john adams was the lawyer who defended the british soldiers involved in the boston massacre

by Keara Smitham 4 min read

Adams led the American Revolution before his presidency, achievingdependence from Great Britain. He was dedicated to the right to counsel and the presumption of innocence and successfully defended British soldiers against murder charges in the Boston Massacre.

As noted in the 2008 HBO mini-series chronicling the life and career of John Adams (1735-1826), as a young lawyer the future president served as counsel for the defense in the trial of eight British soldiers accused of murder during a riot in Boston on March 5, 1770.

Full Answer

Who did John Adams defend in the Boston Massacre?

Adams defended the British officer Thomas Preston and his soldiers in two separate trials. Can you talk about the balancing act Adams undertook to defend all his clients without alienating his fellow Bostonians, many of whom fervently supported the broader patriot cause?

Who was John Adams — defense attorney for British soldiers?

John Adams — Defense Attorney for British Soldiers? Why a Founding Father represented British soldiers during the Boston Massacre Trials aptain Thomas Preston and eight British soldiers were on trial for murder. They would need an excellent attorney to represent them with a jury full of anti-British colonists.

What testimony did the defense have in the Boston Massacre?

Witnesses recalled how the mob had repeatedly called for the British soldiers to be killed. Particularly effective testimony for the defense came from Dr. John Jeffries, who had tended to one of the colonists killed on the night of March 5, 1770.

Did John Adams agree to defend the soldiers in exchange for?

One historian, Hiller B. Zobel, has suggested that Adams agreed to defend the soldiers in exchange for a legislative seat. (Three months after the trial, he was Boston's first choice for the position.)

image

Did John Adams defend the British soldiers in the Boston Massacre?

The Boston Massacre, in which British redcoats killed five American civilians. Adams defended the British officer Thomas Preston and his soldiers in two separate trials.

Who defended the Boston Massacre soldiers?

President John AdamsEight soldiers, one officer, and four civilians were arrested and charged with murder, and they were defended by future U.S. President John Adams.

Why John Adams defended British soldiers in the Boston Massacre trials?

Without hesitation Adams agreed to defend the soldiers and their captain. Above all, John Adams believed in upholding the law, and defending the innocent. Adams was convinced that the soldiers were wrongly accused, and had fired into the crowd in self-defense.

Did John Adams participate in the Boston Tea Party?

Adams Reacts to the Boston Tea Party When he returned the very next morning, he was shocked that the Sons of Liberty undertook such a foolhardy course, but was nonetheless pleasantly surprised.

What did John Adams say in the Boston Massacre?

In the following trial of Preston's men in November 1770, Adams pleaded that the soldiers had acted in self-defence and asked the jury to consider themselves in the shoes of the soldiers and whether any reasonable man would not have concluded that they were in danger of their lives when surrounded by a hostile crowd ...

What did John Adams do?

Adams was a Massachusetts delegate to the Continental Congress and became a leader of the revolution. He assisted Jefferson in drafting the Declaration of Independence in 1776. As a diplomat in Europe, he helped negotiate a peace treaty with Great Britain and secured vital governmental loans.

What were John Adams accomplishments?

In the 1780s, Adams served as a diplomat in Europe and helped negotiate the Treaty of Paris (1783), which officially ended the American Revolutionary War (1775-83). From 1789 to 1797, Adams was America's first vice president. He then served a term as the nation's second president.

Who was Captain Preston?

Thomas Preston ( c. 1722—c. 1798) was a British officer, a captain who served in Boston in the Province of Massachusetts Bay. He commanded troops in the Boston Massacre in 1770 and was tried for murder, but he was acquitted.

Early Life

John Adams was born on October 30, 1735, to his father, John Adams Sr., and his mother, Susanna Boylston, and had two younger brothers, Peter and Elihu.

Boston Massacre

The Boston Massacre was a conflict in Boston on March 5, 1770. British soldiers shot and killed many people, perceiving them as a mob, and leading patriots including Paul Revere and Samuel Adams heavily publicized the event.

Boston massacre trial

Following the Boston Massacre, Captain Thomas Preston, eight British soldiers, and five British civilians were charged for murder. They were exposed to the possibility of execution and could not find a defense team as they would have to defend them in the anti-British city of Boston.

