who was hillary clinton's lawyer during email scandal

by Judson Graham Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago 4 min read

Who gave Hillary Clinton's emails to her lawyer?

She gave thumb drives containing her work emails to her lawyer, David Kendall. In May 2015, federal District Court Judge Rudolph Contreras, presiding over one of a series of pending cases related to Clinton's email, ordered the State Department to begin producing batches of the 55,000 pages of Clinton's work messages on a rolling basis every month.

Did the FBI recommend no charges against Hillary Clinton over emails?

^ "FBI recommends no charges against Hillary Clinton over emails". BBC News. July 5, 2016. Retrieved November 14, 2016. But investigators found that a number of messages that were marked classified at the time were sent from her account. ^ Herridge, Catherine; Browne, Pamela K. (June 11, 2016).

Should the Clinton email scandal change your opinion of the President?

The most important thing to understand about the Clinton email controversy is that it shouldn't — and probably won't — force you to radically revise your own opinion of Clinton or whether she should be president. Rather than telling us something new about her, the scandal reveals what Clinton obsessives — fans and foes alike — already knew.

What happened to Hillary Clinton’s email server?

July 2013 – Clinton’s email server is changed once again to be backed up by a McAfee-owned company.

When did Hillary Clinton address the email controversy?

Clinton's initial response. Clinton addressing email controversy with the media at the UN Headquarters on March 10, 2015. Clinton's spokesman Nick Merrill defended Clinton's usage of her personal server and email accounts as being in compliance with the "letter and spirit of the rules.".

How many emails did Hillary Clinton have?

Clinton's server was found to hold over 100 emails containing classified information, including 65 emails deemed "Secret" and 22 deemed "Top Secret". An additional 2,093 emails not marked classified were retroactively designated confidential by the State Department.

What did Hillary Clinton do to her private server?

Code § 1924, regarding the unauthorized removal and retention of classified documents or materials, as well as State Department protocols and procedures, and regulations governing recordkeeping. Clinton claimed that her use complied with federal laws and State Department regulations, and that former secretaries of state had also maintained personal email accounts (however Clinton was the only secretary of state to use a private server ). News reports by NBC and CNN indicated that the emails discussed "innocuous" matters already available in the public domain. For example, the CIA drone program has been widely discussed in the public domain since the early 2000s; however, the existence of the program is technically classified, so sharing a newspaper article that mentions it would constitute a security breach, according to the CIA.

Why did Hillary Clinton say she had done so?

Clinton herself stated she had done so as a matter of "convenience."

What was the Clinton controversy?

The controversy was a major point of discussion and contention during the 2016 presidential election, in which Clinton was the Democratic nominee. In May, the State Department's Office of the Inspector General released a report about the State Department's email practices, including Clinton's.

When did Hillary Clinton use a BlackBerry phone?

Hillary Clinton holding a BlackBerry phone in 2009. Prior to her appointment as Secretary of State in 2009, Clinton and her circle of friends and colleagues communicated via BlackBerry phones. State Department security personnel suggested this would pose a security risk during her tenure.

Who provided data backup service for Hillary Clinton's emails?

Datto, Inc. , which provided data backup service for Clinton's email, agreed to give the FBI the hardware that stored the backups. As of May 2016, no answer had been provided to the public as to whether 31,000 emails deleted by Hillary Clinton as personal have been or could be recovered.

Who is the Clinton email address?

January 13, 2009 – The domain clintonemail.com is registered in the name of longtime adviser to former President Bill Clinton, Just in Cooper. Hillary Clinton’s email is set up as hdr22@clintonemail.com

How many emails did Hillary Clinton send in 2014?

Also in 2014, at the request of the State Department, Clinton hands over 55,000 pages — approximately 30,000 emails. Left out were emails deemed by her and her staff to be “personal.”

How many pages of notes did the FBI release?

