i can't afford a lawyer how do i get a public defender for new york

by Dr. Rebeca Stark Jr. 10 min read

Ask a lawyer - it's free! If, based on your financial information, the judge states that you do not qualify, and you return to court after talking with some attorneys and tell the judge you could not afford to hire anyone, the judge will sometimes, at that point, grant you a public defender.

The City Bar Justice Center's Legal Hotline offers legal information, advice and referrals to low-income New Yorkers who cannot afford a private attorney or do not have access to legal representation.

Full Answer

Can I get a public defender if I can't afford an attorney?

 · You will not be eligible for a public defender unless you cannot afford a private defense lawyer. At the time of your request, you can expect the court to inquire into your finances. The judge may even require evidence of economic hardship for you or your family.

How can I Help my Public Defender?

 · 3 attorney answers. If, based on your financial information, the judge states that you do not qualify, and you return to court after talking with some attorneys and tell the judge you could not afford to hire anyone, the judge will sometimes, at that point, grant you a public defender. However, if you own a home, or make significant income the judge will stick to …

Can I get a public defender for a traffic ticket?

 · If you can't afford an attorney, you have the right to have a lawyer provided for you in a criminal case, which generally means a public defender. But what if you want a new public defender because of problems with your assigned one? A public defender is a government-paid attorney whose sole job is to represent criminal defendants who can't afford their own lawyer. …

What happens if a public defender is appointed immediately?

How do I get appointed a public defender? I cant afford a lawyer. Lawyer directory. Find a lawyer near you. Avvo has 97% of all lawyers in the US. Find the best ones near you. ... New …

image

What is it called when you can't afford a lawyer?

When a court decides someone is "indigent" - with few assets and no funds to pay an attorney - generally either a private lawyer will be appointed by the court and paid with county funds, or a public defender program will be appointed to represent the person.

Do I qualify for a public defender in NY?

To qualify for a public defender, a person must have an income that is no more than 25% above the poverty line, based on the number of people in the household.

What does a public defender cost?

Under California law, every person who is represented by a court-appointed attorney, including the Public Defender's Office, may be asked to pay a registration fee of up to $25 to the County of Napa. You will not be forced to pay anything if you cannot afford to pay the registration fee.

What if a person can't afford to have a lawyer for his or her defense?

If you're unable to afford a lawyer, you should start by looking into Legal Aid. Legal aid is an umbrella term for any service which provides legal assistance to those unable to afford it otherwise.

Do you need a lawyer for Family court in NY?

The parties in most Family Court proceedings have the right to have a lawyer. You are free to hire a lawyer of your choosing. If your particular case is one where you have the right to a lawyer, but you cannot afford to pay for your own lawyer, then the court will usually assign one to the represent you.

What percentage of criminal defendants Cannot afford private lawyers?

The U.S. Department of Justice estimates that 60 to 90 percent of defendants can't afford to hire their own attorney and must instead have a court-appointed public defender. Because of these factors, public defenders may have little time to meet with a defendant and prepare their client's case.

Who holds the burden of proof?

In a civil lawsuit, the burden of proof rests on the plaintiff or the person filing the suit. The plaintiff should prove that the allegations are true and that the defendant, or the other party, caused damages. When it comes to establishing a civil case, the plaintiff must usually do so by a preponderance of evidence.

Are public defenders lawyers?

Public defenders are licensed attorneys, but they are not specialized and because of a high turnover of clients may not have the solid field experience a seasoned private attorney has. Using a public defender is like going to a family doctor when you really need a heart surgeon.

What to do if your public defender is not doing his job?

You can request the court for a new public defender. The judge in charge of your case will then switch public defenders on your case. If you are successful, the judge will appoint a new public defender to represent you.

Can I represent myself in court?

Provision for Fighting One's Own Case as per Advocate's Act. Section 32 of the Advocate's Act clearly mentions, the court may allow any person to appear before it even if he is not an advocate. Therefore, one gets the statutory right to defend one's own case through Advocate Act in India.

Can you get legal aid for criminal cases?

If your case goes to the Crown Court, legal aid is available, but is also means-tested, however, you will always be granted legal aid but may have to pay a contribution to the government to cover all the costs of representing you in court.

Can you get legal aid for civil cases?

There are two types of legal aid: for civil and for criminal cases. All applications for legal aid for criminal cases are means tested. But some applications for legal aid for civil cases are not means tested, for example care cases and Mental Health Tribunal cases.

Julie Crawford

If, based on your financial information, the judge states that you do not qualify, and you return to court after talking with some attorneys and tell the judge you could not afford to hire anyone, the judge will sometimes, at that point, grant you a public defender.

Curtis Lamar Harrington Jr

Explain to the judge using balance sheets and cash flow how you advance above the threshold for public defender and yet below a threshold level of non-affordability. You may want to fill out the schedules for a chapter 7 bankruptcy to help your organize your showing to the judge.

Robert Lee Marshall

How do you know whether you qualify for the public defender? Have you already applied and been rejected? If it's the first court appearance, tell the judge that you would like to have the public defender appointed. The court will probably have you fill out a financial declaration...

How to change your public defender?

To change your public defender, you generally need to write a letter to the judge in your case or contact the public defender's office, depending on the rules in your state. Make sure you keep good notes of what you believe to be the biggest problems with your attorney.

What happens if you can't afford an attorney?

If you can't afford an attorney, you have the right to have a lawyer provided for you in a criminal case, which generally means a public defender. But what if you want a new public defender because of problems with your assigned one?

What to do before filing paperwork?

