerk It can help you to find out if anyone has filed a lawsuit against you because the court clerk can conduct a record search for any pending lawsuits or judgments. If there is a case that has been filled you must find out before the court has placed a default judgment against you.

How to serve a court case?

In the majority of states, you can serve papers by sending them to the defendant via certified mail with a return receipt requested. In some states, service by certified (or registered) mail is one among several ways you may serve papers. Other states require you to try service by certified mail first, before any other method of service. Normally, the court clerk does the mailing for you and charges a small fee. This is recoverable if you win. The mail method is both cheap and easy, but in most states the defendant must sign for the letter for this type of service to be effective. (In a few states, service is accomplished even if a certified letter is rejected by the defendant.) Most businesses and many individuals routinely sign to accept their mail. However, some people never do, knowing instinctively, or perhaps from past experience, that nothing good ever comes by certified mail. The consensus in an informal survey of court clerks is that about 50% of court papers served by certified mail are accepted. If you try using the mail to serve your papers and fail, and you end up having to pay a process server, tell the judge about it as part of your presentation and chances are your costs will be added to the judgment.

What should a process server do if a person refuses to take a paper?

If the process server locates the right person, but the person refuses to take the paper, acts hostile, or attempts to run away, the process server should simply put the paper down and leave. Valid service has been accomplished. The process server should never try to use force to get a defendant to take any papers.

How to get a default judgment against a military member?

To get a default judgment, you will probably have to file a statement under penalty of perjury that the defendant is not in the military. This declaration is available from the clerk. Clerks almost always accept a Declaration of Nonmilitary Service signed by the plaintiff, as long as the plaintiff reasonably believes that the defendant is not on active duty. This constitutes a lenient interpretation of the law by clerks, but no one seems to be complaining.

How old do you have to be to serve a small claims lawsuit?

1. Small claims papers may be served by an adult who is not named in the lawsuit by leaving a copy at the person's dwelling place in the presence of a competent member of the household who is at least age 18 (and who must be told what the papers are about) or at the person's workplace during normal business hours with the person in charge (who must be told what the papers are about).

How old do you have to be to serve in a civil case?

Service by disinterested adult. Some states allow service by any person who is at least 18 years old, except the person bringing the suit. Any person means just that–a relative or a friend is fine. However, many states require that this person be approved by the court.

Why do you have to serve the other side?

The reason you must serve the other side is obvious: Defendants in a case need to know about any claims against them and must be notified of the day, time, and place that they can show up to defend themselves. Normally, papers must be served in the state where you filed your lawsuit.

Can you serve out of state on a small claims claim?

Many states allow out-of-state service on this type of claim. Your small claims court clerk will show you how this is handled in your state. All defendants on the plaintiff's claim or all plaintiffs on the defendant's claim must be served. It is not enough to serve one defendant or plaintiff and assume that that person will tell the others.

Why should you avoid being served with legal documents?

The best reason to not pursue a strategy of avoiding being served with legal documents is that it can cause you to forfeit your legal rights, creating consequences potentially much worse than the lawsuits themselves.

How did the defendant avoid service?

The defendant actively avoided service by literally moving away from the process server, who tossed the papers to him, saying, “Now, you are served.”. The court held that service cannot be avoided by moving away and refusing to take the documents into your hand.

What Does It Mean To Be Served?

Being served with process means that the due process and statutory requirements for giving notice to a defendant about a legal action have been met. Each state and type of action can have slightly different requirements, but it’s common to require personal service to be attempted first. Personal service is literally handing the papers personally to the defendant. The person serving the papers must be of suitable age and meet some other requirements depending on the state. If personal service cannot be completed, there are usually other ways for a person to be served. That said, some states do require personal service for some types of actions, such as divorce. There are also exceptions to the general rules, such as the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, that allow and encourage defendants to waive in-hand service. In all cases, there is a method to proceed against defendants no matter how much they attempt to avoid being served.

Why do defendants go underground?

Defendants that “go underground” to avoid being served face liability for the costs of investigation and skip tracing that accrue due to their evasive actions. Investigators employ techniques known as skip tracing to locate people that cannot be found at their last known residence or place of business.

What happens when a court case expires?

When the time period expires on their right to defend the action, the judge could issue a default judgment against them. They will now be responsible for all the costs of the attempted at services, attempts to locate them, plus the attorney’s fees and other costs of attempting to overturn the default judgment.

What is the service of process?

