shouldyou have a lawyer when being sued in small claims court?

by Prof. Wilfrid Lowe 4 min read

Seek Legal Counsel
Getting sued in small claims court may require the assistance of a lawyer. This must be determined on the overall claim itself and the monetary value sought. If the value of the claim is substantial, or higher than the cost of hiring a lawyer, it is recommended that a lawyer is secured.

Full Answer

Do I need a lawyer to go to Small Claims Court?

If someone is suing you for $35,000 or less, they can file a claim against you in Small Claims Court. They must file their claim within 2 years of when they first learned about the problem. You don't need a lawyer to go to Small Claims Court. But you'll probably understand the court process better if you talk to a lawyer or paralegal.

Who can be sued in Small Claims Court?

Practically anyone can bring a small claims court case or be sued in small claims court, including individuals, large corporations, and small businesses. For cases that could win a dollar amount over $10,000, you may want an attorney to bring the matter to a superior court.

Is small claims court the right place to file a claim?

Once you've decided that small claims court is the right place for your case to be heard, the next step is to determine the proper county for filing your claim. Proper "venue" for a court case is determined by a number of factors and depends on the nature of your claim.

What if I'm at the wrong end of a small claims case?

But you don't need to panic if you find yourself at the wrong end of a lawsuit in small claims court—you have options. Here's a checklist you can use to evaluate the case: if you must pay the debt, request installment payments. You'll find more information about each step below, or look for the answer to your question in Small Claims Court FAQ.

How do you negotiate before suing?

Offer to Compromise Before You Sue Before you reach for pen and paper, try to negotiate directly with the person, preferably in person. Know that any offer of compromise, made either orally or in writing, does not legally bind you to sue for that amount if the compromise is not accepted.

What is the least amount you can sue someone for?

As far as the minimum amount you can actually sue someone for, there is no limit. Legally, you can sue someone for any amount in court. The only criteria which has to be met, is that there is a valid cause of action. This refers to issues such as an unpaid debt.

Is suing someone worth it?

Is Going to Court Worth It? Again, it just depends on the specifics of your case. If you have a strong case and a good attorney, suing a person might be worth the costs. But if your case isn't as clear and you don't have a large budget, you may want to think twice before going to court.

How does small claims court work?

If both parties cannot agree on a settlement, then you go to a small claims court hearing carried out by a county judge. You'll be walked through the process, throughout. The judge will decide on a settlement based on your claim and evidence, taking into account any rebuttals by the defendant.

What happens if you don't show up to small claims court?

If you do not go to a small claims hearing, the creditor usually wins automatically “by default”. The plaintiff will get a judgment for the amount of money they asked for in the complaint. You can get a copy of the judgment from the court. The judgment will remain for 20 years.

Can I sue for emotional distress?

To prove a psychological injury you must be able to show that you suffered a quantifiable psychological injury as a result of someone else's negligence or failure while in their duty of care.

Do you need a lawyer to sue someone?

If your case meets the requirements for small claims court, you will usually be able to represent yourself, if you wish. You will save attorneys' fees by doing so. However, you may wish to pay an attorney to coach or advise you on how to prepare your case.

What happens if defendant Cannot pay?

If you don't pay what you owe right away, you will have to pay more. The creditor will get post-judgment interest on any part of the debt not paid back right away. If you don't pay the creditor, they can take steps to collect the money from you. This is called enforcing the judgment.

What is small claims court?

Small claims court is where anyone can bring a civil case in front of a local judge if it is under a certain amount of money. It provides relatively fast resolution to disputes at a low cost. This option is good for people who cannot afford an attorney or who believe their case is simple. The court process is simplified on purpose, ...

How long does a small claims claim take to be filed?

This means you will need to assess the problem and file the claim at your local court within two years of the day the problem occurred.

How much money do you need to file a criminal case in Tennessee?

Depending on the state you live in, the amount of money you ask for in your case may need to be under $2,500 (Kentucky) or could be as much as $25,000 (Tennessee). Most states' limits fall in the middle of those amounts. Your case might involve other government agencies.

What happens if you win a court case?

If you won the court judgment or money judgment, your battle might not be over yet. Some people will refuse to pay you, or they may need a payment plan. The courts will not help you get the money you won.

How to win a lawsuit if you don't fight back?

