An older Walter McMillian in the years after his exoneration and Jamie Foxx in the Just Mercy movie. How accurate is Just Mercy? Gain even more insight into the true story behind the movie by watching the videos below, which include Walter McMillian and Bryan Stevenson interviews.
Another book about Walter McMillian's wrongful incarceration is journalist Pete Earley's 1995 true crime book Circumstantial Evidence: Death, Life, and Justice in a Southern Town. We used both books to investigate the Just Mercy true story.
Walter McMillian had violated the racial and sexual taboos of the small Alabama town in which he lived. "The only reason I'm here is because I had been messing around with a white lady and my son married a white lady," McMillian said in a prison interview." -The New York Times
Walter and Minnie peacefully separate, and Walter stays a while with his sister in Florida. Walter thinks often... (full context) Ballinger-Dix, Elizabeth. "Just Mercy Characters: Minnie McMillian."
His family raises money and refinances their possessions to pay for two Selma civil rights attorneys, J.L Chestnut and Bruce Boynton. Monroeville officials disapprove of Walter hiring out-of-county defense, and they consider it evidence that Walter has drug money. The new attorneys fail to get Walter out of Holman.
Bryan StevensonBryan Stevenson, McMillian's defense attorney, raised awareness on the CBS News program 60 Minutes. Journalist Pete Earley covered it in his book Circumstantial Evidence: Death, Life, and Justice in a Southern Town (1995).
Bryan StevensonBryan Stevenson was Walter's lawyer who tried to get him off death row because of his unfair trial. Stevenson had just started up a tiny law firm in Alabama, and the sole purpose of the firm was to help unfairly imprisoned people get off death row.
He has helped achieve United States Supreme Court decisions that prohibit sentencing children under 18 to death or to life imprisonment without parole....Bryan StevensonStevenson in 2012BornNovember 14, 1959 Milton, Delaware, U.S.EducationEastern University (BA) Harvard University (JD, MPP)4 more rows
Following a week of being interrogated by the police, Myers accused McMillian of murdering 18-year-old Ronda Morrison. At the trial, he testified that he had given McMillian a ride to the dry cleaners where he witnessed him murder Morrison, the store's clerk. Myers pled guilty as a conspirator in the murder.
The high court ruled against him on a legal technicality, but McMillian settled with other parties in the case for an undetermined amount. At the time, Alabama did not have a compensation statute, although the McMillian case helped get a law passed there in 2001.
OPINION 1: i believe the police are most to blame for Walter's conviction. When Myers came clean and said he was lying, they didn't take away the charges for Walter, just sentenced Myers to death. They did not do anything to help the situation and allowed the false accusations to continue.
He never married and has no children. “Bryan is the work,” colleague Sia Sanneh adds. “There's no way to separate him from the work. It's his full self he pours into it.”
Funding: The Equal Justice Initiative is funded by foundations, corporations, individuals, and government grants.
62Â years (November 14, 1959)Bryan Stevenson / Age
The story of Walter McMillian in Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson is the one that I found the most intriguing. Bryan, who was the attorney on Walter’s case, was young and just starting his career. He first encountered Walter while he was on death row (20). He had spoken to other inmates on death row that day, but Walter’s case is the one ...
He was married with three children. He was known as a lady’s man around town and was known to be involved with other women, romantically. Walter became involved with a woman who was eighteen years older than him, Karen. She was married and was having trouble in her marriage.
Because of his race, he was a target. The sheriff knew that Myers was a liar and was not credible, yet he still took his word over Walter’s. The sheriff knew that he needed to find someone guilty for the recent murders that occurred in the town. His sixth amendment was violated.
The case against Walter was beyond unjust, an innocent man was put on death row because of the pressure put on the sheriff. His rights were not protected, yet they were violated. Walter did not have due process. Because of his race, he was a target.
A criticism of the exclusionary rule is, it does not stop police from practicing misconduct, which occurred in Walter’s case. Walter suffered a major injustice. He was a victim of officer misconduct. The town felt uneasy about the murders that had just occurred.
The town felt uneasy about the murders that had just occurred. They put lots of pressure on law enforcement to find the murderer. This made law enforcement feel as if they needed to find the criminal as soon as possible, even if that meant accusing the wrong man. Crimes were much harder to solve in the early 1900s.
