what to do if previous lawyer refuses to hand over case related materials

If the attorney fails to turn over your documents in a timely manner, you can file a complaint with the local bar association or state disciplinary committee. "Factual Files" Versus "Work Product" As a client, you're absolutely entitled to factual work product concerning your case, such as deposition testimony, correspondence, and court filings.

Full Answer

What to do if a lawyer refuses to give you papers?

Oct 24, 2011 · The lawyer has a duty to turn over the file to you (with a few exceptions). Therefore, if you make a written demand of him, he is required to give you the file. If the attorney doesn't surrender the file, then, I'd think that your next step would be a complaint to the Bar Association. Report Abuse. Report Abuse.

What happens if a lawyer fails to hand over a file?

Sep 01, 2015 · In effect, Formal Opinion 471 reaffirms a position the ABA took on the issue in 1977. Informal Ethics Opinion 1376 addressed a lawyer’s ethical duty under Rule 9-102 (B) (4) of the Model Code of ...

Can a lawyer refuse to take a case?

Nov 25, 2011 · Simply stated,the "old" lawyer cannot refuse to give the new file to you. Remind him of his/her ethical responsibility and if he/she does not give you a copy of the file within three days, call the California State Bar Association. By Grace... Shawn Jackson ESQ. (707) 584-4529 Call for 30 minute FREE CONSULTATION

What can I do if my attorney won’t turn over documents?

May 29, 2010 · She has to return any documents that belong to you which you gave her. But she does not have to give you any other work product documents or internal documents that she generated. If you feel that she is refusing to return documents which you provided to her, then you should contact the Florida bar and file a complaint.

What is considered conflict of interest in court?

What is it called when a lawyer messes up?

Are lawyers liable for mistakes?

Are attorney notes part of the client file?

What should you not say to a lawyer?

What is the most common complaint against lawyers?

Is a mistake considered negligence?

What are the possible legal consequences of malpractice?

How do you know if your lawyer is selling you out?

What is client property?

How long do attorneys have to keep files in CA?

How long does an attorney have to keep client files in California?

When do lawyers have to provide materials to the client?

But the opinion states that certain materials generated by a lawyer for internal use may have to be provided to the client when the lawyer’s representation of the client is terminated before the matter is completed.

What is Formal Opinion 471?

Formal Opinion 471 analyzes these issues in the context of a lawyer who represented a municipality for 10 years. When the representation terminated, the municipality requested that the lawyer provide its new counsel with all files—open and closed.

Which states have adopted the entire file approach?

Most state jurisdictions have adopted the entire-file approach, and the ABA opinion cites ethics opinions from Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Iowa, Oregon and Virginia as examples of how it is applied.

Which approach is more client friendly?

Some ethics authorities would have preferred to see the ABA adopt the entire-file approach, which they say is more client-friendly.

Do lawyers have to return papers after termination of representation?

In Formal Opinion 471, however, the committee acknowledges that lawyers often must return papers and property to clients after the termination of the representation to protect clients’ interests.

Can a lawyer charge a fee for a copy of my file?

You are entitled to a copy of your file, the lawyer may charge a reasonable fee for same . If there are papers you gave to the lawyer in the file, you are entitled to them back. Go to the attached link for an Ethics Opinion from the State Bar of Michigan that gives you a primer on this issue.

Can an old lawyer refuse to give you a copy of a new case?

Simply stated,the "old" lawyer cannot refuse to give the new file to you. Remind him of his/her ethical responsibility and if he/she does not give you a copy of the file within three days, call the California State Bar Association.#N#By Grace...

1 attorney answer

She has to return any documents that belong to you which you gave her. But she does not have to give you any other work product documents or internal documents that she generated. If you feel that she is refusing to return documents which you provided to her, then you should contact the Florida bar and file a complaint...

Ayuban Antonio Tomas

She has to return any documents that belong to you which you gave her. But she does not have to give you any other work product documents or internal documents that she generated. If you feel that she is refusing to return documents which you provided to her, then you should contact the Florida bar and file a complaint...

What to do if your attorney doesn't comply with your obligations?

If a lawyer does not fulfill those obligations then a client might be able to seek recourse for the lawyer’s behavior.

Why do lawyers use reasonableness?

Most of the Rules of Professional Conduct use a reasonableness standard in order to determine if an attorney’s conduct is appropriate. Since an attorney is a professional, the question would be one of reasonableness for other professional attorneys.

What is the role of an attorney in a legal case?

An attorney must act with reasonable diligence and promptness when representing a client. To that end, the attorney must be careful not to have a conflict of interest in the matter or with clients. Further, the lawyer must consult with and reasonably inform the client of information related to the legal matter at hand.

What is a disciplinary complaint against an attorney?

A client, who believes that an attorney violated his or her ethical obligations, can file a disciplinary complaint against the attorney with the state bar disciplinary committee. Typically, this involves a hearing on the client’s complaint.

What is the responsibility of an attorney?