The same day, the FBI releases nearly 200 pages of notes from its investigation of Clinton’s private email server. October 28, 2016 – In a letter to Congress, Comey says the FBI is reviewing new emails related to Clinton’s time as secretary of state, according to a letter sent to eight congressional committee chairmen.

When was the Clinton email chain discovered?

September 25, 2015 – An email chain between Clinton and David Petraeus from January and February 2009 is discovered. This causes speculation about whether some emails on Clinton’s server were mistakenly considered personal. The emails did not contain classified information.

How many emails were redacted in 2016?

February 13, 2016 – The State Department releases 551 of Hillary Clinton’s emails. Of those, 84 emails were redacted and deemed classified.

What did Hillary Clinton say about the inspector general?

January 20, 2016 – During a segment on National Public Radio, Clinton says the letter from the inspector general was nothing more than a ruse to damage her campaign for the presidency. Clinton’s spokesman, Brian Fallon, also tells Bloomberg that they believed McCullough and Republican senators were working together to make the letter public.

When did Hillary Clinton's email server change?

November 2012 – Clinton’s private email server was redesigned to use Google as the backup server.

Why did Hillary Clinton set up a private email server?

Hillary Clinton set up a private email server, and a private email network for herself and her family and Abedin. Doing so could prevent her emails from being “accessible” to the federal government, not to mention Congress.

What was Bill Clinton's email program called?

When all was said and done, Clinton deleted thousands of emails with a software program called “BleachBit .” Bill Clinton’s former aide Justin Cooper came back into the picture to deal with at least two of Clinton’s 13 mobile devices. Cooper smashed them with a hammer or broke them in half, according to the FBI. The server itself was shipped off to an obscure company in Denver called Platte River Networks.

What charges did Abedin and Clinton face?

Both Clinton and Abedin face the possibility of additional charges, including perjury and obstruction of justice, for contradicting sworn statements and telling falsehoods to the FBI, not to mention Congress. The photograph of Abedin crying on the Clinton campaign plane after the FBI announced that it was re-opening the case — with Clinton standing by — will linger in the American political consciousness:

What was Hillary Clinton's statement to the Benghazi Committee?

Hillary’s statement to the Benghazi Committee is one of multiple statements that could open Clinton up to charges of perjury or obstruction of justice. And it is one of many areas in which Breitbart News led the media in exposing a Clinton falsehood. But Hillary Clinton did not simply expose national secrets.

How many emails did Comey find?

Comey’s first investigation found 113 emails that had classified information in them, including emails that were clearly marked classified when they were sent. Clinton, for her part, claimed that she didn’t know that a “C” marking on an email meant that it was classified or confidential.

Where was Hillary Clinton's IT specialist?

Hillary’s 2008 campaign IT specialist Bryan Pagliano labored for months in a room on K Street in Washington, D.C. , building the server for Clinton to use.

Who came up with the idea for Clinton to use a private email server?

Huma Abedin has reason to be nervous. In fact, she was the one who came up with the idea for Clinton to use a private email server, according to former Bill Clinton aide Justin Cooper’s testimony in the case. Cooper was Clinton-World’s go-to computer guy, and he set up Abedin’s own personal account on clintonemail.com.

Is Hillary Clinton a private person?

One of the fundamental contradictions of her life is that she is an intensely private person whose ambition drives her to live in the public eye . She can't hold public office and protect her privacy at the same time, but she still tries to do just that.

Is Clinton in trouble with the law?

So far, no federal authority has accused Clinton of breaking any law, and federal officials have said she is not a target of the investigation into the handling of her email. The FBI's security investigation could always turn into a criminal investigation.

Who was the attorney for the DNC?

Elias was also a key player in the Russia collusion hoax. As the attorney for both the DNC and Clinton campaign, he helped bankroll research by Fusion GPS that created the bogus “Steele dossier” used by the FBI to obtain FISA warrants to spy on the Trump campaign during the 2016 race.

Why did Elias sue?

