what irony is employed when judge danforth says to giles corey "oh? it is a proper lawyer?"

by Kristy Hirthe 4 min read

The irony in this statement is found in Danforth's belief that he doesn't "deal in lies" when the court's entire case has been built on the lies of the girls. All those who have confessed have lied. Proctor, by recanting his false confession (by tearing it up) is actually telling the truth, but Danforth will not listen to it.

It is a proper lawyer?" What is his opinion of Giles Corey? The irony in Judge Danforth's statement is that he should know Corey's background due to his dad being involved in a court case with him and he should know that it is law that the defendant has the right to a lawyer.

Full Answer

What is ironic about Judge Danforth's statement?

Danforth: "...children, the law and Bible damn all bearers of false witness". In what ways is Danforth's statement ironic? He takes Abagail's unsupported word as hard evidence, whereas he expects the defenders to bring more proof.

What is ironic about Danforth's request for proof from Giles?

What is ironic about Danforth's request for proof from Giles? It is ironic because Giles always has to put through proof in the court.

What does Judge Danforth do to Giles since he has refused to provide the name?

Giles refuses to name the man who gave him the information because he does not want to open him to Putnam's vengeance. Danforth arrests Giles for contempt of court. Danforth sends for Abigail and her troop of girls.

Why does Danforth dismiss Giles evidence?

Why does Danforth dismiss Giles' deposition? Giles will not reveal the name of his source. What does Abigail succeed in doing in this act? She wins Mary Warren back to her side.

What is Giles Corey's proof of this charge and why won't he reveal it to the court?

What is Giles Corey's proof that Thomas Putnam is "reaching out for land"? Why won't he reveal his source? A man told Giles that he heard Thomas Putnam say that Ruth gave Putnam a gift of land by accusing George Jacobs. Giles will not reveal the name because he doesn't want the man arrested.

Why does Danforth say no to request?

Why does Danforth refuse to postpone the hangings? Danforth refuses to postpone the hangings because it would admit some wrongdoing or doubt, a "floundering" on their part and it would also cast doubt on the executions and condemnations of the who have already been hanged.

Why does Corey refuse to give out any more names?

Why does Giles Corey refuse to reveal the names of the witnesses against Putnam? He was given the information in confidence and will not renege on his promise to keep the names private.

Does Giles refusal to name his informant help or hurt his credibility?

Does Giles Corey's refusal to name his informant help or hurt his credibility? Explain your answer. Corey's refusal to name informant hurts his credibility because Danforth and the court might think the informant does not exist.

What does Giles Corey allege in his deposition about Thomas Putnam's motives?

What does Giles Corey allege in his deposition about Thomas Putnam's motives? Giles claims that Thomas Putnam is accusing people so that he can buy their land once they are executed.

How is Judge Danforth characterized Support your response with a specific detail?

How is Judge Danforth characterized? Support your response with a specific detail. Judge Danforth is a "by-the-law" man who judges with law and religion combined.

Why is Judge Danforth responsible for the trials?

Judge Danforth is responsible because he is not concerned about justice, all he cares about is being correct about the witch trials. Lastly Thomas Putnam is guilty of causing the witch trials because he was able to have people accuse other people so he could claim their land for himself.

How did Judge Danforth abuse his power?

Danforth: Judge, Jury, and Executioner Judge Danforth's position in the crucible is the Judge assigned to the proceedings of the Salem witch trials. Instead of treating this immense responsibility with the respect and restraint that is needed, Danforth abused his power by betraying the people of Salem and the Law.