why nonprofits need lawyer on board of directors

Attorneys may be of great value to nonprofits when serving on nonprofit boards. They bring to the board a special set of knowledge, skills, perspectives, networks, and experiences, including an ability to spot and address particular issues and problems. For such reason, many nonprofits actively seek out attorneys to serve as directors.

Full Answer

Why hire a lawyer as a nonprofit board member?

They bring to the board a special set of knowledge, skills, perspectives, networks, and experiences, including an ability to spot and address particular issues and problems. For such reason, many nonprofits actively seek out attorneys to serve as directors.

Does a nonprofit need a board of directors?

Even if a nonprofit isn’t incorporated or falls beneath the threshold of 501 (c) (3) eligibility, a board of directors may still be a good idea unless the organization is quite small or temporary. A nonprofit board of directors helps the organization follow best practices, ensuring it stays within legal and ethical bounds.

Can a lawyer be a member of the Board of directors?

The Lawyer as Director of a Client (American Bar Association) A lawyer for a corporation or other organization who is also a member of its board of directors should determine whether the responsibilities of the two roles may conflict. The lawyer may be called on to advise the corporation in matters involving actions of the directors.

Should I hire a lawyer for my board meeting?

Lawyers on your board are there to fulfill their passions about your mission, not to represent your organization. Even if the lawyer is knowledgeable and qualified to advise on a legal question, you can avoid issues by seeking outside counsel.

What are the top three responsibilities for a nonprofit board of directors?

Nonprofit board members have the legal responsibility to meet the duty of care, the duty of loyalty, and the duty of obedience. Under well-established principles of nonprofit corporation law, a board member must meet certain standards of conduct and attention in carrying out their responsibilities to the organization.

Who should not serve on a board of directors?

Without further ado, here are five Board No-Nos.Getting paid. ... Going rogue. ... Being on a board with a family member. ... Directing staff or volunteers below the executive director. ... Playing politics. ... Thinking everything is fine and nothing needs to change.

Why does a nonprofit need a board of directors?

Nonprofits need a board of directors for a variety of reasons. Not only is the members' wealth of knowledge and experience invaluable to the organization, but they are also necessary for essential tasks like applying for bank accounts, filing annual reports, and making important purchases.

What qualities should members of the board of directors of a nonprofit possess?

To truly be a great nonprofit board member requires having good character, a strong commitment to the cause, the gift of time, and a willingness to use personal and professional resources to advance the organization's mission.

What are the 7 functional responsibilities of a nonprofit board?

Nonprofit Boards: 7 Key Responsibilities for Good GovernanceEnsure Effective Organizational Planning.Provide Sufficient Resources.Make Sure the Organization Fulfills Legal Obligations.Provide Proper Financial Oversight.Select and Evaluate the Executive Director.Improve the Organization's Public Standing.More items...•

Can the founder of a nonprofit be on the board of directors?

Can a founder be on the board of directors? We run into this thought process if a founder is generally overly cautious or has a fear of there being a conflict of interest. However, “founder” is not actually a designated role recognized by the IRS or any state. So, yes, a founder can be on the board.

What are the three primary functions of a board of directors?

Just as for any corporation, the board of directors of a nonprofit has three primary legal duties known as the “duty of care,” “duty of loyalty,” and “duty of obedience.”

How many board members should a nonprofit have?

The IRS generally requires a minimum of three board members for every nonprofit, but does not dictate board term length. What is important to remember is that board service terms aren't intended to be perpetual, and are typically one to five years. Service terms must be outlined in the nonprofit bylaws.

Do board members get paid in a non profit?

Even though there is no federal rule against compensating board members of charitable nonprofits, most charities do not pay board members. 3 However, board members may be reimbursed for certain expenses or receive a deduction on their personal income taxes4 .

How do you make a good nonprofit board of directors?

You might address:Mission and vision. Offer a brief history of the organization. ... Expectations. Tell board members what's expected of them. ... Staff and volunteers. Provide a current organizational chart, including bios of current board members and key staff. ... Policies. ... Reports. ... Legal and tax documents. ... Practical details.

What makes an effective board member?

Effective board members refrain from obsessing on a single issue and come with an open mind to ask questions about all issues. Decisions-timely distribution of material sets the stage for decision-making. Board members become energized and engaged when they are an active part of forward progress.

What are three characteristics that are desired in a board member?

Here are the critical qualities of an effective board member:Dedicated and Committed. ... Able to lead and influence others. ... Straightforward and impartial. ... Knowledgeable and an insatiable learner. ... Values discretion and confidentiality.

Why do lawyers help nonprofits?