Balancing Act of Adams to defend his clients without distancing his fellow Bostonians

These days, criminal defense lawyers regularly take John Adams’s defense of the British soldiers to to represent specific clients. He did not blame the city for initiating the riot and focused on facts.

Conclusion

It is generally unsatisfying to get a mixed verdict in a case involving so much passion and emotion. However, these cases serve as a compelling example, and the Boston Massacre trial was among these trials.

Where was John Adams carried?

He was carried along to King Street, where a file of redcoats was formed up at a distance from some blood-stained ice. Nearby two townspeople lay dead; three were mortally wounded. Adams, who had been spending a convivial evening in the South End with members of his club, now thought of home.

How many people were acquitted of Adams' crimes?

Six were acquitted, and two were found guilty of manslaughter. (Their punishment was to be branded on the right thumb by the Boston sheriff.) More than this, however, the speech illuminated the core of Adams’s political thought, especially his view of the human material of which politics is made.

How long did it take for Adams to prepare for Rex v. Wemms?

Adams had a week or ten days in which to prepare for the second and final massacre, Rex v. Wemms et al. That the wheels of justice did not turn without lubrication in those days is obvious from the itemized expenses for which Adams later sought reimbursement from the British army.

How many votes did John Adams get?

Yet on June 6, when an election was held in Boston to fill a newly vacant position on the General Court, Adams received 418 out of 536 votes cast. As was customary, the candidate did nothing on his own behalf.

What was the best resolution of the cases of Preston and his men?

In the opinion of the Boston mob, the best resolution of the cases of Preston and his men, short of immediate hangings, was an instant trial, conducted while the town was still on the boil. But Hutchinson deftly deflected this hope, and the proceedings were postponed until the autumn.

What inference to be drawn from the Preston verdict?

The inference to be drawn from the Preston verdict was that they had fired without a lawful order. To the Whigs, they were murderers. For the student of John Adams’s life and thought, the most important feature of the second massacre trial was the presence in the courtroom of a shorthand writer.

What did the extreme patriots think of the lynching of Preston?

Extreme patriots regarded the absence of a lynching of Preston and his men as proof of the impartiality of Boston justice. John Adams, possessing strong patriotic views by refusing to express them on any terms but his own, sometimes was suspected of a lack of Whiggish zeal.

Who was the first colonist killed in the Boston Massacre?

After a soldier was knocked down, someone fired into the crowd, confused, and killed the first colonist in the Revolutionary War — Crispus Attucks. Panic ensued, and soldiers fired into the crowd of colonists. After the skirmish ended, five of the colonists had been killed.

How did the Boston Massacre impact the legal system?

The impact on today’s legal system. The Boston Massacre trials served as a landmark case for the new justice system in the colonies. This trial was the first time that a jury was sequestered, which is now typical practice in high profile cases. The standard of reasonable doubt was also introduced during this trial.

Why was Boston important to the British?

Boston was a major port for trade as well as a hotbed for Patriot activity and organization. Britain stationed a large garrison of troops in the city with the aim of controlling unruly colonists who were resisting customs officials. On March 5, 1770, a crowd gathered outside the Customs House that was being guarded by the British.

What did Adams and the defense argue about the crowd?

Adams and the defense argued that the crowd was endangering the soldiers’ lives and they acted in self-defense. He called witnesses that described how the crowd verbally threatened the soldiers and threw objects at them. Witnesses recalled how the mob had repeatedly called for the British soldiers to be killed.

How many soldiers were found not guilty of murder?

After deliberating for three hours, the jury found all eight soldiers not guilty of murder. Two of the men were found guilty of the lesser charge of manslaughter and their penalty was reduced to branding on the thumb. The other six soldiers were completely cleared of all charges.

What was the Boston Massacre called?

Before the trial, Loyalists and Patriots engaged in a propaganda war. Patriot cartoons and articles painted the riot as an all-out attack by aggressive British soldiers. Paul Revere even published a cartoon which he named The Bloody Massacre, leading the riot to be known as the Boston Massacre.

Why did Britain feel that the colonies had only flourished?

Britain felt that the colonies had only flourished because of the protection and support from their home country. In response to bids for more autonomy, Parliament began passing laws to control trade, stop smuggling, and raise more revenue from the colonies.

Who was the patriot who defended the British soldiers in court?

However, one of the patriots so essential to the revolution, John Adams, chose to defend the British soldiers in court.

Why did Adams take the case?

