how to respond to your own lawyer of settlement offer

by Corine Mueller 4 min read

Full Answer

Should I accept my lawyer’s settlement offer?

Your lawyer must discuss the settlement offer with you, because you are the one who has to make the actual decision about whether or not to accept the settlement offer. You have to understand the risks and benefits of accepting or rejecting the settlement offer.

Do I need a lawyer to negotiate a personal injury settlement?

Not only will your lawyer be able to help you value your injury claim, but your attorney can help you when you negotiate a settlement for your injury. It is best to let your lawyer handle any direct negotiations with the insurance company. Generally, you should not propose a counter settlement number to the insurance company over the phone.

How do I respond to a car accident settlement offer?

Develop and plan your response (which is often called a counteroffer). Respond to the offer in writing. Do not settle your claim until you have healed from your injuries. Serious car accident injuries may cause you to incur substantial medical bills.

How can I get a fair personal injury settlement offer?

Most personal injury law firms offer a free consultation to injured victims. Sometimes a letter from your attorney is all it takes to get a stubborn or lazy adjuster to make a fair personal injury settlement offer. Charles R. Gueli, Esq. is a personal injury attorney with over 20 years of legal experience.

How do you respond to a settlement offer?

Steps to Respond to a Low Settlement OfferRemain Calm and Analyze Your Offer. Just like anything in life, it's never a good idea to respond emotionally after receiving a low offer. ... Ask Questions. ... Present the Facts. ... Develop a Counteroffer. ... Respond in Writing.

How do you politely decline a settlement offer?

Countering a Low Insurance Settlement OfferState that the offer you received is unacceptable.Refute any statements in the adjustor's letter that are inaccurate and damaging to your claim.Re-state an acceptable figure.Explain why your counteroffer is appropriate, including the reasons behind your general damages demands.More items...•

How do you respond to a settlement letter?

Once you receive a written copy of the initial settlement offer, review the settlement amounts and the reasons stated for such a low offer. You should respond to each of the reasons cited by the claims adjuster in a written letter that includes a logical and reasonable counter-offer.

Can I negotiate a settlement claim?

Indeed, it means you're ready to demand the compensation you deserve for your suffering and losses. If you are determined to seek fair compensation for your losses, you must be prepared to negotiate with the insurance company (or, more specifically, the claims adjuster) to get what you want.

Should I accept the first offer of compensation?

Unless you have taken independent legal advice on the whole value of your claim, you should not accept a first offer from an insurance company.

How do I reject a payment offer?

Declining the offer in person If you're sure that you want to decline, consider saying something like this: "I appreciate the offer and your time, but I can't accept this position at the salary you're offering. If the salary range is something that can be negotiated, please let me know."

What happens if you pay a settlement offer?

When you settle an account, its balance is brought to zero, but your credit report will show the account was settled for less than the full amount. Settling an account instead of paying it in full is considered negative because the creditor agreed to take a loss in accepting less than what it was owed.

What percentage of a debt is typically accepted in a settlement?

Typically, a creditor will agree to accept 40% to 50% of the debt you owe, although it could be as much as 80%, depending on whether you're dealing with a debt collector or the original creditor. In either case, your first lump-sum offer should be well below the 40% to 50% range to provide some room for negotiation.

How do you increase your settlement value?

Here are three tips that can help you do that:Increase the Defendant's Risk. One of the best ways to increase the value of a settlement without going to trial is to increase the defendant's risk. ... Objectify the Plaintiff's Injuries. ... Establish Gross Negligence. ... What You can do to Help Your Client in the Meantime.

How do lawyers negotiate settlements?

The negotiation process typically starts with your lawyer providing a written proposal for settlement to the insurance adjuster or the defendant's lawyer. The adjuster or lawyer will respond to your lawyer either in writing or over the phone.

How do you evaluate a settlement offer?

A variety of factors can affect what a reasonable settlement offer might be, including the following:Whether the injured plaintiff is partially liable.The extent and severity of the victim's injuries.The past and future likely costs of treatment.Whether the plaintiff is likely to fully recover or has fully recovered.More items...

How do you negotiate a compensation settlement?

How to Negotiate the Best Deal on Your Settlement AgreementPrepare Well for the Settlement Agreement Negotiation. ... Decide which negotiation tactics to use. ... Ask for a Protected Conversation with your Employer. ... Don't ask for too much. ... Don't ask for too little. ... Find out how the settlement payments will be taxed.More items...

How to respond to a low settlement offer?

Find out why the insurance claims adjuster evaluated your case the way he or she did. Call or email the claims adjuster with specific questions that break down where the offer came from. The insurance adjuster lawfully must give a reason if he or she denies your claim. The adjuster’s responses can guide you in how to respond with an appropriate and informed counteroffer. For example, if the adjuster estimated your losses based on incomplete injury documentation, you may be able to provide updated medical expenses or proof of lost wages to increase the offer.

