who benefited more in the bet the lawyer or banker

by Dr. Forest Nitzsche 5 min read

“The Bet” proves that if a person achieved the highest human wisdom he wouldn’t care about money or material things at all. He would be like Buddha or Jesus or Gandhi or Socrates, all of whom owned nothing and wanted nothing. The banker, in contrast to the lawyer as Chekhov intended, does nothing to improve his mind over the same fifteen years.

Full Answer

Why do bankers and lawyers make the same bet?

The banker and lawyer make the bet for the same reason that most people make a bet. They each believe that their opinion is right and best, and they are willing to risk something to prove it.

Why does the banker keep the lawyer in comfort?

The banker has nothing to gain He probably regrets getting involved in such a contest as soon as he has committed himself. He not only stands to lose a fortune, but he has to keep the lawyer in comfort for as long as the young man chooses to stay. He provides his meals and even offers to serve him wine.

Why does the banker decide to kill the lawyer?

Like the everyday people that the lawyer grows to despise, the banker is ruled by his need to maintain his wealth no matter the cost. He decides to kill the lawyer the night before the bet is completed because he fears that the lawyer will become rich and successful with his money while he himself becomes a beggar.

How does the banker seem to be acknowledging he lost the bet?

The banker seems to be acknowledging that he lost the bet by his thoughts and behavior on the night before the term of imprisonment expired. He sneaks into the prisoner's room for the first time in fifteen years with the intention of murdering him after keeping him in solitary confinement for all that time.

What was the bet between the lawyer and the banker?

They agreed to a bet: if the lawyer could spend fifteen years in total isolation, the banker would pay him two million rubles. The lawyer would have no direct contact with any other person, but could write notes to communicate with the outside world and receive whatever comforts he desired.

Why did the lawyer give up the money in the bet?

Answers 1. The lawyer renounced the bet because during his time in is prison he realized that the money would not afford him true freedom....the money wouldjust become another kind of prison. He didn'twant the money, and he had no desire to become a prisoner of society.

What does the lawyer stake in the bet?

"Gentlemen, I stake two million!" "Agreed! You stake your millions and I stake my freedom!" said the young man.

What do the banker and the lawyer learn from the story the bet?

In Chekhov's "The Bet," the banker and the lawyer both learn the futility of their wager, as they have found that life and its conditions differ greatly from their more youthful perceptions. The lawyer learns that his sweeping statement that life on any terms is better than death is not true.

How much money the lawyer will receive after winning the bet?

Taking this idea as the bet, it was shown at the end of the story that the lawyer lost the bet. The rule was clearly stated, “The slightest attempt on his part to break the conditions, if only two minuets before the end, released the banker from the obligation to pay him two millions” (2).

How much amount would the lawyer get if he wins the bet?

A banker and a lawyer wager a bet at a party. The banker tells the lawyer that if he can endure fifteen years of voluntary captivity, he will be rewarded with two million rubles.

Who in your opinion won the bet between the banker and the lawyer?

The banker certainly wins the bet in terms of the money that he put up. Because the lawyer left the house before the 15 years were up, he loses and the banker keeps his money.

What does the banker value in the bet?

Anton Chekhov's “The Bet” sets up a seemingly simple bet about the nature and value of life. The banker, who believes that the death penalty is more humane and moral than life imprisonment, argues that experiences, pleasures, and relationships are what make life worth living.

How much money does the banker bet on the completion of lawyers term in the cell?

What were the terms of the bet? Answer: The banker placed a bet of two million which he would give the lawyer if he stayed in solitary confinement for five years.

What emotions and desires motivate the lawyer and the banker to make such a bet Are these appropriate emotions and desires Why or why not?

The emotions and desires that motivated the Lawyer and Banker were greed and competitiveness. Engaging in such a bet reveals that they are very competitive and are not very graceful. These emotions and desires are not appropriate because it makes them unhappy.

What was the amount of B between banker and lawyer?

(D) Two billion roubles​ See what the community says and unlock a badge. sonubuxarss is waiting for your help. Add your answer and earn points.

How does the lawyer in The Bet change?

The lawyer in Anton Chekhov 's story " The Bet " is forced to compensate for his confinement by trying to improve his mind through reading, thinking, and writing. He even teaches himself foreign languages. As a result he changes dramatically from being just another professional man motivated by greed and vanity into a sort of holy man who despises material things. Initially the lawyer only had potential. The intelligent reader can’t help thinking that he would do the same thing himself if he had to spend fifteen years in solitary confinement. Naturally he would do a lot of reading, and naturally this would improve his mind and change his character—providing he chose good books. It is reading that changes all of us. If we read great writers we acquire some of their greatness. That would seem to be the main reason for reading the works of writers like Plato and Aristotle. “The Bet” proves that if a person achieved the highest human wisdom he wouldn’t care about money or material things at all. He would be like Buddha or Jesus or Gandhi or Socrates, all of whom owned nothing and wanted nothing.

What happens if a gatherer gathers too much?

If the gatherer gathers too much, nature takes out of the man what she puts into his chest; swells the estate, but kills the owner.

Why does the banker think the lawyer is taking all the risk?

He thinks the lawyer is taking all the risk because the younger man will not be able to stand solitary confinement for more than a few years. The banker actually tries to talk the lawyer out of the bet.

What is the banker's explanation of the bet?

