what does it mean when va lawyer admits mistakes

Clear and Unmistakable Error Claims Clear and unmistakable error (referred to as CUE) involves a situation where the correct facts as they were known at the time were not before the VA or the law and regulations in effect at the time of the VA’s decision were not applied correctly.

Full Answer

What are the most common VA mistakes?

One of the most common mistakes the VA makes is failing to notify you when they need evidence. After you submit an application, the VA must tell you what evidence they’ll need to make a decision about your case. This notice should also tell you which evidence you’ll be responsible for gathering and what they’ll gather on your behalf.

Did the VA make an error in my claim?

Getting a favorable decision from the VA is a victory in and of itself. However, just because the VA granted your claim, does not mean they haven’t made any errors. It is important to make sure the VA gets the rating and the effective date right as well.

What are some common mistakes VA makes when adjudicating Veterans’ Claims for TDIU?

A common mistake VA makes when adjudicating veterans’ claims for TDIU is considering a veteran’s age to deny benefits. Specifically, VA will often state that a veteran retired or is no longer working because of his or her age rather than considering the impact of his or her service-connected conditions.

What happens if the VA fails to follow the law?

Sometimes, at the Regional Office or at the Board of Veterans Appeals (BVA), the VA fails to adhere to the laws and regulations that govern its operations. When this is the case, the oversight of the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims may be necessary to obtain a successful outcome in your case. Talk to a Lawyer.

What does it mean when the VA says they are correcting an error?

We corrected an error A judge at the Board of Veterans' Appeals either: Found an error and had it corrected, or. Made a decision that changes your disability rating or eligibility for benefits.

How long does the VA have to correct an error?

How Long Do VA CUE “Claims” Take? Under the AMA, the VA's goal for responding to appeals is roughly 125 days. Typically, for HLR and supplemental claims, the process is quicker. When done correctly CUE requests are straightforward and decisions can be made easier.

Does the VA make mistakes?

Some of VA's errors occur more frequently than others, including those related to (1) total disability based on individual unemployability (TDIU); (2) orthopedic claims; (3) Compensation and Pension examinations; (4) effective dates; and (5) psychiatric conditions.

Can the VA reverse a decision?

The Board of Veterans' Appeals is the appellate body of the Department of Veterans Affairs that has the ability to review and reverse decisions issued by the Regional Office (RO).

What percentage of VA appeals are successful?

Historically, the VA disability appeal success rate for veterans has been considered relatively low. According to the Board of Veterans Appeals (BVA) Annual Report for Fiscal Year 2021 recorded a 32% acceptance rate for legacy decisions and 38.1% for AMA decisions.

How long does it take a veteran law judge to make a decision?

The Veterans Benefits Administration usually takes 12-18 months to review new appeals and decide whether to grant some or all of the appeal. When you request a review from a Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans' Appeals, it could take 5-7 years for you to get a decision.

Can a veteran be denied VA benefits?

Some of the reasons why the VA may reject a claim for benefits include: Failure to prove that the disabling condition resulted from an injury during active duty. Failure to prove that the disabling condition began during active duty. Failure to prove that the disabling condition is related to military service.

What percentage of PTSD claims are approved?

The average (mean) VA disability rating for PTSD is between 50 percent and 70 percent, with 53.9% of veterans being rated between 50% and 70%.

Does the VA investigate disability claims?

After you are awarded disability compensation benefits, the VA will evaluate whether your disability is such that you ought to be scheduled for a future reexamination to determine if your benefits need to be adjusted. Types of disabilities subject to reexamination are those that can be expected to improve over time.

What is the VA 5 year rule?

The VA disability rating 5-year rule states that the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) cannot reduce a veteran's disability rating if it has been in place for five years or more unless the condition shows sustained improvement over time. In this situation, the veteran's rating is considered a stabilized rating.

How often are VA claims denied?

The VA denies around 30% of disability claims each year. It can be frustrating to learn that your claim for VA compensation was denied. You may feel like you did everything they asked of you and provided all the evidence necessary to get the disability compensation you deserve.

How can you lose your VA benefits?

VA disability compensation payments are reduced if a Veteran is convicted of a felony and imprisoned for more than 60 days. Veterans rated 20 percent or more are limited to the 10 percent disability rate. For a Veteran whose disability rating is 10 percent, the payment is reduced by one-half.

How do I correct a dd214 error?

If you believe you are the victim of an error or injustice which affects your military record, you may apply for a Correction of Military Records by completing and submitting a DD Form 149, Application for Correction of Military Record. Submit your completed DD Form 149 to the appropriate address on page 2 of the form.

How do I correct a mistake on my dd214?