How to negotiate with an insurance adjuster?

Stay polite and professional when negotiating with an insurance claims adjuster, even if you believe he or she is trying to take advantage of you or is using bad faith tactics. Getting angry and yelling at the adjuster will not help your case and may even hurt your ability to obtain fair compensation. Your anger could position you as an unreliable witness and put you at a greater disadvantage during settlement negotiations. Try to remain calm and polite instead. Hire a personal injury attorney to speak to insurance companies on your behalf if desired.

What is the most difficult part of a personal injury claim?

Dealing with an insurance company is one of the most difficult aspects of a personal injury claim. Even if you succeed in proving someone else’s liability for your accident and injuries, you may then have to contend with a lowball settlement offer or other bad faith tactics from an insurance provider to ensure a fair outcome.

What happens if you collect more evidence?

The more evidence you collect, the stronger your claim to damages will be. You will have the paperwork backing up the amount you believe is fair and reasonable to cover your damages, making it more difficult for the insurance company to argue for a lower settlement.

Do you have to accept a low insurance offer?

Do not let an insurance company pressure you into accepting a low offer. No law obligates you to say yes to the first, second or any settlement offer. You do not have to accept until you believe the insurance company is offering a fair amount.

Try to Remain Calm and Analyze the Offer

One of the biggest mistakes you can make is to fire back a response, as this is when emotions are running high, particularly if you’re angry, upset, or in desperate need of money. You need to remain calm and give yourself time to go over the offer and think about how you’ll respond.

Respond in writing

You should always respond in writing to the offer, however, it’s fine to call or email the insurance adjuster before writing a formal response, as this is a good opportunity to ask any questions before you proceed.

Formulate Your Counteroffer

The next step you need to take is to calculate your counteroffer, and while tempting, it's not going to go down well if you respond to a low personal injury settlement with an equally unreasonable - but far higher - counteroffer.

Final Verdict

It’s perfectly normal to get a low settlement offer the first time around, so don’t worry if this happens to you, as it’s seen more as a starting point and the insurance company is simply testing you.

What does it mean when a settlement offer is too low?

You know the first settlement offer for your injuries is going to be too low. This means that you need to be patient when responding to it. For many victims, this creates a frustrating delay. Most people want to get their claim resolved as soon as possible so they can start putting their accident behind them.

Why do companies push victims into low settlement agreements?

They do this because they want to settle all personal injury cases before the victims have an opportunity to speak to a personal injury attorney.

What is the law in Rhode Island for people injured by another party?

Under Rhode Island law, people who have been injured due to another party’s negligence are entitled to compensation for the full extent of their damages. In other words, you need to add together all of your economic and noneconomic damages to find the fair value of your claim.

How to get a lawyer after an accident?

Not only will your lawyer be able to help you value your injury claim, but your attorney can help you when you negotiate a settlement for your injury. It is best to let your lawyer handle any direct negotiations with the insurance company. Generally, you should not propose a counter settlement number to the insurance company over the phone. Instead, you should get all of the information related to your case in front of your lawyer so that he or she can formulate a written counteroffer.

What happens if you make a counter offer?

Making a counter is a complicated process. If you make an unreasonably high offer, the negotiations may grind to a halt. On the other hand, if you make a counteroffer that is still too low, you may leave money on the table.

What does an insurance company look for in a conversation?

Remember that All Conversations are Formal. Insurance companies will look for information that they can use against you to reduce the value of the claim. For example, the insurance company may try to find some reason to suggest that your accident was partially your fault.

Why is it important to understand the underlying interests of insurance companies?

Above all else, the company is attempting to make money. The more the company pays out in settlements, the less money it will bring in.

Lowball Settlement Offer: Why Did I Receive It?

In most cases, you will receive an undesirable settlement offer simply because that is the opposing insurance company’s job. They are capitalistic, for-profit companies that aim to maximaize their profits while reducing their payouts for car accidents.

Write a Rejection Letter

Once you understand why the other insurance company sent you less compensation than you deserve and you have thoroughly read the settlement offer, you need to respond with a rejection letter. You have a legal right, as a party in the car accident insurance claim, to dismiss the amount that the adjustor gave you and fight for a higher payment.

Make a Reasonable Counteroffer

A reasonable counteroffer is a key component of your rejection letter that you must include for the insurance adjustor to increase your settlement. Without a new compensation amount for them to consider, you have no local ground to defend obtaining a higher dollar amount.

We Have Experience Negotiating Low Settlement Offers

You, like other personal injury victims, can find yourself in a financially challenging position if an opposing driver crashes into your vehicle and compromises its functionality and your health. Feeling like a victim is difficult to avoid when you are wearing a cast or are having to catch rides from family.