Have a court date set and serve the other person with the claim (in some cases, you may have to tell them about the court date yourself) Wait for the other side to answer you (if they do not fight back before the court date, you will automatically win) Once you actually go to court, you can expect to:

What to do after a jury trial?

After the case concludes, you will: Hear the final result (called a "court judgment") or receive a "money judgment" by certified mail.

Can you appeal a court case if you don't like the outcome?

Follow the judge's instructions to return personal property, pay fines, be paid a settlement, or other retribution , or file an appeal if you do not like the outcome of the case. Appeals often need to be filed quickly, so it is in your best interest to file the appeal right away.

How to file a small claims lawsuit?

Learn what to do -- and not to do -- if someone sues you in small claims court. 1 read the paperwork 2 check for a procedural problem 3 negotiate a settlement 4 try mediation 5 decide whether to default or fight the case, or 6 if you must pay the debt, request installment payments.

What to do if you are at the wrong end of a small claims lawsuit?

But you don't need to panic if you find yourself at the wrong end of a lawsuit in small claims court—you have options. Here's a checklist you can use to evaluate the case: read the paperwork. check for a procedural problem. negotiate a settlement.

Why is mediation important in a dispute?

If negotiation doesn't solve the problem, mediation is almost always beneficial to the defendant, because the process tends to encourage a compromise settlement for a lower amount than the plaintiffs demand. Also, mediation gives the defendant a chance to raise issues that are not officially part of the plaintiff's lawsuit. For instance, in a dispute between neighbors, businesspeople, or relatives, it's often important to discuss and settle emotional concerns in addition to sorting out how much is owed.

What to do if court clerk can't help you?

If the court clerk can't help you, then seek legal assistance. Out-of-state defendants. If you don't live or do business in a state where you are sued, a court normally doesn't have power (jurisdiction) to enter a valid judgment against you, unless court papers are served on you while you happen to be in that state.

Can a plaintiff be sued by default?

Sometimes the plaintiff—the person suing you—doesn't follow all of the procedural legal rules properly. Do not be tempted to simply not show up in court just because you think there's a procedural defect in the plaintiff's case. A judge can easily overlook even a major technical problem and, as a result, enter a judgment against you by default. If this happens, you will have to go to the trouble of requesting that the judgment be set aside (vacated).

Can you get mediation in a small claims court?

In some states, small claims courts require parties to try mediation before a judge hears the case. Elsewhere, voluntary mediation is easily accessible, either right in the courthouse or at a nearby community mediation project. Ask the small claims court clerk where mediation is available in your area.

How much can you sue for in a small claims case?

The maximum amount you can sue for in a small claims case is $5,000. The maximum amount in District Court is $30,000. The original complaint and your counterclaim or crossclaim will both be heard during the same trial. If there is a good reason, the court can order that the trials be held at different times.

How is small claims different from regular civil cases?

Small Claims are different from regular civil cases in the District Court. The rules and procedures in Small Claims Court are simpler and more informal. If you have been sued as the defendant in a regular civil case in the District Court, this article may still be helpful, but be aware that there are differences.

What is a summons in court?

The Summons is the court document notifying you that a lawsuit has been filed against you. The Summons has the time and place of the hearing. The Complaint is the document that the Plaintiff filed to begin the lawsuit. The Plaintiff is the person filing the lawsuit. The Defendant is the person or business that the Plaintiff is alleging owes them ...

What to do when you have been sued in Maryland?

What To Do When You Have Been Sued in Small Claims Court. If you have just been served with (given a copy of) a Summons and a Complaint to appear in Small Claims Court, you are now the defendant in a lawsuit. Small Claims Court is part of the District Court of Maryland. The Summons is the court document notifying you that a lawsuit has been filed ...

How long do you have to respond to a summons?

You must file a “Notice of Intention to Defend” within 15 days of being served the Summons and Complaint. In some cases, you have 60 days to respond (e.g., if you are out of state or own a business with a resident agent).

What to do if you reach an agreement with a judge?

TIP - If you reach an agreement through your negotiation or mediation, ask the judge to enter the agreement as part of the court order. Just in case the other side does not live up to their side of the agreement, it is easier to enforce a judgment than a private agreement.

What happens if a suit is brought in the wrong county?