An attorney has the responsibility to provide competent representation to each client. That means that the attorney must have the legal knowledge and skill to represent the client in a particular matter and be thorough in his or her legal preparation.

Do attorneys have to take a professional responsibility exam?

In most jurisdictions, attorneys are required to take and pass a Professional Responsibility Exam prior to being admitted to the bar. Upon admittance to the bar, attorneys agree to comply with the ethical requirements of their jurisdiction. Most attorneys uphold that promise.

Can a client pursue a malpractice claim in court?

Clients also have the right to pursue legal malpractice claims in court. If a client successfully proves that a lawyer was negligent or guilty of misconduct and that the client suffered monetary damages as a result then the client may recover those damages in a professional malpractice lawsuit.

When switching attorneys, do you want to have access to documents?

Particularly if you're switching attorneys in the middle of a dispute, court case, or other ongoing legal matter, you want your new attorney to have access to these important documents.

How to request a copy of a legal document?

You can ask your lawyer to send the files directly to you or your new attorney, in which case the safest way to make the request is in writing, via letter or email. Alternatively, you can pick up a copy of your file in person (but contact the office first, so that it has time to locate and review the contents of your file and make a copy for you).

How to be respectful of an attorney?

Be respectful of the attorney and professional in your communications; emphasize that the disagreement and decision are not personal.

Can a client have an absolute work product?

Some states, such as California, have ruled that the client is not entitled to "absolute work product." These would include documents that reflect the attorney's impressions, opinions, and legal theories, as well as legal research.

Do you have to hand over documents to an attorney?

Upon request, an attorney is required to promptly hand over the contents of your case files. Under the American Bar Association's Model Rule 1.16 (d) (which has been adopted by most U.S. states), an attorney must, to comply with ethical and professional standards, " [surrender] papers and property to which the client is entitled and [refund] any advance payment of fee or expense that has not been earned or incurred" as soon as the representation is terminated.

Do you have to charge a fee for copying documents?

Your new attorney will want to communicate with that body and make sure it sends any new correspondence, such as motions from the opposing party, directly to the new attorney.) Your attorney should not charge you a fee for copying the documents in your file.

Do old lawyers deserve more money?

You may feel that your old lawyer doesn't deserve any more money. But you need to weigh these costs against the harm that could be done to your legal interests if your old lawyer acts in bad faith and holds documents hostage. It might be better to pay your bill in order to facilitate a clean break of the relationship.

What to do if your attorney messes up your case?

You do have options if your attorney messes up your case. Generally, your possibilities depend on the type of mistake and how much it affected your case. For minor mistakes, you can fire your attorney and get a second opinion. You can also report them for failing to meet their duties of professional conduct. For the most serious of cases, you can ...

What happens if a lawyer doesn't take a case?

If they do not and they still take the case, they are making an error and opening themselves up to legal malpractice claims. They break their fiduciary duty to a client: A lawyer’s main job is to protect and advocate for their client. This means that they have to act in the best interests of the client and they cannot act in their own best interest.

What are the common mistakes made by attorneys?

There can be severe legal consequences if your attorney makes a mistake in our case. Some common errors include: Missing a statute of limitations: This is a time limit that you have to comply with when filing a lawsuit.

What happens if there is no harm to you?

If there is no harm to you, then there is no legal malpractice claim. For instance, there is no damage if an attorney made a mistake in filing a document but the judge did not add any penalties because of it.

What happens if you don't have a strong case?

This means that if you did not have a strong case to begin with, you would be unlikely to win a legal malpractice case.

What is legal malpractice?

Legal malpractice is when an attorney makes a grievous error in handling a case. Lawyers are held to a general standard and codes of ethical and professional conduct. Depending on the severity, when they break these rules they may be guilty of medical malpractice.

Why are lawyers more likely to make mistakes?

They are more likely to make a mistake if they are specialists in a certain type of law and have no experience in the legal rules associated with your case. They must have some competence in the core of your case. If they do not and they still take the case, they are making an error and opening themselves up to legal malpractice claims.

What documents must a lawyer surrender?

Applying Model Rule 1.16 (d), the ABA determined that the lawyer must surrender any materials provided by the client; legal documents filed with a tribunal (or those completed and ready to be filed); executed instruments like contracts; orders or other records of a tribunal; correspondence in connection with the representation (including emails retained according to the lawyer’s document retention policy); discovery or evidentiary exhibits (including interrogatories and their answers, deposition transcripts, expert witness reports and witness statements, and exhibits); legal opinions issued at the client’s request; and third-party evaluations or records paid for by the client.

When should a lawyer provide notice of retention policy?

The lawyer should provide notice of the retention policy at the outset in a retainer agreement and/or at the end of representation in a closing letter. Jorgenson adds, “Client notice of the firm’s file retention period may render client demand for documents after expiration of the retention period unreasonable, or at least less reasonable.”

What is the ABA opinion on return of client files?

In July 2015, the American Bar Association (ABA) provided further guidance on the return of client files in Formal Opinion 471, Ethical Obligations of Lawyer to Surrender Papers and Property to which Former Client is Entitled. The ABA noted that the lawyer must, at a minimum, turn over materials that would likely harm the client’s interest if not provided.