In Pennsylvania, Elias filed suit to force county boards of elections to accept late ballots that don’t arrive for a full week after the election. He also sued to force officials to count late ballots without a postmark to prove they were cast by Election Day. Elias also sued to prevent county boards of elections from disqualifying ballots if the signatures don’t match those on file , and to prevent rejection of ballots that aren’t in the security envelope, and only inside of one envelope.

Who is Marc Elias?

Marc Elias the Democratic National Committee’s election lawyer and legal adviser to Hillary Clinton’s 2016 campaign, filed more than 50 lawsuits around the country challenging state election laws in advance of the 2020 presidential election.

What did Elias do to overrule state laws?

Though most of the state laws he challenged have been on the books for years, Elias went full steam ahead asking courts to overrule state election laws, force states to count ballots that came in after Election Day, or force states to have unattended ballot collection boxes.

Who is Jonathan Turley?

Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington University. You can find his updates on Twitter @JonathanTurley.

What was the problem with the Steele dossier?

The problem was that both the Steele dossier and the Alfa Bank allegations fell apart soon after being fed to the FBI. A key source for dossier compiler and former British spy Christopher Steele was viewed by American intelligence as a Russian agent, and it was believed that the Clinton campaign and the dossier were being used by Russian intelligence to spread disinformation.

Did Sussman tell the truth?

According to the indictment, Sussman told the truth — and contradicted what he’d originally told the FBI general counsel — when interviewed under oath in December 2017 before the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, telling them he did not hold the meeting of his own volition but at the request of a client.

Overview

Responses and analysis

Clinton's spokesman Nick Merrill defended Clinton's usage of her personal server and email accounts as being in compliance with the "letter and spirit of the rules."
Clinton herself stated she had done so as a matter of "convenience."
On March 10, 2015, while attending a conference at the headquarters of the Un…

Background

Prior to her appointment as Secretary of State in 2009, Clinton and her circle of friends and colleagues communicated via BlackBerry phones. State Department security personnel suggested this would pose a security risk during her tenure. The email account used on Clinton's BlackBerry was then hosted on a private server in the basement of her home in Chappaqua, New York, but that informati…

Use of private server for government business

According to Clinton's spokesperson Nick Merrill, a number of government officials have used private email accounts for official business, including secretaries of state before Clinton, but none have set up their own private domain to house their private email account.
State Department spokesperson Marie Harf said that: "For some historical context, Secretary Kerry is the first secretary of state to rely primarily on a state.gov email account." John Wonderlich, a t…

Server security and hacking attempts

In 2008, before Hillary Clinton became Secretary of State, Justin Cooper, a longtime aide to Clinton's husband, former President Bill Clinton, managed the system. Cooper had no security clearance or expertise in computer security. Later, Bryan Pagliano, the former IT director for Clinton's 2008 presidential campaign, was hired to maintain their private email server while Clinton was Secretary of State. Pagliano had invoked the Fifth Amendment during congressional …

Deletion of emails

In 2014, months prior to public knowledge of the server's existence, Clinton chief of staff Cheryl Mills and two attorneys worked to identify work-related emails on the server to be archived and preserved for the State Department. Upon completion of this task in December 2014, Mills instructed Clinton's computer services provider, Platte River Networks (PRN), to change the server's retention period to 60 days, allowing 31,830 older personal emails to be automatically d…

Classified information in emails

In various interviews, Clinton has said that "I did not send classified material, and I did not receive any material that was marked or designated classified." However, in June and July 2016, a number of news outlets reported that Clinton's emails did include messages with some paragraphs marked with a "(c)" for "Confidential." The FBI investigation found that 110 messages contained information that was classified at the time it was sent. Sixty-five of those emails wer…

House Oversight Committee hearing

On July 7, 2016, Comey was questioned for 5 hours by the United States House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. Comey stated that there was "evidence of mishandling" of classified information and that he believed that Clinton was "extremely careless; I think she was negligent." He defended the FBI's recommendation against bringing charges because it "... would have been unfair and virtually unprecedented ..."