Correction to Veterans Military Records. If you are in need of a correction to your Certificate of Release of Discharge from Active Duty (DD Form 214), you must submit a written request for a correction (DD Form 215) and include a copy of your DD Form 214.

What do I do if my VA claim is denied?

To file an appeal with the VA Regional Office that denied you benefits, you will need to submit a Notice of Disagreement (NOD). The VA doesn't have an NOD form, so you can use Statement in Support of Claim form. You can find this form at www.va.gov/vaforms/.

How do I get a DD 215?

How To Get A DD Form 215Sign in.Click on Correspondence/ Documentation.Select Defense Personnel Records Information (DPRIS) from the drop-down menu.Choose the Personnel File tab.Select Request My Personnel File.Fill out the form.In the Document Index section, select DD 215.Click on the Create and Send Request button.

What is the mistake VA makes when adjudicating veterans’ claims for TDIU?

A common mistake VA makes when adjudicating veterans’ claims for TDIU is considering a veteran’s age to deny benefits. Specifically, VA will often state that a veteran retired or is no longer working because of his or her age rather than considering the impact of his or her service-connected conditions.

What do VA examiners need to include in their report?

VA examiners must include rationale for any medical opinions they provide, along with the evidence they used to reach their conclusions. If examiners only list medical treatment records or medical research that does not support the veteran’s claim, an argument can be made that they ignored more favorable information.

Why does the VA deny TDIU?

VA Denies TDIU Because the Veteran is Working. In some cases, VA errs in denying TDIU on the grounds that the veteran is working. Here, VA fails to take into account marginal employment and protected work environments – two situations in which veterans may be able to continue working while receiving TDIU benefits.

What degree can a veteran bend forward?

For example, a veteran might be able to bend forward 85 degrees, but starts to experience pain at 55 degrees.

What is VA orthopedics?

Typically, VA will rate orthopedic conditions based on diagnostic testing of a veteran’s range of motion. This type of diagnostic testing is typically performed during a Compensation and Pension (C&P) examination. However, VA examiners should also consider functional loss, flare-ups, and how the veteran’s disability impacts his or her daily life overall when rating orthopedic conditions.

What is the VA rating for mental health?

Mental health conditions are rated at 0, 10, 30, 50, 70, or 100 percent using VA’s General Rating Formula for Mental Disorders based on the veteran’s overall level of social and occupational impairment. Sometimes VA will ask that veterans provide a stressor, or a traumatic event that occurred during service, that caused their mental health condition. If veterans are unable to provide this stressor, they are denied benefits. However, it is important to note that stressor verification is only required in claims for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Therefore, if a veteran is claiming service connection for an acquired psychiatric condition or depression, it is incorrect for VA to deny benefits based on a lack of stressor.

What is the effective date for VA disability?

4. Effective Dates. An effective date is the date that a benefit became effective and it is used by VA as a start date for the payment of disability compensation. Importantly, the effective date of a claim impacts the amount of retroactive benefits, or back pay, a veteran will receive.

Why is the VA required to provide a medical exam?

The VA is required to provide this exam when there isn't sufficient medical evidence in the file and there is: evidence that you have a current disability.

What is the BVA in VA appeals?

If you appealed to the Board of Veterans Appeals (BVA), the BVA is required to include in its decisions a discussion of the facts and law on which the decision is based. You will need an attorney's help to check whether the BVA failed to properly address medical or lay evidence that helped your claim. Consult with a VA disability attorney to determine if this is a basis for appeal in your case.

Does the VA have a duty to get records?

By law, the VA must help you obtain records that support your claim for benefits. If you have identified these records adequately, the VA has a duty to get these records for you. This means you must provide enough information about when and where you were treated so that the VA could reasonably locate your records.

Do you have to give consent to a lawyer to text you?

You are not required to provide consent as a condition of service. Attorneys have the option, but are not required, to send text messages to you. You will receive up to 2 messages per week from Martindale-Nolo. Frequency from attorney may vary.

Can you win an appeal against a VA disability claim?

You may be able to win an appeal if you can show that the VA made a mistake on your claim; for instance, the VA evaluated your disability under the wrong code in the Schedule of Rating Disabilities, which gave you a lower rating. Sometimes veterans are denied benefits because of procedural mistakes made by the VA.

Why did the VA Regional Office err?

The court agreed that the VA Regional Office erred when it did not provide a medical opinion to the surviving spouse. However, because the Court could find no evidence that the Veteran had been diagnosed with PTSD, it concluded that the error was harmless – essentially, it concluded that no medical opinion could connect an undiagnosed condition ...

What is the rule of prejudicial error?

§ 2111), which requires courts to review cases for errors of law, without regard to errors that do not affect a party’s substantial rights.