State Constitutions have adopted this right and passed “ service of process ” laws that detail the methods that must be used to deliver legal documents to defendants. When faced with legal action, some people will make tremendous efforts to avoid being served with legal documents thinking that they will avoid the consequences ...

Can you waive in hand service?

There are also exceptions to the general rules, such as the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, that allow and encourage defendants to waive in-hand service. In all cases, there is a method to proceed against defendants no matter how much they attempt to avoid being served.

What Happens if you are not Served Court Papers?

You will be fined, your hearing will go on, your case will not be postponed for not having been properly served. Instead, the following tactics are what happens if you are not served court papers.

What happens if you avoid the process server?

If you simply avoid the process server, the mail, the newspaper, and any other legal means of reaching you, you’ll still be assumed to have been notified that legal action or even a lawsuit is pending against you.

What Process Servers Can Do?

Let’s take a look at the ways the law allows you to be served papers and what happens if you are not served court papers.

What is substituted service?

Substituted Service. When a process server has exercised due diligence in tracking a party down for legal service, but still has been unable to hand the papers over, there are provisions called “substituted service.”.

What happens when personal service fails?

2. Mailing You Court Papers. When personal service has failed, a process server can go to the judge and ask for permission to use substituted service. This can take various forms, but every state has some type of statute which allows service by mail.

What is default judgment?

Default Judgments. When a lawsuit is filed, process servers complete an important duty by ensuring that all other parties to the suit receive timely notice and that legal action is pending against them.

What happens if you don't file a default judgment?

At this point, if you don’t file an answer and show up to court, a default judgment can, and likely will, be rendered against you. This can result in wage and bank account garnishments or even jail time depending on the severity of the matter.

What happens when a defendant sees a process server?

When defendants see a process server, they may erroneously believe that they have the right to refuse service by not accepting the papers in their hands. Now you have some tools to deal with this tactic.

What did the server say when the defendant was moving away?

While defendant was moving away in a sidewise manner and looking at the server, the server handed or tossed the process toward defendant—the papers fell a few feet from him—at the same time saying, “Now you are served.". Defendant did not pick it up but continued to walk away from the premises.

What was the court ruling in Trujillo v. Trujillo?

1945) 71 Cal.App.2d 257, the court held that service was proper when the papers were left under a windshield wiper after the defendant locked himself in his car. While the car window was open, the process server explained to the defendant the nature of the documents which he attempted to serve and read to him the order to show cause “in a loud and clear voice," but the defendant rolled the window up and refused to accept the documents. The process server then placed the papers under the windshield wiper in plain view of the defendant, who first tried to dislodge the papers by starting the windshield wiper, but failed to do so until after he had driven away. The court rejected defendant’s argument that he couldn’t hear from the process server was saying and that the papers fell off the wiper as he drove away.

Why was service invalid in the case of Gordon?

The defendant argued that service was invalid because the receptionist was not authorized to accept service and because a third party in the reception area threw the papers in the trash. The court rejected these arguments and held that service “amply complied" with section 415.20 and that the gratuitous actions of third party Gordon did not render ...

What is the greatest challenge in serving a defendant?

1. Defendant’s refusal to accept service. Sometimes the greatest challenge in serving a defendant is locating them. But what do you do when you find them and they refuse to accept the papers? For example, you might knock on their door, but they refuse to open it and tell you to go away.

Can a court dismiss a case if you fail to serve a summons?

But it’s not amusing if you are unable to timely serve a summons and complaint. A court has the right to dismiss your case if you fail to serve a defendant. Keep in mind that the cases in this guide are interesting because the facts are interesting. The facts are detailed.

What happens if I do not serve the defendant?

Not only would the defendant likely not know to show up to court to defend him or herself, the court could decide to dismiss the case altogether. However, the court may allow you to bring the lawsuit at a later date. If you serve process outside of the time frame, the court will dismiss the case. However, you can usually file a motion for more time, if you give the court sufficient reasons as to why you could not serve the defendant.

What must I do once I have filed a lawsuit?

Once you file a lawsuit against the defendant, you must notify him or her. This is called service of process. Service of process requires that you deliver a copy of the summons and complaint directly to the defendant within a certain time of filing the lawsuit with the court.

What is a summons?

A summons is a document that officially notifies the defendant of a civil case brought against him or her. The summons usually includes information such as the name of the case, the case number, the time frame in which the defendant must answer the complaint, the location of the lawsuit, and information about the plaintiff’s attorney.

What is a complaint?