If a suit is brought in the wrong county, it can be transferred or dismissed. Cases will be transferred for the convenience of the parties or “in the interests of justice”. If you both appear for the hearing, the case can be heard, even if the county is not the correct one. Read the Rule: Md. Rule 3-326.

Responding To A Small Claims Complaint

Find out what options you have if you are served with a Small Claims Complaint, including tips for resolving or defending the case.

Suing The Person Who Is Suing You In Small Claims

Find out how you can sue the person who is suing you in small claims court if you believe that person owes you money, including how to analyze, prepare, and file a Small Claims Counterclaim.

Setting Aside A Small Claims Default Judgment

Learn what you can do if a default judgment has been entered against you (most likely because you failed to show up at a small claims hearing or failed to respond to the Small Claims Complaint you received), including how to ask the court to “set aside” (cancel or revoke) the judgment.

What is it called when you are sued in small claims court?

It will tell you what they’re suing for, and why. When you receive this form, it’s called being served .

How long do you have to file a small claims lawsuit?

If someone is suing you for $35,000 or less, they can file a claim against you in Small Claims Court. They must file their claim within 2 years of when they first learned about the problem. You don’t need a lawyer to go to Small Claims Court.

How long does it take to reply to a claim?

If you want to reply to the claim, you must file and a Defence within 20 days of receiving the claim. In your Defence, you can tell your side of the story. You can agree with all, some, or none of the claims the plaintiff made against you.

Should the plaintiff have to pay you for something they did?

you think someone else is responsible for the plaintiff’s loss. For example, you may want to file a counterclaim if: the plaintiff hasn’t paid the bill for a service you provided.

How to file a small claims lawsuit?

How to File for Small Claims Court. Now that you have a proper county for filing your claim, you will then initiate a lawsuit by filling out and filing the appropriate paperwork with the court clerk . Once you have completed and filed your paperwork, the clerk will assign you a hearing date. The clerk will also, in most states, serve ...

Why do people go to small claims court?

These are just a few reasons why people typically go to small claims court to resolve their problems: To recover a security deposit. If your landlord fails to return your security deposit to you after you have vacated his property, you may have to take him to small claims court.

What to do if your neighbors refuse to pay the emergency room bill?

If your neighbors refuse to pay the emergency room bill, you may have to take them to small claims court. To recover money spent to repair or replace damaged or destroyed personal property. If your neighbors' bratty kid throws a tantrum, hurls a toy at your brand new Mercedes and scratches the paint, and the neighbors refuse to pay for repair ...

How to be the best litigant at a court hearing?

Make sure your documents are organized so that you can locate any document to which you need to refer quickly and easily. By simply being the best organized litigant at the hearing, you will have a huge advantage over the defendant. At the hearing, take your cues from the judge.

How to prepare for a court hearing?

At the hearing, take your cues from the judge. When asked to do so, state your case clearly and concisely. Do not ramble. Get right to the point. Do not interrupt the defendant or, heaven forbid, the judge--always wait your turn. Most of all, be prepared.

How to prepare for a lawsuit?

Most of all, be prepared. Make sure you have answers ready to any question that may arise, even (and especially) regarding those issues that may be damaging to your case. Make sure you have documentation or evidence to support all of your answers and claims.

What documents should be included in a court case?

Appropriate documentation may include contracts, letters, receipts, cancelled checks, memos, even photographs. If you are not sure whether a document is relevant, include it anyway. If you don't include it, and if your luck is anything like mine, that single document will be the only document the judge wants to see.

Why do you take your case to a small claims court?

The possible downside to small claims court is the lack of attorney representation.

What is a small claims court?

Small claims courts are courts of "limited jurisdiction," meaning that they can only hear specific types of cases. Most small claims courts can only hear civil cases involving small amounts of money, usually around $10,000 or less. You'll need to check with your county and state to determine the limits for your case.

What is a court hearing?

There is a court hearing where they speak directly to the judge. Both sides present evidence and make arguments. The judge issues a verdict. The judge will read the plaintiff's claim and the defendant's answer, hear both sides of the case on the hearing date, and render a verdict reasonably quickly.

Can a judge postpone a case if the other party is absent?

The party that did show can then have that judgment enforced. In rare cases, the court may postpone the case if the other party was absent due to an actual emergency , such as a medical emergency or a car accident. The judge usually has total discretion over whether to postpone the case.