Lawyers often have the experience and understanding to help a nonprofit think through risk-related issues. Conflict on a board will arise especially when challenging core assumptions (“sacred cows”). A board’s social nature seeks to limit, if not eliminate, conflict engendered when members assert fundamental differences.

Why do lawyers serve on boards?

For every year a lawyer serves on a board they should be prepared to make a significant financial contribution and participate in the nonprofit’s fundraising activities. An attorney can best fulfill their board fiduciary responsibilities if they treat their organization and board service like one of their clients.

How many hours do lawyers spend on board?

Lawyers on average should spend several hours per week on board business.

Can a lawyer be covered by malpractice insurance?

If they engage in practicing law on behalf of the organization while serving on the board and a lawsuit is filed, they may not be covered by either their malpractice or the nonprofit’s insurance. Throughout their service lawyers remain bound by their code of ethics and professional responsibility for which they may be accountable for their actions.

Should a board member receive an audit report?

Every board member should monitor financial reports on a monthly basis and review them thoroughly before board meetings. The board should receive an audit report without the executive director or senior managers present and make certain actionable recommendations are implemented.

Can a board ignore dissenting members?

Boards may ignore or, worse, affirmatively shut down or eliminate dissenting members, thereby creating a perilous “group think” phenomenon. A lawyer’s experience in addressing conflict, especially through mediation skills, can be invaluable to make certain all sides of an issue are heard and considered.

What is a nonprofit board of directors?

Essentially, a nonprofit board of directors provides a nonprofit with oversight as well as insight. If you’re thinking of starting a nonprofit, take the time to set up an excellent board of directors.

What is the role of a board member in a nonprofit?

Board members have an obligation to ensure the organization abides by all state and federal laws governing nonprofit entities, and provides support in areas such as public relations, legal matters, and human resources. The board also sees that the organization handles its assets responsibly . 4 .

How long does a nonprofit board of directors serve?

Most organizations’ bylaws also state how long members can serve; the typical term ranges from two to five years. When terms expire, the original board ...

What is an unincorporated nonprofit?

An unincorporated nonprofit is usually composed of two or more people to support a common goal in a typically temporary and informal way. Since unincorporated nonprofits are informal entities, they aren’t held to the same laws as nonprofit corporations, and thus do not need a board of directors to operate.

How to become a non profit?

The first step to becoming a nonprofit is to incorporate in the organization’s home state. States write corporate law and most require all nonprofit corporations (nonprofits that have incorporated) to create and maintain a minimum number of directors on a board of directors. 1 . The minimum board member requirements are defined by ...

How often do board members meet?

Most states require that board members meet at least once annually, but it’s up to the organization’s bylaws to set more specific meeting times. Meetings cover and document essential matters, such as choosing the Executive Director, programmatic direction, finances, and fundraising. 4 .

What are the qualities of a board member?

Board members should have integrity, commitment, and interest in the mission. Consider board members who aren’t necessarily professionals, such as heavily involved volunteers within your nonprofit. Passion and commitment are as important as professional skills in some cases.

What are the duties of a board member of a non profit?

As a board member, or director, of a nonprofit corporation, an individual must meet the fiduciary duties of care and loyalty. Generally, these duties are to act in good faith, in a manner that director believes to be in the best interests of the corporation and with such care, including reasonable inquiry, as an ordinarily prudent person in ...

What does a board member do?

A board member who is an attorney offers to the nonprofit specialized knowledge, skills, perspectives, and networks of contacts. But serving as a board member is very different from representing the organization as pro bono counsel, which makes it critical for the parties to understand the precise role in which the attorney will serve. ...

What is a director entitled to?

In performing the duties of a director, a director may be entitled to rely on information, opinions, reports or statements prepared or presented by an attorney. This may serve as a defense to a claim if, for example, a director took an action that would otherwise have been considered negligent but not for the director’s reliance on the opinion ...

Can a director's opinion be received without consideration?

The concern is two fold: (1) your opinions offered as a director may be received with unwarranted and unspoken deference if the rest of the board considers it legal advice, and (2) your legal advice offered as an attorney may be received without appropriate consideration if the rest of the board considers it merely the opinion of a director.

Is attorney client communication protected?

If it’s clear that the communications are to be attorney-client communications, they should be protected by the privilege. However, such protection may be lost if it’s not clear that you are communicating only as an attorney or if the communication is recorded in minutes to which other persons have access. Competence.

Why are attorneys important to nonprofits?

Attorneys may be of great value to nonprofits when serving on nonprofit boards. They bring to the board a special set of knowledge, skills, perspectives, networks, and experiences, including an ability to spot and address particular issues and problems.

Who should be the lawyer for a corporation?

A lawyer for a corporation or other organization who is also a member of its board of directors should determine whether the responsibilities of the two roles may conflict. The lawyer may be called on to advise the corporation in matters involving actions of the directors.

