Full Answer
If you have questions about divorce trials, you should contact a local divorce lawyer for advice.
Our discussion of California divorce trials start with a fact. Many divorce lawyers don't know what they are doing in a trial. They don't know the rules of evidence as well as they should. They proceed unprepared.
They are often the same issues that cause a couple to argue and disagree before working things out when there is no trial. The two biggest issues are how assets should be divided, and custody and support issues when there are children involved. How assets are divided varies from state to state.
Divorce trials are similar to what you see on TV: each attorney will present opening statements to the trial judge explaining what they anticipate the evidence will show. Witnesses will be called by both sides and cross-examined by the other side. Evidence will be presented to the court to help both sides articulate their divorce case.
If you have questions about divorce trials, you should contact a local divorce lawyer for advice.
When witnesses are done testifying for the plaintiff, the defendant (also known as the respondent) has the right to cross-examine or question the witnesses on matters that were explored during the initial testimony.
You and your attorney may call expert witnesses to testify about complicated topics. For example, vocational experts are often called to testify about how much income the spouses can earn based on job skills, work histories, and education. Or, an attorney may call a property appraiser to give an opinion about the value of the family home. In contested custody cases, judges or parents often request a custody evaluation, which would require the expert evaluator to testify about any custody recommendations.
Then the judge issues a written order that finalizes the divorce and disposes of all the issues presented at trial. After receiving the written order, the parties discuss the order with their attorneys and consider whether to appeal all or part of it. If neither side appeals within a certain number of days, then the court's divorce order becomes final.
Of course, the best scenario is one where divorcing spouses work together—or through their attorneys—to settle all of their issues without going to court.
The defense then calls its own witnesses and admits its own exhibits. The defense rests at the conclusion of its case. The judge will grant the plaintiff “rebuttal” time. The plaintiff carries the burden of proof during civil trials, so the plaintiff also gets the last word. Rebuttal can’t exceed the boundaries or subject matter of the testimony that’s already in evidence.
If the day wears on and the case still isn’t settled, you and your attorney can use downtime during the lunch hour or recesses to try again to reach an agreement that satisfies everyone.
During a trial, both sides will present evidence and call witnesses to support their claims on issues such as a division of assets, child custody, spousal and child support and other related matters.
If your divorce is headed for trial, you absolutely need to be prepared for what’s to come. Keep in mind that only about 5% of divorces end up going to trial. Even if you think you and your spouse are likely to settle before going to trial, it’s still helpful to know how divorce trials work so you’re prepared for the worst-case scenario. ...
The end of a divorce trial rarely means the end of a divorce case. For starters, the judge still needs to make final rulings on all the outstanding issues. He or she will either do this on their own, but oftentimes they will also ask both attorneys to submit proposed final judgments.
Judges will decide things such as temporary child custody and visitation privileges, temporary alimony and child support, which spouse is responsible for a variety of financial matters (mortgage, childcare, health insurance, etc.), and emergency issues, such as temporary restraining orders.
Trials are lengthy, stressful, and expensive. That’s why only about about 5% of all divorces ends up in a full-blown, contested trial. Often times, the stakes are high, and there’s no guarantee of the outcome. That’s why spouses opt for other types of settlements before their cases end up in court.
Written order. The judge will issue a written order that finalizes the divorce and rules on all the issues presented at trial.
Most of the time, you and your attorney will need to accomplish the following before you go to trial. Preparation of financial affidavits . A judge will want to know what your financial position is just before you go to trial. An exchange of disclosures .
Witnesses might include neighbors, friends, co-workers, and other parties who know both spouses. If the couple has any children, witnesses might also include teachers, nannies, daycare instructors, and other important figures. The witness can vouch for either parent’s capabilities, their shortcomings, and so on.
This judgment will include orders regarding each key aspect of divorce, from child custody to asset division. Once a final judgment has been reached, an official document will record the ruling, and each party will sign.
The Divorce Trial Process: 1. The Petitioner Presents: The spouse who filed for divorce, the petitioner, will present their case before the judge first. This presentation will include key documents about finances, assets, properties, children, and anything else pertinent to the marriage. 2.
First, you and your spouse will need to file a petition for divorce, serve or respond to the petition, attend temporary hearings, and more.
If mediation isn’t an option for you, or if you aren’t able to resolve everything in mediation, a divorce trial will be your last option.
Once a final judgment has been reached, an official document will record the ruling, and each party will sign. Once the final judgment has been signed by each spouse and the judge, the divorce will be final. To learn more about the divorce procedure in Washington state, visit our Divorce Process page.