What is the basis for ethics complaint?

Failure to promptly hand over the file to the departing client or to his new counsel is a strong basis for an ethics complaint and a common reason for disciplinary action.

What is the ABA model rule for a lawyer?

Applying Model Rule 1.15, the ABA determined that the lawyer must return all property that came into his possession in connection with the representation. This includes tangible personal property; items with intrinsic value or that affect valuable rights, such as securities, negotiable instruments, wills, or deeds; and any documents provided by the client.

What does it mean when a lawyer is terminated from representation?

Lawyers who are terminated from representation or withdraw from representation must protect the client’s interest by surrendering papers and property that belong to the client. Although the ABA Model Rules and Formal Opinions provide guidance, the state rules of professional conduct are what governs.

Can a lawyer charge for a client's file?

Lawyers may charge a client for the reasonable costs of duplicating or retrieving the client’s file only if they had a written fee agreement, at the outset, allowing such a charge. Billing the client for such costs, without prior written authorization from the client, violates Rule 1.16 (f).

What happens if a lawyer doesn't take your case?

Additionally, the cost of developing the testimony to prove up your case has to be factored into the analysis of the attorney. If the cost of the expected depositions exceeds the expected return on the case, an attorney most likely will not accept the case. If a lawyer doesn’t take your case, you can get a second opinion from another lawyer who has ...

Why won't a lawyer take my case?

Here are the top 7 reasons why a lawyer won’t take your case: 1. There is No Money to be Made in Your Case. There is a real cost associated with trying a case. For a lawyer to take a case, the case needs to have the potential to recover more money than the lawyer will have to invest to try the case.

What happens if you are dropped from another law firm?

If your case has been repeatedly “released” or “dropped” from another law firm, subsequent attorneys will think twice about taking your case from either a liability perspective or an unreasonable expectation perspective.

How long do you have to sue for a personal injury?

For example, in some states, the statute of limitations on personal injury claims is two years, so that means you have two years to sue for a personal injury case.

Why is it important for a lawyer to protect their reputation?

Lawyers have an interest to protect their own reputations since a strong reputation will draw in more clients, just as a weak reputation will do exactly the opposite. In personal injury cases, how badly you’re injured is an important factor in a case.

What does it mean when a lawyer takes on a new client?

7. They don’t like you. A lawyer is never obligated to take your case. Taking on a new client means starting a new working relationship – and relationships are a two-way street. If you’re perceived to be difficult to work with, obnoxious, or abrasive, then they may choose to pass on your case.

Why are cases turned down?

Often times, many cases are turned down because the potential client appears to be shopping around for a lawyer based upon the feedback they receive on the potential value of the case.

What to look for when a lawyer has not been paid?

The first place to look for issues regarding representation when a lawyer has not been paid is in the client agreement that he or she has in place and that the client signed. This agreement may state how the lawyer will be paid and when the lawyer can withdraw from representation. There may be a clause that states that failing to pay for ...

What happens if a lawyer withdraws from a case?

If a lawyer does withdraw from a case, he or she still has ongoing duties. For example, he or she must maintain client confidentiality. Additionally, if the lawyer has any of the client’s property, he or she must return it. He or she must provide the client’s file upon request and cooperate with the transfer process.

How to withdraw from a case?

Typically, a lawyer must get the judge’s permission before he or she can withdraw from a case. A judge is less likely to approve the withdrawal if the client will be prejudiced or otherwise adversely affected by the lawyer’s withdrawal, such as if the case is close to trial. A lawyer makes a motion to be relieved as counsel before he or she will be permitted to stop working on the case. He or she cannot simply refuse to pass along information or act on the client’s behalf simply because the judge has not yet granted the motion. The court can refuse to honor the request to withdraw. If the court does grant the motion to withdraw, the client may have additional time to find new counsel.

What are the rules of conduct for a lawyer?

The professional rules of conduct may permit the lawyer to withdraw when he or she will not be negatively impacted by the withdrawal or if there is a suitable replacement that is willing to take on the case. The professional rules of conduct often allow the lawyer to abandon the client even in some situations when it may harm the client’s interests.

Why is it less likely to allow a client to withdraw from a case?

Prejudicing the Client’s Position. The court is less likely to allow withdrawal if withdrawal would materially prejudice the client’s ability to litigate the case. This may be the case when a trial is imminent. Additionally, the court may not honor the request to withdraw if the facts giving rise to the request to withdrawal are in dispute.

Why do lawyers withdraw from their jobs?

One common reason is because the client has not paid the bill. Lawyers are not expected to work without compensation. The professional rules of conduct may permit the lawyer to withdraw when he or she will not be negatively impacted by the withdrawal or if there is a suitable replacement that is willing to take on the case.

Can a lawyer sue a client for owed money?

If the lawyer is owed money, he or she may have a right to sue the client. He or she cannot realistically be opposed to the client and provide proper representation in his or her case.