Before you file any paperwork, make sure that you talk to your current public defender. Sometimes the issue isn't that your attorney isn't doing the work, it's a communication problem. Tell your attorney about what is making you unhappy, and see if something can be done to change it.

Can a public defender be difficult to work with?

But just like in any other field, sometimes public defenders can be difficult to work with. If you think this may negatively affect your case, then you need to know how to get a new lawyer.

1. Ask for a Public Defender at Arraignment

Once arrested, you will either be given a notice to appear in court, or you will be held in a local jail cell until your arraignment.

2. Interview With the Public Defender's Office

Many cities and counties ( like San Francisco, for example) have their own dedicated public defender's offices. These offices employ full-time government lawyers who work exclusively to represent indigent criminal defendants for free.

3. Conflicts of Interest Check

Once you've proven yourself eligible for free legal representation, then the public defender's office will likely conduct an intake interview in order to assign you to a specific attorney.

How often do you have to hire a public defender?

Unfortunately, public defenders often handle hundreds of cases every week and do not have the time to carefully review every file. Most public defenders glance at the file a few minutes or hours before the case goes to court and decide what to do then.

How much does it cost to represent a misdemeanor?

You can usually find someone to represent you on a misdemeanor case for between $500 and $2,000 dollars, depending on their experience and where you live. For a felony case, it varies a lot more depending on what you are charged with, but you can expect it to cost between $2,000 and $10,000. Unless you have a specific conflict, there is no way ...

Can you fire an attorney?

You cannot "fire" an appointed lawyer as you can with a one you have retained. You may, however, request what is called a Marsden hearing. In this closed hearing, the judge will hear your complaints, and let the public defender respond, and then make a decision about whether or not you are receiving adequate representation. If the judge feels that you are not, he/she will relieve your current attorney and appoint another one. You do not, however, get to make a choice as to what lawyer you wish to have; such is the public defender process. These are hard motions to win but they are granted occasionally. Otherwise, you will be left with your present attorney. Of course, you can always hire the attorney of your choice. If nothing else, when a public defender has to respond to a Marsden motion he/she sometimes get the message and work a little harder on the case.

Can you retain a public defender?

Retaining private counsel will remove the public defender. Otherwise you must make a motion to the court for a new attorney.

Can you hire a lawyer for Marsden?

Otherwise, you will be left with your present attorney. Of course, you can always hire the attorney of your choice. If nothing else, when a public defender has to respond to a Marsden motion he/she sometimes get the message and work a little harder on the case.

What is the first time you can ask a lawyer to represent you?

In general, the first time you can request a lawyer to represent you will be the first time to appear before the judge after his arrest. This is called an arraignment .

Is a lawyer better than nothing?

To answer this question, it should be borne in mind that, in most situations, any legal representation in a criminal hearing is better than none. However, this does not mean that a lawyer is a little better than nothing. In fact, many public defenders and legal aid lawyers are some of the best legal minds in the world. Public defenders usually have more hours on the court and experience that many defense attorneys private that the bend in age. Is more, the public defenders have been on the side of the defense of many of the causes of the most recognized in the history of our country.

What to do if you don't have a lawyer?

Still, whether it's a divorce or you're being taken to court for something else, if you don't have a lawyer, a logical move would be to call the courthouse and ask who they would suggest going to. You think you're the first person who couldn't afford a lawyer? Hardly.

What happens if you can't afford legal assistance?

In a criminal proceeding, if you can't afford legal assistance, a court will appoint an attorney for you. In a civil case, generally described as a dispute between two private parties, to get legal representation, you have to get creative.

How to get free legal consultation?

Some attorneys will offer free consultations – usually by phone or videoconference. You aren't likely to come away feeling like you're ready to try your first case, but even if it's just a 15-minute call, you may at least get enough information to have a better sense of what legal morass you're in for. You might also be able to get some direction as to who can help you for free or a bargain basement price.

What happens if you lose a pro bono case?

That is, if you lose your case, you won't pay money, but if you win, the law firm will take a portion of the money awarded to you.

What law schools offer free legal advice?

Many law schools have pro bono programs in which law students can offer free legal advice. Some of the schools that have such programs include American University, Appalachian School of Law, Arizona State University, Howard University, Tulane University and many others.

What is lawhelp.org?

You can find more ideas at LawHelp.org, a nonprofit aimed at connecting people with low and moderate incomes to free legal aid programs in their communities.

What is legal aid?

Legal aid societies are nonprofit organizations found in almost every corner of the country that provide free legal services to low-income people. While this is certainly worth exploring, the problem for many households is that the individual or couple makes too much money to qualify for help.

image

Ask For A Public Defender at Arraignment.

  • Once arrested, you will either be given a notice to appear in court, or you will be held in a local jail cell until your arraignment. In either case, you must appear at your arraignment court date, at which time you can ask the judge for a court-appointed public defender. Depending on your state or county, you may be required to bring proof of your...
See more on findlaw.com

Interview with The Public Defender's Office.

  • Many cities and counties (like San Francisco, for example) have their own dedicated public defender's offices. These offices employ full-time government lawyers who work exclusively to represent indigent criminal defendants for free. After requesting a public defender at arraignment, you will typically be required to provide the public defender's office with proof of your poor finan…
See more on findlaw.com

Conflicts of Interest Check.

  • Once you've proven yourself eligible for free legal representation, then the public defender's office will likely conduct an intake interview in order to assign you to a specific attorney. Since many public defenders handle literally hundreds of cases each year, it is important for the public defender's office to determine -- based on the intake interview or future conversations -- if repres…
See more on findlaw.com