ORLANDO, Fla. (AP) — A judge who was captured on video berating and threatening to fight an assistant public defender has been ordered removed from the bench by the Florida Supreme Court.
Full Answer
A Florida judge who was caught on camera threatening to beat down a lawyer in court last year — and then allegedly made due on his promise — has been removed from his post thanks to his dishonorable behavior.
Weinstock, who resigned his job when Murphy returned to the bench in July 2014 after anger-management counseling, declined to discuss the judge's removal. “No, thank you,” he said before hanging up his phone Friday.
The Florida Supreme Court decided Thursday that Brevard County Judge John C. Murphy should be taken off the bench after his "grievous misconduct became a national spectacle and an embarrassment to Florida's judicial system."
Blocton, who was a circuit judge in the Birmingham court’s domestic relations division, also used fake Facebook accounts “to communicate with litigants in a pending domestic-relations case in an effort to affect the outcome of the case,” according to the judgment.
The Florida judge was found guilty of 'grievous misconduct' for threatening and fighting an attorney before continuing to hear cases.
The Florida Supreme Court removed a judge from office Thursday for telling a public defender “I’ll just beat your ass” before making good on the threat and continuing court proceedings without defense counsel.
Weinstock maintained through his boss, Blaise Trettis, who gave media interviews after the incident, that he expected a conversation, not a physical confrontation, when he followed Murphy into the hallway, but was instead surprised by a grabby, fist-flinging judge. [.
Judge who caused 'national spectacle' by challenging public defender to fistfight loses his job. Rejecting a recommended 120-day suspension and $50,000 fine for a Florida judge who challenged a public defender to a fistfight last year, the state supreme court on Thursday removed him from office. Calling the June 2014 incident in Brevard County ...
Later, Weinstock quit his job over the incident, saying that he felt his boss should have opposed Murphy’s return to the bench.
Weinstock remains standing. “You know what? I’m the public defender,” he replies. “I have a right to be here, and I have a right to stand and represent my clients.”
The court filing said a doctor did not back up that diagnosis, but said the judge suffered from a "perfect storm" of emotional stress due to fatigue from his job and the death of his father.
Murphy's courtroom conflict erupted last June during an argument with a public defender, Andrew Weinstock, over a client's right to a speedy trial.
The state's Supreme Court could not prove the beating happened — but said the judge's behavior was bad enough on its own.