A complaint is the formal pleading, or document that contains what the plaintiff alleges against the defendant. The complaint initiates the lawsuit and informs the defendant of the basis on which he or she is being sued. The complaint usually must also include what relief the plaintiff believes he or she is entitled to from the defendant, reasons that the plaintiff is entitled to such relief, and a demand for judgment by the court.

How do I legally serve someone?

In general, the plaintiff must serve the summons and complaint on the defendant within a certain time frame, usually within 90-120 days of filing the lawsuit with the court.

Who can serve the defendant?

You may also consider hiring a private process server. Otherwise, a “disinterested adult” must serve process. A disinterested adult is someone who is at least 18 years old but who is not the person filing the lawsuit. Sometimes states require that the court approve the process server first.

How do I know which service of process rules to follow?

Rules about service of process depend on who the defendant is, where the defendant and plaintiff live, the nature of the lawsuit, and even where the events of the lawsuit occurred. Be sure to check with a local civil litigation attorney to be sure which rules apply to your case.

What happens if you don't show up for court?

If you have not been properly served, and you don’t show up, the court has no personal jurisdiction over you, and can’t enter a judgment against you. The case can be continued to another court date, and the other side can try again to serve you. It’s tricky if you were improperly served.

What happens if you don't sign for a mailman?

If you don’t sign for it—or the mailman overlooks the “restricted delivery” requirement and lets somebody else sign for it— you haven’t been properly served. If there was abode service, and you don’t show up, a default judgment can be entered against you for whatever the other side sued for.

What is a court case program?

A program to help you tell the court and the other parties that you are participating in a court case.

Can you serve summons by certified mail?

Courts are pretty generous in saying who’s a family or household member who can accept abode service. In Small Claims cases, it’s also possible to serve the Summons and Complaint by certified or registered mail. But only the Circuit Clerk’s office can send it, and the person getting sued must sign for it.

Can you be served without knowing about a summons?

Answer. You must be served with a Summons and a copy of whatever Complaint or Petition that was filed against you. Until then , you don’t have to go to court, and no judgment can be entered against you. But, caution: You can be served without knowing about it.

Can you appear in court without being served?

Of course, you can always voluntarily appear in the case , without having been served. That can save you court costs, by saving the person who is suing you from having to serve you. Last revised. May 24, 2020.

Can you get abode papers in the mail?

But if they don’t, with luck you’ll get them in the mail. Abode service isn’t complete unless someone at your home is served, and copies are sent by regular postal mail to you. Be sure, then, that somebody, where you live or stay, didn’ t get served with the court papers aimed at you.

What is a malpractice lawsuit?

Attorney malpractice is a form of professional malpractice and the proper remedy is a civil suit called a “legal malpractice lawsuit.” In order to prove attorney malpractice, you must prove:

What to do if you believe your attorney was guilty of malpractice?

If you believe your original attorney was guilty of legal malpractice, you should contact a legal specialist for advice on the issue and to determine if you have a case.

How to serve summons and complaint?

Rules regarding proper service of legal documents vary by state, but the most common way to serve a summons and complaint is to have them personally delivered by an adult who is a resident of the state where the complaint is filed. This is usually done by hiring a private process server or your local sheriff’s department to serve the documents.

What happens if you ignore a summons?

If you ignore the summons, the court will enter a default judgment against you and you will be legally obligated to pay for all the damages awarded! This means that the plaintiff will most likely be able to seize your bank accounts, garnish your wages, and potentially foreclose on your home.

What is a summons in court?

A summons is a separate document that gives the defendant official notice that he is being required to appear and answer the allegations made by the plaintiff. In most states, a person representing themselves will need to have the summons issued by the court clerk.

What is affirmative defense?

An affirmative defense is a defense that does not depend on the veracity of the plaintiff’s allegations.

What to do if you have a contract and you fail to hold up your end of the bargain?

Likewise, if you have a binding contract with someone and they fail to hold up their end of the bargain, you may need to file a lawsuit to recover your losses due to that breach of the contract. The first step to beginning any lawsuit is to file a civil complaint. In the complaint, the plaintiff (the person bringing the lawsuit) ...

Can you sue the city for a sidewalk?

For example, if you trip on the sidewalk, you cannot necessarily sue the city for your damages. You will need to allege that the city (or someone else) was negligent in some manner. Perhaps the sidewalk was in a poor state of disrepair.

Do all civil cases have no lawyer?

It’s no surprise then, that research done by americanprogress.org has found: “In more than three-fourths of all civil trial cases in the United States, at least one litigant does not have a lawyer. . . And these are just the Americans who make it to court.

image