The town hired a new sheriff in hopes of finding more evidence . Walter’s ex-wife began a relationship with a white man. This man had a criminal record and was involved in drug dealing. He wanted to be the center of attention and be involved in things that were mysteries, like the recent Pittman murder.
Michael B. Jordan and Jamie Foxx in "Just Mercy". Jake Giles Netter. It was a rousing, goose-bump-inducing call to arms, one fueled by a galvanizing belief in the capacity of individuals to effect change, but also the kind of speech that few orators could pull off without seeming hectoring or maudlin.
Supreme Court. He created a museum on the history of lynching, slavery and racial discrimination and a memorial to peace and justice. He’s authored a best-selling memoir and been featured in a TED Talk on mass incarceration that went viral. He’s received a MacArthur “genius” grant.
After his injury, McMillan went on partial disability and was able to work part-time taking in junk cars for scrap metal . In the years after his release from prison, McMillan said it was difficult not to be angry but tried to “get over it” by keeping his mind off the wrongful conviction.
Walter McMillan was exonerated after spending six years on death row for a crime he didn't commit, but the trauma continued to plague him for the rest of his life. By Jill Sederstrom. Photo: Jake Giles Netter.
McMillan, a 46-year-old black man, was well-known in the community because the married man had been having an affair with a white woman. Myers eventually told police he and McMillan had driven to the cleaners together, but that McMillan had been the only one to go inside.
With Trina Garnett’s case, Stevenson highlights not only how people with intellectual disabilities are mishandled by the justice system, but how people in the United States can be locked up for life for crimes they committed as children.
Chapter Eight: All God’s Children. Stevenson recounts the case of Trina Garnett. She was from a poor area in Chester, Pennsylvania. Trina’s father was extremely abusive to her mother, raping her and beating her. She and her siblings learned to hide from him when he was drunk and prowling around the house to abuse them.
Trina gave birth to her son while handcuffed to a bed, and the boy was then taken into foster care. By thirty, prison doctors diagnosed Trina with multiple sclerosis, intellectual disability, and mental illness related to trauma.
After her mother died, her father began sexually abusing her, and so she and her sisters moved to other relatives’ houses, only to find these living situations disrupted by violence, leaving Trina out onto the streets. The desperate circumstances compounded Trina’s emotional and mental health problems.
At fourteen, Antonio became the youngest person in the U.S. condemned to die in prison for a crime in which no one was physically injured. Stevenson comments that by the late 1980s and early 1990s, fear and anger were sweeping the country and fueling mass incarceration.
In the 1960s and 1970s, laws were enacted to prevent involuntary commitment to mental institutions and people were empowered to refuse treatment. But while the reforms were needed, a consequence was that deinstitutionalized poor people suffering mental disabilities were at great risk of imprisonment.
He was sentenced to life in the Apalachee Correctional Institution. To protect him from sexual assault, Ian was put in solitary confinement, a concrete box the size of a closet with three showers a week and occasional exercise. He began cutting himself with anything sharp on his food tray.
The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance. Chapter 1: Mockingbird Players. Walter had a history of cheating on his wife, Minnie, with whom he had five children.
Minnie McMillian Character Analysis. Minnie McMillian. Minnie is Walter McMillian’s wife. Like Walter, she is from the poor black community just outside of Monroeville. She is resilient, patient, intelligent and hospitable. She supports and cares for her five children during Walter’s incarceration.
The morning of the hearing, Stevenson tells Walter about his conversation with Minnie. Walter seems sad, but he tells Stevenson: “nothing can really spoil getting your freedom back.”... (full context) ...his story was “effective” in winning audience sympathy and indignation about his experiences.
Stevenson, Minnie and Jackie travel down a long, isolated road, until they reach “an entire community hidden... (full context) Chapter 11: I’ll Fly Away. ...The State decides to join rather than oppose the motion. Before the hearing, Stevenson visits Minnie to pick up a suit for Walter.
Walter had a history of cheating on his wife, Minnie, with whom he had five children. In 1986, at 43, Walter was involved with a... (full context) Chapter 5: Of the Coming of John. ...home. He first notices the home’s disrepair and the familiar signs of poverty.