Can a small claims court be represented by a lawyer?

Many states do not allow parties to be represented by lawyers in small claims court. One of the main advantages of small claims cases is informality and inexpensiveness, so bringing a lawyer can defeat the purpose.

Can you appeal a small claims verdict?

You can appeal a small claim's verdict in most states. The process and your rights to the appeal will vary depending on your state laws. You should look into your state laws for: Anyone wishing to appeal a small claims case should consult their state's laws to determine what rights they have to an appeal, if any.

Can a small claims court hear a civil case?

Small claims courts can hear most types of civil court cases, such as: Most small claims courts do not hear: Practically anyone can bring a small claims court case or be sued in small claims court, including individuals, large corporations, and small businesses. For cases that could win a dollar amount over $10,000, ...

What to expect in a small claims trial?

If you’ve ever seen a television court show, you know what to expect in a small claims trial. The judge starts by allowing the plaintiff to explain the case and present evidence. You’ll be expected to listen quietly no matter how infuriating the other side’s statements might be (although you’ll have the right to make evidentiary objections). Afterward, you’ll put forth your evidence, and ultimately, the judge will decide who wins. What you don’t see on television, however, is the preparation and planning that takes place before you appear in court. Not only will your pretrial efforts help you present your case in the best light, but also might be the key to prevailing.

How long does it take to file a lawsuit?

The plaintiff must file the suit within a particular period called the “statute of limitations.”. The time frame is usually one to six years depending on your state and the type of case (but it could be longer).

What to do if plaintiff stands a good chance of winning?

If the plaintiff stands a good chance of winning, you’ll want to look for holes that could prevent the plaintiff from meeting the evidentiary burden (proving the case—more below). If the case is sound, it’s reasonable to cut your losses and agree to pay what you owe (or less).

What is the best strategy for a lawsuit?

Planning Your Strategy: What’s Driving the Case? 1 A plaintiff with a winning case who knows you can afford to pay a judgment. 2 An aggressive, arrogant plaintiff who believes that they can sway the court. 3 An angry plaintiff who wants to punish you with a court battle. 4 Some combination of the above.

What happens before a court hearing?

Before hearing the matter, most courts require litigants to go into the hallway for settlement talks. Court personnel or a volunteer might be available to help you reach a compromise. If successful, the court will document the terms of your settlement.

Why do people prefer to let minor disputes go?

In truth, most people prefer to let minor disputes go rather than launching into a small claims case because filing, serving, and presenting the case—not to mention collecting the judgment—takes a lot of effort . So, the question becomes, “Why did this plaintiff sue me?”.

How to get far in a case?

You can get far by presenting your evidence in a level-headed, determined manner. Staying calm and focused will help the judge accurately assess credibility. Such cases involve things like injuries resulting from a physical altercation, property damage, an unreasonable repair bill, or a fallout with a business partner.

What is small claims court?

The small claims court system allows people to resolve legal problems in an efficient and cost-effective manner. It starts when the plaintiff files paperwork asking the court to award money for harm caused by the defendant (the person or company being sued). The defendant might file allegations, as well.

What questions should I ask my attorney?

Questions for Your Attorney 1 Am I judgment proof? 2 Can you negotiate down the judgment on my behalf? 3 Can I get rid of the judgment in Chapter 7 bankruptcy?

How long does it take for a judgment to be collected?

For instance, in some jurisdictions, the judgment creditor cannot start collection efforts until 30 days passes. Others have a ten-day waiting period.

What happens if you don't show up for a property examination?

If you fail to show up for the examination, the court will likely issue an arrest warrant.

How long do you have to wait to appeal a judgment?

Others have a ten-day waiting period. Another only recommends waiting until the applicable appeal period expires. You’ll find your court rules on your court’s website. To locate the information, look under the heading “Collecting the Judgment” or a variation thereof.

Can a judgment take property?

The judgment creditor can take property—such as real estate and personal possessions—to sell at auction. Because of the time and expense involved, its unusual for a creditor to use this procedure unless you own valuable property free and clear. Till tap.

Can a judgment debtor make payment directly to the court?

For instance, California has a special small claims rule that allows the judgment debtor to make payment directly to the court. While this is an unusual practice, if it's available to you, it would be a good idea to use it. The court would have proof that you paid the creditor.