What is the standard of care of a director?

Standard of Care. A director’s standard of care is generally expressed as that of an ordinarily prudent person in a like position under similar circumstances. While there are cases of inside directors (who are employees) of for-profit corporations having a higher standard of care than outside directors, there does not appear to be authority that extends to directors of nonprofit corporations with specific professional knowledge, skills, and experience that might be relevant in exercising their fiduciary duties. Accordingly, directors who happen to be lawyers should not be held to a higher standard of care than other directors. But there have proposals (including in a 2004 Discussion Draft Proposal from the Staff of the Senate Finance Committee) that would require directors with special skills or expertise to use such skills or expertise in meeting their duty of care. And it’s plausible that a director also acting as an attorney to the organization on a particular matter may be held to a higher standard of care based on being comparable to an inside director.

What is a director entitled to?

In performing the duties of a director, a director may be entitled to rely on information, opinions, reports or statements prepared or presented by an attorney. This may serve as a defense to a claim if, for example, a director took an action that would otherwise have been considered negligent but not for the director’s reliance on the opinion ...

Is attorney client communication protected?

If it’s clear that the communications are to be attorney-client communications, they should be protected by the privilege. However, such protection may be lost if it’s not clear that you are communicating only as a lawyer or if the communication is recorded in minutes to which other persons have access. Competence.

Can a director be received without legal advice?

The concern is two fold: (1) your words offered as a director may be received with unwarranted and unspoken deference if the rest of the board considers it legal advice, and (2) your legal advice offered as a lawyer may be received without appropriate consideration if the rest of the board considers it the thoughts of a director.

Can a non profit attorney serve as a director?

For such reason, many nonprofits actively seek out attorneys to serve as directors. But this can also cause a misunderstanding of the capacity in which the attorney is going to serve. Nonprofits may want and expect the attorney to serve as pro bono counsel while the attorney often wants to serve purely as a director.

What does the board of directors do?

The board hires the executive director and makes sure that he or she does not endanger the financial future of the nonprofit or engage in unlawful acts that could put the organization in legal jeopardy. Board members are expected to help support the organization financially and to help raise funds.

How to help a board member who shys away from personal contact?

Board members who shy away from personal contact with potential donors can still help by making phone calls, writing thank you notes, or hosting fundraising events. Board members need to understand the difference between the responsibilities of the board and the staff.

How to make sure a board runs smoothly?

To make sure that the board runs smoothly, the first board members should set up a nominating committee whose job will be to find new board members to both expand the board and to fill open positions as they come up.

How long can a board member serve?

For instance, one could serve one year, one could serve two years, and the third could serve for three years. You will want to specify in your articles of incorporation and bylaws what the maximum term is for board members going forward.

Is Joanne Fritz a nonprofit?

Joanne Fritz. Updated October 30, 2019. A nonprofit is a corporation and, just like its for-profit cousins, nonprofit corporations exist independently of the people who founded them. It is a legal requirement for a nonprofit to have a board of directors .

Do nonprofits have a board of directors?

It is a legal requirement for a nonprofit to have a board of directors. The state in which your nonprofit incorporates has standards for nonprofit boards. They usually include several "duties," such as the Duty of Care, Loyalty, and Obedience. Those duties involve the responsibility to make sure that the nonprofit follows nonprofit law, ...

What is a Nonprofit Board of Directors and its purpose?

The nonprofit board of directors is the legislative and governing body of a nonprofit organization. Individual board members generally have one vote each and collectively decide the direction that a nonprofit organization should take.

Nonprofit Board of Directors and Membership Classes

There are two different classes of voting members as a governing method for a nonprofit organization.

Who chooses the board of directors for nonprofits?

Nonprofit board of directors is an elected governing body and there should be no appointment or selection except for member driven organization. The board members of a nonprofit are elected during board meetings of an existing board by existing directors for set period of term.

Can the Founder of a nonprofit be on the board of directors?

Yes, the founder of a nonprofit organization may serve on the board of directors and they usually do. However, refrain from adopting undemocratic terms or special considerations for the founder in the bylaws. The nonprofit founder should not be appointed for life or have any other privileges or powers that a regular board member does not have.

Can family members be on the nonprofit board of directors?

The question of electing family members to the board of directors of a nonprofit organization comes up on a daily basis and I can’t give a yes or no answer. Electing family members as directors is usually not a good idea because of the naturally existing conflict of interest. Let me go through a few scenarios so I can explain it.

Who are the officers of a nonprofit organization and how are they different from directors (board members)?

This is a source of great confusion for many and these titles are used interchangeably by mistake and failure to understand and practice the correct procedures has grave consequences. Nonprofit directors (board members) are unpaid volunteer legislators who have one vote each and set the policies and the programs of the organization.