What is the VA form for TDIU?

So when they assign TDIU, they’ll assign it just on the date that the veteran request TDIU and VA often requires a form called the VA Form 21-8940, and so the day that VA receives that form is generally the day that VA is going to assign that date, and that’s not necessarily the right date.

Can a veteran testify to their disability?

One, the veterans, the most competent person to testify to how their pain affects them on a day to day basis, and then their family members can also witness these things. That corroborating evidence can go a long way and showing VA that their disability is more severe than the range of motion that actually reflects.

What is the most difficult case in VA law?

In my opinion, CUE cases as a whole are the most difficult cases in veterans law. CUE can be difficult to spot, and it can be difficult to convince VA adjudicators that there was a mistake made in the prior decision and that if this mistake had not been made, the veteran would have been awarded his benefits.

What happens if the VA agrees to a CUE?

If the VA agrees that the old decision contains CUE, it will pay the veteran back to the date of that old decision. Generally speaking, to win a CUE case, the veteran must show that a prior decision contains some kind of a mistake, and it must be undebatable that if this particular mistake had not been made, the veteran would have been awarded ...

What does CUE mean in VA?

CUE is short for “clear and unmistakable error.”. Basically, when a veteran brings a “CUE claim,” he is asking the VA to revise a decision that is final (meaning, the time to appeal the decision has passed). Any decision, no matter how old, is subject to at least one CUE challenge.

Can a veteran rest his CUE argument?

Similarly, the veteran must rest his CUE arguments on the law that existed at the time of the prior decision. This requires, of course, knowing what the law was at the time of the prior decision! There are also certain types of mistakes that can never amount to CUE. For example, let’s say the VA should have given the veteran a medical examination ...

When does the VA issue new evidence?

The veteran submits new and material evidence one month before the end of the appeal period. If the veteran’s claim is eventually granted down the road, the effective date should be the date of his original claim. However, the VA will usually miss this and assign an effective date that corresponds with the date of the claim ...

What is the intent to file VA?

Veterans may file what is known as an “intent to file” to preserve an earlier effective date. Currently, this is done by submitting a VA Form 21-0966. Prior to March 2015, veterans could file what was known as an “informal claim.”. Regardless of what they are called, the purpose of these actions is to preserve an earlier effective date.

How long does it take for a veteran to file for VA benefits?

Specifically, whenever a veteran (or their qualifying survivor/dependent) first files for any type of benefit from the VA, the VA must provide “information concerning benefits not later than three months after the date of filing.”.

Is the VA required to provide aid and assistance to veterans?

Also, the VA is required to provide “aid and assistance to members of the Armed Forces, veterans, and eligible dependents in the preparation and presentation of VA claims.”. Unlike the previous two paths to an earlier effective date, this one is not a regulation. Instead, this path is more of a theory.

Does the VA make errors on the effective date?

Common Effective Date Errors the VA Makes. Getting a favorable decision from the VA is a victory in and of itself. However, just because the VA granted your claim, does not mean they haven’t made any errors. It is important to make sure the VA gets the rating and the effective date right as well. These are both areas that ...

Why is the Board of Veterans Appeals waiting for their decision?

The Board of Veterans’ Appeals is waiting for their decision because it may affect your appeal. Status. The Board made a decision on your appeal. What it means. The Board of Veterans’ Appeals sent you a decision letter about your appeal. Status. Your appeal was merged.

Who reviews a Veterans appeal?

A Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals is reviewing your appeal. The judge is getting more evidence or an outside opinion from a legal, medical, or other professional. This additional information will help them make a decision about your appeal. A higher court is reviewing a group of appeals.

What does "your appeal was merged" mean?

Your appeal was merged. What it means. The Board of Veterans’ Appeals merged your appeal with one of your older appeals that was closer to receiving a Board decision. The Board merges appeals so that you can receive a single decision on as many appeals as possible.

How long does a VA appeal stay open?

The Board of Veterans’ Appeals is holding your case open for new evidence for 90 days.

What does VSO mean?

What it means. Your Veterans Service Organization (VSO) is reviewing your appeal to prepare additional arguments to support your case. Status. A judge is reviewing your appeal. What it means. A Veterans Law Judge at the Board of Veterans’ Appeals is reviewing your appeal.

TDIU Errors

Orthopedic Claims

Compensation and Pension (C&P) Examinations

• VA also commits several errors in regards to C&P examinations when adjudicating veterans’ disability claims. As mentioned above, VA examiners often overlook factors such as functional loss and flare-ups. In doing so, they fail to take into account the whole disability picture and how a veteran’s limitations translate to his or her everyday life. Ho...

See more on cck-law.com

Effective Dates

Mental Health Conditions