who was the lawyer who defended the british soliders in the bosto

by Maude Rippin 8 min read

John Adams

Who was John Adams — defense attorney for British soldiers?

John Adams — Defense Attorney for British Soldiers? Why a Founding Father represented British soldiers during the Boston Massacre Trials aptain Thomas Preston and eight British soldiers were on trial for murder. They would need an excellent attorney to represent them with a jury full of anti-British colonists.

Who did John Adams defend in the Boston Massacre?

Adams defended the British officer Thomas Preston and his soldiers in two separate trials. Can you talk about the balancing act Adams undertook to defend all his clients without alienating his fellow Bostonians, many of whom fervently supported the broader patriot cause?

What testimony did the defense have in the Boston Massacre?

Witnesses recalled how the mob had repeatedly called for the British soldiers to be killed. Particularly effective testimony for the defense came from Dr. John Jeffries, who had tended to one of the colonists killed on the night of March 5, 1770.

Who was on trial for the Boston Massacre?

Next on trial were the eight soldiers under Preston’s command on the night of the Boston Massacre. There was a different jury for this trial and they were, once again, sequestered. During the seven-day trial, more than eighty witnesses were called to testify.

image

Who was the lawyer during the Boston Massacre?

The prosecution lawyers were Robert Treat Paine and Samuel Quincy. The defense team included John Adams, Josiah Quincy, Jr. (Samuel Quincy's brother), Sampson Salter Blowers, and Robert Auchmuty. Both trials lasted longer than one day, which was rare at this time for Massachusetts courts.

Who was the lawyer who defended the 8 British soldiers?

John Adamsaptain Thomas Preston and eight British soldiers were on trial for murder. They would need an excellent attorney to represent them with a jury full of anti-British colonists. Who would be willing to take on such a task? Patriot and Founding Father John Adams stepped up to the job.

Who defended the Boston Massacre soldiers?

President John AdamsEight soldiers, one officer, and four civilians were arrested and charged with murder, and they were defended by future U.S. President John Adams.

Why John Adams defended the British soldiers?

Without hesitation Adams agreed to defend the soldiers and their captain. Above all, John Adams believed in upholding the law, and defending the innocent. Adams was convinced that the soldiers were wrongly accused, and had fired into the crowd in self-defense.

Who was the Patriot who represented Preston and the soldiers?

He agreed to represent Preston and the soldiers, joined by fellow Patriot Josiah Quincy.

Who was the governor of Boston during the Boston riots?

Governor Thomas Hutchinson arranged to have the accused soldiers removed to an island in Boston Harbor. The Attorney General issued murder indictments for Captain Thomas Preston and eight other soldiers for their participation in the riot.

Why was Boston important to the British?

Boston was a major port for trade as well as a hotbed for Patriot activity and organization. Britain stationed a large garrison of troops in the city with the aim of controlling unruly colonists who were resisting customs officials. On March 5, 1770, a crowd gathered outside the Customs House that was being guarded by the British.

What did Adams and the defense argue about the crowd?

Adams and the defense argued that the crowd was endangering the soldiers’ lives and they acted in self-defense. He called witnesses that described how the crowd verbally threatened the soldiers and threw objects at them. Witnesses recalled how the mob had repeatedly called for the British soldiers to be killed.

How many soldiers were found not guilty of murder?

After deliberating for three hours, the jury found all eight soldiers not guilty of murder. Two of the men were found guilty of the lesser charge of manslaughter and their penalty was reduced to branding on the thumb. The other six soldiers were completely cleared of all charges.

How did the Boston Massacre impact the legal system?

The impact on today’s legal system. The Boston Massacre trials served as a landmark case for the new justice system in the colonies. This trial was the first time that a jury was sequestered, which is now typical practice in high profile cases. The standard of reasonable doubt was also introduced during this trial.

What was the Boston Massacre called?

Before the trial, Loyalists and Patriots engaged in a propaganda war. Patriot cartoons and articles painted the riot as an all-out attack by aggressive British soldiers. Paul Revere even published a cartoon which he named The Bloody Massacre, leading the riot to be known as the Boston Massacre.

Early Life

John Adams was born on October 30, 1735, to his father, John Adams Sr., and his mother, Susanna Boylston, and had two younger brothers, Peter and Elihu.

Boston Massacre

The Boston Massacre was a conflict in Boston on March 5, 1770. British soldiers shot and killed many people, perceiving them as a mob, and leading patriots including Paul Revere and Samuel Adams heavily publicized the event.

Boston massacre trial

Following the Boston Massacre, Captain Thomas Preston, eight British soldiers, and five British civilians were charged for murder. They were exposed to the possibility of execution and could not find a defense team as they would have to defend them in the anti-British city of Boston.