Nonprofit board of directors positions, roles, and responsibilities

In a nonprofit corporation, the voting director offices are volunteer positions and cannot be compensated. The followings are standard leadership positions that almost every state requires for governance of a nonprofit organization including their role in the matter.

What are the legal obligations of a nonprofit board member?

Under nonprofit corporation law, board members have legal obligations defined as “duty of care,” “duty of loyalty,” and “duty of obedience.” While these terms may sound archaic, they are well-established tenets of good governance.

What are the responsibilities of a nonprofit board?

While every nonprofit has a unique mission and organizational structure, boards typically share common, basic responsibilities. Nonprofit boards typically take responsibility for these eight key tasks: 1 Setting an actionable mission and an inspiring vision for the organization 2 Hiring a chief executive, supporting their efforts, and evaluating their performance 3 Partnering with key staff to create short- and long-term plans, monitoring results, and modifying when needed 4 Ensuring the effectiveness of programs and services 5 Helping to secure operating funds and providing ongoing financial oversight 6 Managing and improving board performance 7 Meeting or exceeding legal and ethical standards and expectations 8 Maximizing stakeholder and community support

How are nonprofit boards changing?

Nonprofit boards are changing as regulatory requirements become more stringent and societal needs evolve. Nonprofit boards have often been perceived as a bastion of wealthy men. Historically, they’ve also not been particularly diverse. While many boards require their members to be donors, this requirement isn’t as critical as it once was. Many nonprofits now find that they need more from board members than deep pockets, as governance issues and legal compliance grow in complexity. Gorske says, “rubber stamp boards are going the way of the dinosaur.”

What are the tasks of a nonprofit board?

Nonprofit boards typically take responsibility for these eight key tasks: Setting an actionable mission and an inspiring vision for the organization. Hiring a chief executive, support ing their efforts, and evaluating their performance.

What is corporate board?

Corporate board members are guardians of shareholders’ interests, while their nonprofit counterparts work to meet the needs of those served by the organization’s work . The common ground is delivering a clear mission and organizational values while providing sound governance and oversight.

What is the duty of obedience?

Duty of obedience requires board members to perform their responsibilities in a way that is faithful to the stated mission— while following all laws and internal rules, policies, and regulations.

How can a board be more effective?

First, the right board members must be in place. Second, an effective chief executive should be leading the organization. Lastly, both the board and the chief executive must know their responsibilities and be dedicated to ongoing communication.

What are the advantages of having an attorney on the board?

Advantages of having an attorney on the board. 1. Professionalism, conscientiousness, attention to detail. Notwithstanding all the lawyer jokes, attorneys are learned professionals. They are typically detail-oriented, conscientious, and risk-averse.

Why do attorneys go to law school?

Attorneys are trained in law school to take in legal and factual information, to analyze that information, and to make recommendations based upon fact, law, financial risk, and other factors. There are many instances where — short of serving as the organization's attorney — this point of view can be very helpful. 1.

What are the good traits of an attorney?

The good traits of attorneys (such as the ability to form a convincing argument) may compel other board members to give unreasonable weight to the attorney's point of view, and other board members may even feel that to disagree is to risk legal exposure. The attorney himself may feel a need to be the expert, or to imply ...

What does "no attorney-client relationship" mean?

No attorney-client relationship means no malpractice insurance coverage. The atty may ultimately win on the merits but the costs of defense will bury him or her. Again organizations should have outside counsel for legal services and not rely on attorney board members. Scott Forsyth.

Is an attorney a board member?

The organization’s attorney should never be a Board member. An attorney-Board member should not be thought of as a "two-fer" or a free attorney. The organization’s attorney should always be a disinterested party. A Board member serving as the organization’s attorney is a conflict of interest.

Is a board member a substitute for outside counsel?

Related to the issue of substantive law, there are no shortcuts: The Board Member/Attorney is no substitute for outside counsel in terms of an independent perspective, the appearance of same, and the ability to devote the time and energy required to understand the underlying issues and develop a legal strategy.

Do attorneys serve on boards?

Attorneys who serve on boards are volunteers like anybody else. The skills learned in law school and honed in practice may enable us to handle best quasi-legal tasks like writing by-laws and policies. On the other hand if an organization wants legal advise it should retain an attorney for this purpose.

Ethical Considerations

• People tend to perceive lawyers as well off (aka: ready to write out the big donation check) and knowledgeable of all areas of law (aka: ready to dispense free legal advice). So, awesome choice for a board member, right? Turns out, it can get a bit more complicated than that. Attorneys can …

See more on birkenlaw.com

Heightened Exposure to Liability

Tips For Attorney/Directors

Additional Resources