He clearly knew that taking on this case was dangerous. An angry mob could threaten his family, and should his reputation be tarnished, his ambitions and economic future would be endangered.

Why did the British invade Massachusetts?

In 1768, British troops arrived in Massachusetts to enforce the hated, tax-heavy Townshend Acts. Over the ensuing months, tensions between the colonists and their mother country’s soldiers boiled over, culminating in what became known as the Boston Massacre.

Why did the British soldiers have trouble finding defense counsel?

The British soldiers, facing the prospect of the death penalty, had trouble finding defense counsel. No colonist, it seemed, wanted to take on this unpopular case, as doing so might affect his reputation and economic future. However, as British subjects, the soldiers had the right to competent defense lawyers, and the people ...

When did the Preston trial take place?

Results of the Trials. Preston’s trial took place between Oct. 24 and Oct. 30, 1770 . Adams argued that Preston had not given the order to fire, and that Preston's soldiers were provoked by the crowd.

Who was the patriot who fought against the British in the Revolution?

However, one of the patriots so essential to the revolution, John Adams, chose to defend the British soldiers in court.

Did Adams argue that they acted in self defense?

Here, Adams argued that they acted in self-defense. The jury in that case acquitted six, but found two guilty of the lesser charge of manslaughter. Finally, in December the four civilians went to trial, and all were acquitted.

Who was the soldier who surrounded the Boston crowd?

Crispus Attucks. Captain Preston and a detachment of seven or eight soldiers were surrounded by Boston citizens who were angry and taunting the men. Attempts to calm the gathered citizens were useless. At this point, something happened that caused a soldier to fire their musket into the crowd.

What did John Adams believe?

John Adams believed that the rule of law should be paramount and that the British soldiers involved in the Boston Massacre deserved a fair trial.

What happened on March 5th 1770?

On March 5, 1770, a small gathering of colonists in Boston were tormenting British soldiers. Unlike normal, the taunting on this day led to an escalation of hostilities. There was a sentry standing in front of the Custom House who talked back to the colonists. More colonists then arrived on the scene. In fact, the church bells began ringing which ...

What was the effect of the Boston Massacre?

The verdict's effect was huge as the leaders of the rebellion used it as further proof of Great Britain's tyranny. Paul Revere created his famous engraving of the event that he titled, "The Bloody Massacre perpetrated in King Street." The Boston Massacre is often pointed to as an event that presaged the Revolutionary War. The event soon became a rallying cry for the Patriots.

Who said the soldier who shot first was hit by a stick?

Soldiers including Captain Prescott claimed the crowd had heavy clubs, sticks, and fireballs. Prescott said that the soldier who shot first was hit by a stick. Just like with any confusing public event, a number of disparate accounts were given about the actual chain of events.

How long did the Sons of Liberty trial last?

However, in the meantime, the Sons of Liberty had started a major propaganda effort against the British. The six-day trial, quite long for its time, was held in late October.

image

Early Life

Boston Massacre

  • The Boston Massacre was a conflict in Boston on March 5, 1770. British soldiers shot and killed many people, perceiving them as a mob, and leading patriots including Paul Revere and Samuel Adams heavily publicized the event. Boston, the capital of the Massachusetts Bay, was a significant shipping town and a center of resistance to unpopular taxation acts by the British Par…
See more on historyten.com

Boston Massacre Trial

  • Following the Boston Massacre, Captain Thomas Preston, eight British soldiers, and five British civilians were charged for murder. They were exposed to the possibility of execution and could not find a defense team as they would have to defend them in the anti-British city of Boston. John Adams realized that there was a lot at stake for colonial America, and it was important for the a…
See more on historyten.com

John Adams’ Role in The Boston Massacre Trial

  • In the trial, Adams said that Captain Preston had never ordered his soldiers to fire. He also put forward that those who had shot into the crowd did so entirely for self-defense. He called the people involved in the mob who provoked the soldiers “outlandish Jack tars.” H” persuaded and won th” case releasing Preston and six of his soldiers on all c...
See more on historyten.com

Conclusion

  • It is generally unsatisfying to get a mixed verdict in a case involving so much passion and emotion. However, these cases serve as a compelling example, and the Boston Massacre trial was among these trials. The Boston massacre could have led to a revolution, but it did not, as people accepted it was a very controversial verdict. For firing against the orders of Captain Prest…
See more on historyten.com