Balancing Act of Adams to defend his clients without distancing his fellow Bostonians

These days, criminal defense lawyers regularly take John Adams’s defense of the British soldiers to to represent specific clients. He did not blame the city for initiating the riot and focused on facts.

Conclusion

It is generally unsatisfying to get a mixed verdict in a case involving so much passion and emotion. However, these cases serve as a compelling example, and the Boston Massacre trial was among these trials.

Who was the patriot who defended the British soldiers in court?

However, one of the patriots so essential to the revolution, John Adams, chose to defend the British soldiers in court.

Why did the British soldiers have trouble finding defense counsel?

The British soldiers, facing the prospect of the death penalty, had trouble finding defense counsel. No colonist, it seemed, wanted to take on this unpopular case, as doing so might affect his reputation and economic future. However, as British subjects, the soldiers had the right to competent defense lawyers, and the people ...

Why did Adams take the case?

He clearly knew that taking on this case was dangerous. An angry mob could threaten his family, and should his reputation be tarnished, his ambitions and economic future would be endangered.

Why did the British invade Massachusetts?

In 1768, British troops arrived in Massachusetts to enforce the hated, tax-heavy Townshend Acts. Over the ensuing months, tensions between the colonists and their mother country’s soldiers boiled over, culminating in what became known as the Boston Massacre.

When did the Preston trial take place?

Results of the Trials. Preston’s trial took place between Oct. 24 and Oct. 30, 1770 . Adams argued that Preston had not given the order to fire, and that Preston's soldiers were provoked by the crowd.

Who was the patriot who fought against the British in the Revolution?

However, one of the patriots so essential to the revolution, John Adams, chose to defend the British soldiers in court.

Did Adams argue that they acted in self defense?

Here, Adams argued that they acted in self-defense. The jury in that case acquitted six, but found two guilty of the lesser charge of manslaughter. Finally, in December the four civilians went to trial, and all were acquitted.

image

Trouble in The Colonies

The Search For Justice

  • Governor Thomas Hutchinson arranged to have the accused soldiers removed to an island in Boston Harbor. The Attorney General issued murder indictments for Captain Thomas Preston and eight other soldiers for their participation in the riot. Before the trial, Loyalists and Patriots engaged in a propaganda war. Patriot cartoons and articles painted th...
See more on historyofyesterday.com

The Trial Begins

  • Preston’s trial began on October 24, 1770. For the first time, the jury was sequestered away from family and friends for the duration of the trial. The key question was whether or not Preston had given the order to fire. Preston strongly denied giving any such order. Witness testimony was mixed, with some saying he gave the order and others declaring he did not. Adams was able to i…
See more on historyofyesterday.com

The Verdict Is Delivered

  • In his closing statements, Adams reminded the jury of the law of self-defense. He recalled testimony that the crowd was chanting to kill the British soldiers. Adams implored the jury to consider how they would react when a mob was calling for their death. He entreated the jury to judge the case based on facts and evidence, rather than their Patriot leanings. After deliberating …
See more on historyofyesterday.com

The Impact on Today’S Legal System

  • The Boston Massacre trials served as a landmark case for the new justice system in the colonies. This trial was the first time that a jury was sequestered, which is now typical practice in high profile cases. The standard of reasonable doubt was also introduced during this trial. In his instructions, one of the judges reminded the jurors that they needed to be “convinced beyond a r…
See more on historyofyesterday.com

Early Life

Boston Massacre

  • The Boston Massacre was a conflict in Boston on March 5, 1770. British soldiers shot and killed many people, perceiving them as a mob, and leading patriots including Paul Revere and Samuel Adams heavily publicized the event. Boston, the capital of the Massachusetts Bay, was a significant shipping town and a center of resistance to unpopular taxation acts by the British Par…
See more on historyten.com

Boston Massacre Trial

  • Following the Boston Massacre, Captain Thomas Preston, eight British soldiers, and five British civilians were charged for murder. They were exposed to the possibility of execution and could not find a defense team as they would have to defend them in the anti-British city of Boston. John Adams realized that there was a lot at stake for colonial America, and it was important for the a…
See more on historyten.com

John Adams’ Role in The Boston Massacre Trial

  • In the trial, Adams said that Captain Preston had never ordered his soldiers to fire. He also put forward that those who had shot into the crowd did so entirely for self-defense. He called the people involved in the mob who provoked the soldiers “outlandish Jack tars.” H” persuaded and won th” case releasing Preston and six of his soldiers on all c...
See more on historyten.com

Conclusion

  • It is generally unsatisfying to get a mixed verdict in a case involving so much passion and emotion. However, these cases serve as a compelling example, and the Boston Massacre trial was among these trials. The Boston massacre could have led to a revolution, but it did not, as people accepted it was a very controversial verdict. For firing against the orders of Captain Prest…
See more on historyten.com