Posted on October 21, 2020 09:45am. The trial is the very last step in any divorce process, which means there are plenty of opportunities to avoid trial altogether. Mediation and settlement options can help resolve the details of a divorce without presenting the case in court, but this isn’t always a viable option for every couple.
A divorce trial is the same as any other trial, in the sense that the family court judge will take evidence and then make a decision.
Step 1: Meet With Your Attorney. This should be your first step when dealing with any legal problem. Your attorney will already be familiar with many of the issues you will be going through and that you will be going through in the near future, so you can get legal advice and guidance from the beginning of your case.
It can be especially difficult when divorcing a narcissist because a narcissist won’t be able to empathize with your pain and cause you emotional harm because of a sense of entitlement and an inability to understand your feelings.
Most people become so focused on the divorce that they forget to meet their own physical and emotional needs.
Sometimes the legal issues make it impossible for couples to agree on a resolution because there are rules about child support, child custody, alimony/spousal maintenance in Arizona, attorney’s fees, and other issues that make it difficult for the individuals to agree.
Among the top reasons for divorce, there are several that involve communication and emotions.
You can even stop during the trial and agree to terms. That doesn’t mean that you should feel afraid of going to trial and agree to terms against your best interests, because your divorce attorney will back you up all the way. Your attorney is your advocate and will fight for you if necessary.
If the receiving spouse contests what’s in the divorce complaint, then you’ll need to litigate your case through the discovery process and eventually trial. Early on in your divorce, you and your spouse must submit financial disclosures detailing your income and monthly expenses. Your financial disclosures should estimate your monthly expenses on ...
Once your exhibit is marked, you must show it to your spouse and/or attorney, and you’ll need to have at least a few additional copies for the judge and court reporter to review and add to the divorce record. Things can get complicated if your spouse’s attorney objects to the exhibit or disputes its authenticity. If you have additional questions about using evidence or exhibits at trial, contact a local family law attorney for advice.
Any evidence you submit at trial should be accurate and up-to date. A judge will rely on your income, asset, and debt information when determining property awards, child support, and alimony. You’ll introduce written evidence at trial in the form of exhibits.
Your financial disclosures should estimate your monthly expenses on items like rent/mortgage, utilities, food, transportation costs, insurance premiums, and other personal care costs. If your income or expenses change during the divorce process, you must update your disclosures and provide verifying documentation.
There are many ways to present evidence. Some evidence that a judge will consider at trial will be provided through your own testimony. You may also call witnesses in your case, including family, friends, and experts. It’s important that if your experts have relied on certain evidence to form their opinions, that you make ...
A judge may also need bank statements, tax returns, and property and asset information to make a fair division of the marital estate. Your child's school and medical records may be pertinent if you’re seeking primary physical custody based on your spouse’s failure to meet your children’s basic needs.
This information should come out naturally during the discovery process. You and your spouse can settle your case at any time. However, if you’re unable to settle, a judge will set your case for trial.
When you go to court, your lawyer will generally do most of the talking on your behalf. Unless the judge asks you a direct question, you probably won’t say much at all. However, your ex will be expected to speak for him- or herself. Your attorney will tell you what to expect in court before you go, which you can pass on to your ex if you’re so inclined. However, you aren’t obligated to share any information.
Your ex cannot talk to your attorney for advice. Your lawyer and your ex can pass on information to each other, because your ex has no one to speak on his or her behalf, but that’s the legal extent of their communication with each other.
The Downside of Self-Representation During Divorce. While divorce seems like a straightforward process, that’s not always the case. In fact, there usually are back-and-forth documents that often need to be filed with the appropriate clerks within certain timeframes.
There are many websites that provide general information about divorce, but they can’t replace the case-specific advice that only an attorney can give . Well-meaning friends and family might be able to provide personal anecdotes about their own child custody , property division and other divorce experiences, but every case has its own nuances; what works for one person won’t work for another, even if the situation is similar.
Your divorce begins when either spouse files a petition for divorce (also called a “divorce complaint”) and properly serves it on the other spouse. There are strict deadlines for responding to a divorce petition. At this point, the receiving spouse can file an answer to the divorce petition or accept ...
The purpose of a pretrial conference is to help a judge understand what issues still need to be resolved at trial. If your judge has an extremely busy schedule, or it looks like you’ll have a long divorce trial, you may have to wait several months to have your day in court. In some cases, a judge will require divorcing couples to attend ...