The banker's explanation is also Chekhov's explanation. The bet was the caprice of a pampered man and simple greed on the part of the young lawyer. There is also the certainty, although Chekhov doesn't mention it, that they were both drunk. At any rate, the lawyer begins serving his fifteen-year sentence in one of the banker's guest lodges, and this proves that the bet was made in earnest. The reader forgets about the implausibility of the bet as he becomes interested in the lawyer's ways of coping with solitary confinement, as viewed from the perspective of the banker.

Why do bankers and lawyers make bets?

The banker and lawyer make the bet for the same reason that most people make a bet. They each believe that their opinion is right and best, and they are willing to risk something to prove it.

Why does the banker think the death penalty is more humane?

The banker flat out disagrees. He feels that the death penalty is more humane because it ends a man's life quickly instead of drawing out the process over many years.

Does it take the banker long to tell the lawyer to put his money where his mouth is?

From that point, it doesn't take the banker long to tell the lawyer to put his money where his mouth is.

What does the banker tell the lawyer over dinner?

The banker further goads the lawyer over dinner, telling him to back out before it is too late. He points out... (full context)

How old is the lawyer in The Banker's Party?

The Lawyer Character Analysis. The Lawyer. Just 25 years old when he attends the banker’s party at the beginning of the story, the lawyer initially asserts that life-imprisonment is far preferable to capital punishment.

What does the banker note about the lawyer?

The banker notes that the lawyer is so emaciated by the end of his sentence that he is hard to look at, prematurely aged, and appears ill. This outward appearance contrasts with the lawyer’s own belief that he has bettered himself.

Why is the banker distraught in Part 2?

Part 2. It is fifteen years later and the eve of the lawyer ’s release. The banker is distraught because he cannot afford to pay the two million rubles. ... (full context) The old banker fears that the lawyer will, having won the bet, become wealthy, marry, and enjoy life the same way he... (full context)

What happens to the lawyer in the second year?

In the second year, the lawyer stops playing piano and starts reading classic books. By the fifth year, he is playing... (full context)

What is the lump in the lawyer's skull?

All the wisdom from the books, writes the lawyer, is condensed into a little lump in his skull. He has become cleverer than almost... (full context) The lawyer has come to hold people who appreciate earthly things in contempt, and as such he... (full context) The banker has begun to cry.

Where was the lawyer in the banker's garden house?

The lawyer was imprisoned in the banker’s garden house in complete solitude. The rules were that no visitors, letters or newspapers were allowed. However, he could write letters, and he was permitted to read books, allowed a musical instrument, wine, and cigarettes. The only communication with the outside world for him would be through a small window through which he could write notes and ask for things.

Why did the lawyer refuse to drink wine?

The first year was tough on the lawyer, he refused to drink wine as wine would lead to desire and according to him desire is a man’s worst enemy. Also he didn’t want to smoke as he’d be polluting the little space he was trapped inside. He mainly read light books and played the piano though he was depressed. By the second year he left music and turned toward literature. For the next four years he studied languages, philosophy, history and theology.

What is the Bet in Chekhov?

Anton Chekhov’s ‘The Bet’ is a short story that starts out as a conversation between a few people at a dinner, which then turns to an argument between two young and enthusiastic people. The banker and lawyer disagree on the form of punishments, capital and life imprisonment. The banker says capital punishment is more humane than life imprisonment, the lawyer disagrees. Their argument takes a turn when the banker bets two million that the lawyer cannot go through with imprisonment. The lawyer agrees to the bet.

What is the irony of the story of the lawyer?

The irony of the story was that the lawyer had reached victory but now his desire for it no longer existed so he purposely lost the bet. His behaviour in the end was unpredictable.

Why does the banker decide to kill the lawyer the night before the bet is completed?

He decides to kill the lawyer the night before the bet is completed because he fears that the lawyer will become rich and successful with his money while he himself becomes a beggar.

Why does the banker decide to kill the lawyer?

Like the everyday people that the lawyer grows to despise, the banker is ruled by his need to maintain his wealth no matter the cost. He decides to kill the lawyer the night before the bet is completed because he fears that the lawyer will become rich and successful with his money while he himself becomes a beggar. Upon finding the lawyer’s note and discovering what he has been through physically and psychologically, however, the banker is racked with guilt and self-hatred for making the bet in the first place. Nevertheless, he ultimately decides to protect himself from possible retribution on the part of the lawyer by hiding the letter in his safe. A complex character, the banker reveals both undesirable truths and redeemable realities of the human condition.

Why is the banker distraught?

The banker is distraught because he cannot afford to pay the two million rubles. At the time... (full context) The old banker fears that the lawyer will, having won the bet, become wealthy, marry, and enjoy life... (full context) ...the morning and everyone is asleep. The wind howls and it is pouring rain.

Who said the banking reserves of the United States must be shared by every banking institution in the country?

On October 13, 1917, Woodrow Wilson stated: “It is manifestly imperative that there should be a complete mobilization of the banking reserves of the United States. The burden and the privilege (of the Allied loans) must be shared by every banking institution in the country.

Who financed the Kaiser?

Sometimes, the bankers financed both sides. The Rothschilds’ agents, the Warburg banking house, were financing the Kaiser. Paul Warburg, a naturalized citizen from Germany who had been decorated by the Kaiser in 1912, was vice chairman of the Federal Reserve Board.

Why did the Rothschilds buy Wolff?

The Rothschilds meanwhile bought the German news agency, Wolff, to further control the flow of information to the German people and what the rest of the world would hear from inside Germany. One of the leading executives of Wolff was none other than Max Warburg! The Rothschilds would later buy an interest in the Havas news agency in France ...