Like in the movie, Judge Key stated that McMillian needed to be put to death for the "brutal killing of a young lady in the first full flower of adulthood.". -The New Yorker. Ralph Myers, who pled guilty as a conspirator in the murder, was given 30 years in prison.
The jury at Walter McMillian's trial was made up of eleven whites and one African American. On August 17, 1988, they found McMillian "guilty of the capital offense charged in the indictment" and agreed on a sentence of life in prison. However, the judge overruled the jury and levied the most extreme punishment.
Myers pled guilty as a conspirator in the murder. The scars on Myers's face, which were recreated for the movie, were the result of a childhood fire.
Another book about Walter McMillian's wrongful incarceration is journalist Pete Earley's 1995 true crime book Circumstantial Evidence: Death, Life, and Justice in a Southern Town .
Herbert Richardson, portrayed by Rob Morgan in the Just Mercy movie, was a Vietnam veteran and a real-life client of Bryan Stevenson. It's true that Stevenson failed to save Richardson from the death penalty. The movie doesn't delve into why Richardson was on Death Row.
Yes. In real life, this supposedly happened during the reading of the initial guilty verdict, prior to when Bryan Stevenson became involved in the case. According to Sheriff Tate, Johnny exclaimed, "Somebody's going to pay for what they've done to my father.".
The movie is based on lawyer Bryan Stevenson's 2014 bestselling memoir Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption. Stevenson is portrayed by Michael B. Jordan in the movie.
Walter McMillian, who is Black, was convicted and sentenced to death for the murder of a young white woman who worked as a clerk in a dry cleaning store in Monroeville, Alabama. Mr. McMillian was held on death row prior to being convicted and sentenced to death. His trial lasted only a day and a half.
McMillian was released in 1993 after spending six years on death row for a crime he did not commit. In 1988, Bryan Stevenson met Walter McMillian and began working to appeal his conviction and death sentence.
EJI's Bryan Stevenson took on the case in postconviction, where he showed that the State’s witnesses had lied on the stand and the prosecution had illegally suppressed exculpatory evidence. Mr. McMillian's conviction was overturned by the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals in 1993 and prosecutors agreed the case had been mishandled. Mr. McMillian was released in 1993 after spending six years on death row for a crime he did not commit.
In Alabama, elected trial judges were authorized to override a jury’s life verdict and impose the death penalty. Judge Robert E. Lee Key overrode the jury’s sentence of life imprisonment and sentenced Mr. McMillian to death by electrocution. Mr.
EJI proved the State’s witnesses had lied on the stand. Mr. McMillian’s conviction was overturned and he was released from death row. Supporters celebrated Mr. McMillian’s release. Mr. McMillian at his family’s home on the day of his release after six years on death row.
Minnie says the trial had been the worst. Though cautious about expressing strong opinions, but having read the trial transcript with anger, Stevenson says the trial was constructed with lies. The phone rings, and Jackie and Minnie explain that Walter’s extended family want to meet Stevenson.
Chapter Seven : Justice Denied.
Stevenson thinks Charlie is way too small and young-looking and terrified to be even fourteen. Charlie can’t make eye contact or respond as Stevenson introduces himself. Stevenson’s concern for Charlie grows as the boy remains unresponsive. He tries to make jokes, but receives no response.
Charlie tried to revive her and stop the bleeding, begging his mother to wake up. He had to call an ambulance, but the phone was in the bedroom with George. He entered while George was asleep and considered his hatred for George and everything he’d done to his mother before now likely having killed her.
In addition to many details provided by witnesses, after a few months, they discover that Bill Hooks had been paid $5,000 by Sheriff Tate to testify, and immediately freed after giving testimony. The State was legally obligated to reveal all of this to Walter’s counsel before trial, but they hadn’t.
Stevenson meets with Mozelle and Onzelle, Pittman’s aunts, who still have questions about the case and say they were treated by police like white trash. Stevenson digresses to discuss how, leading up to and including that time in the 1980s, not all crime victims received the same treatment or respect.
Charlie, at fourteen, had no record and was considered well-behaved, but Charlie had shot and killed his mother’s boyfriend George, who was drunk and violent. The night of the shooting, George punched Charlie’s mother, causing her to fall unconscious on the floor.