Most of the information you’ll need to prepare your disclosures was probably uncovered during the divorce discovery process. During discovery, you and your spouse had to supply financial disclosures, submit interrogatories, attend depositions, and maybe even participate in custody evaluations. During the discovery process you probably discovered all your spouse’s assets and debts, income information, and you may have a good idea about your chances at getting alimony, child support, and/or custody at trial.
You’re divorce is almost over when you receive a notice of a pretrial conference. Learn more about what you can expect and how to prepare for your pretrial hearing.
Alternatively, a couple can settle their case at any time before trial. You and your spouse can hire a mediator, attend a settlement conference or try to work out an agreement on your own. It’s important to ensure that any settlement agreement addresses all issues in your divorce. Any issues not resolved in a settlement must be decided at trial. ...
At this point, the receiving spouse can file an answer to the divorce petition or accept the divorce complaint’s terms. A spouse who doesn’t file a response to the complaint risks having a default divorce entered. Once a spouse files an answer, the divorce case will proceed through the discovery process and eventually trial.
In some situations, a judge may prefer to consult only with the attorneys involved. For example, a judge may take each attorney back in chambers to discuss each side’s stance on certain issues, find out what witnesses will be presented, discuss any potential expert testimony, and get an overall feeling for the case.
There are four subjects that normally require attention in a divorce trial, and each of them may involve witnesses: the grounds (reasons) for the divorce. child support and spousal support (alimony) custody and parenting time (visitation), and. property division. Many times, family members and friends will be brought in to testify as to ...
Grounds for Divorce. This used to be an area in which spouses frequently called witnesses to prove or disprove accusations, such as adultery or abuse. Having a witness was a good way to try to avoid a he-said/she-said standoff.
Parents often resolve child-related issues on their own. However, a divorce with children can be the most contentious of all types of divorce trials. And this intensity ratchets up exponentially if there's an allegation of child abuse or endangerment.
You couldn't resolve your divorce issues, and now you have to go to trial. It's pretty much a given that you and your spouse will have to testify, but whether you'll need others to testify as well depends in large part on what you're fighting about. In certain instances, bringing in witnesses may be unavoidable.
Child support trials don't normally require testimony from anyone other than the parents. The court gathers financial data from the parents early on in the divorce process, and applies that data to the state's child support guidelines, which will result in a support amount. The procedure is relatively cut and dried.
With certain exceptions—such as some cases involving juveniles—court proceedings are generally open to everyone. This is true for divorce, as well.
This is not to say that some people won't want their pound of flesh and demand that the divorce proceed on fault-based grounds. If that's the case, witnesses will probably be necessary.
In Orange County, a trial of 5 hours or less is “short cause.”. Get longer than 5 hours and the divorce case flirts with “long cause” status. Divorce trials that go one or more days are sometimes set during consecutive days but often spread out over a week or more.
Divorce trial subpoenas compel something - that something may be a person to appear in court, documents or both. Witnesses and documents are common elements of a California divorce trial. If "consumer records" are being subpoenaed (that term is very broad and covers more categories than you may realize), there are certain minimum timelines and specific rules that apply.
There is often too much at stake. Knowledge of the law, a clear understanding of the facts and evidence the lawyer wishes to use, how to do it and clearly defined goals are the key to success. California divorce trials also need realistic expectations.
At a California divorce trial, the issue of attorney fees is typically presented by an attorney fee declaration from the lawyer and the itemized billing statements provided to the Court and the other lawyer. Attorney-client privileged portions of the bills within the billing entries should be redacted. There usually isn’t extensive testimony on attorney fees but there is a lot of argument if the fee request is a large one. Common arguments at a divorce trial for fees are that the fees requested are necessary to level the field because of a disparity and access to income and money to pay for fees. Common arguments at a divorce trial against fees are the fees expended were not reasonable or necessary, the disparity in income is not a large one or each spouse has necessary access to funds.
When they go to a trial in a divorce case, it’s usually because there are allegations of abuse (child abuse, substance abuse, etc.), neglect or domestic violence. Parenting time disputes, by themselves, usually don’t make it to a trial but there are exceptions.
There are several rules in play for a California divorce trial. The first are California statutes. These are “code” books like the Family Code, Code of Civil Procedure, Evidence Code, etc. The second are California Rules of Court. These “Rules” will either piggyback on the “code” or have their own procedural guidelines.
If they cannot, the judge will set a trial date. Most divorce trials in California are set between 60-150 days away, depending on that particular judge’s calendar. Los Angeles, San Diego, Riverside, San Bernardino, Kern and Ventura counties also have their own procedures for setting a case for trial.