fictional story about lawyer who bought as much cherokee land as he could to save the cherokee

by Dr. Darlene Medhurst 7 min read

Why did Georgia remove the Cherokee from their land?

In 1828, tired of resistance and emboldened by the election of Andrew Jackson (a president in favor of removal of Indigenous peoples), members of the Georgia state legislature passed a series of laws meant to strip the Cherokee people of their rights to the land.

How did Will Thomas help the Cherokee?

In 1830, Will Thomas became the agent/attorney for the Qualla Cherokee. As the U.S., under President Andrew Jackson, pushed for full removal of the Native peoples of the Southeast, Will Thomas helped the North Carolina Cherokees resist removal by buying land for them.

Who owned the land in the Cherokee Nation?

Cherokees owned their land collectively and the concept of individual land ownership was foreign. By the late 1800s, sentiment in the U.S. turned towards moving Indians to reservations and opening their lands for occupation and westward expansion.

How did Andrew Jackson affect the Cherokee Nation?

The council named Ridge his counselor. A month later, Andrew Jackson was elected president of the United States. He would test the Cherokees’ leadership soon enough, but even before Jackson was inaugurated, Georgia presented a more immediate threat, passing laws that annexed Cherokee land and extended state laws to that territory.

How did the Cherokee try to save their land?

The Cherokee used legal means in their attempt to safeguard their rights. They sought protection from land-hungry white settlers, who continually harassed them by stealing their livestock, burning their towns, and sqatting on their land.

Did John Ross sell Cherokee land?

They agreed to sell their land and move west within two years. Ross did not agree and fought for the next two years to stop it, but nothing worked. In 1838, the Cherokee were forced to leave their homes and move to Oklahoma. The 800-mile journey became known as the “Trail of Tears”.

What court case ruled the Cherokee could stay in their land?

Worcester v. Georgia was a landmark case of the Supreme Court. Although it did not prevent the Cherokee from being removed from their land, the decision was often used to craft subsequent Indian law in the United States.

Who sold the Cherokee land?

Under the guidance of Major Ridge, his son John, and his nephew Elias Boudinot, a small group of Cherokees signed the 1835 Treaty of New Echota, which ceded all Cherokee Nation land east of the Mississippi and stated that the Cherokees would remove in two years.

Who is the most famous Cherokee?

John Ross (1790-1866) was the most important Cherokee political leader of the nineteenth century. He helped establish the Cherokee national government and served as the Cherokee Nation's principal chief for almost 40 years.

Who was the most famous Cherokee warrior?

Cherokee Indians called themselves “The Principal People.”

Who won the Cherokee Nation v Georgia case?

Georgia, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the Cherokee Nation was sovereign. According to the decision rendered by Chief Justice John Marshall, this meant that Georgia had no rights to enforce state laws in its territory.

What was the name of the court case that was to determine the fate of the Native American tribes?

Menominee Tribe of Indians v. 506, 607 F.

Does tribal law supersede state law?

As a general rule, state laws do not apply to Indians in Indian country. Instead, tribal and federal laws apply.

How much money do Native Americans get a month?

Members of some Native American tribes receive cash payouts from gaming revenue. The Santa Ynez Band of Chumash Indians, for example, has paid its members $30,000 per month from casino earnings. Other tribes send out more modest annual checks of $1,000 or less.

What are the 3 Cherokee tribes?

There are only three federally recognized Cherokee tribes in the U.S. - the Cherokee Nation and the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians, both in Tahlequah, and the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians in North Carolina.

Who helped the Cherokee survive on the Trail of Tears?

In 1838–39 Ross had no choice but to lead his people to their new home west of the Mississippi River on the journey that came to be known as the infamous Trail of Tears. In the West Ross helped write a constitution (1839) for the United Cherokee Nation.

What did Justice Thompson argue about the Cherokee Nation?

He argued that the way the Cherokee Nation was treated by Congress when signing treaties was more relevant than analyzing word choice in the Constitution.

What did the Cherokee Nation do in Worcester v. Georgia?

The Cherokee Nation did not give up and attempted to sue again in Worcester v. Georgia (1832). This time, the Court found in favor of the Cherokee people. According to the Supreme Court in Worcester v.

Why did Wirt argue that the Court had jurisdiction over the case?

Wirt argued that the Court had jurisdiction over the case because the government had previously recognized the Cherokee Nation as a foreign state in treaties. Attorneys on behalf of Georgia argued that the state had a right to the land-based on its 1802 agreement with the federal government. Additionally, the Cherokee Nation could not be considered ...

What was the Cherokee Nation v. Georgia case?

Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831) asked the Supreme Court to determine whether a state may impose its laws on Indigenous peoples and their territory. In the late 1820s, the Georgia legislature passed laws designed to force the Cherokee people off their historic land. The Supreme Court refused to rule on whether the Georgia state laws were applicable to the Cherokee people. Instead, the Court ruled that it did not have jurisdiction over the case because the Cherokee Nation, was a “domestic dependent nation” instead of a “ foreign state ."

Why did the Supreme Court not rule on the Cherokee Nation v. Georgia case?

Instead, the Court ruled that it did not have jurisdiction over the case because the Cherokee Nation, was a “domestic dependent nation” instead of a “ foreign state .". Fast Facts: Cherokee Nation v. Georgia. Case Argued: 1831.

Why did the Supreme Court not have jurisdiction to hear the Cherokee case?

Ruling: The Supreme Court ruled that it did not have jurisdiction to hear the case because the Cherokee Nation is not a "foreign State" but rather a "domestic foreign state," as defined by Article III of the Constitution.

How many Cherokees died on the Trail of Tears?

It is unknown exactly how many Cherokees died on the trail, but estimates place the number at between three and four thousand.

Why did the Cherokee tribe buy back the Cherokee?

Since the 1990s, the tribe has been buying back historic Cherokee sites in an attempt to reclaim the land stolen from them, revive a history too often ignored, and assert their sovereignty. (Related: Sequoyah, the Native American-governed state that almost existed.)

What was the land taken from the Cherokee?

The land taken from them was redistributed to white settlers. </p>. An 1884 map shows the territory that originally belonged to the Cherokee. The land taken from them was redistributed to white settlers. Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division.

What tribes were involved in the Cherokee burial?

Two years later, the EBCI came together with two other tribes, the United Ketoowah Band and the Cherokee Nation, to formally rededicate the land. In keeping with an old, pre-removal tradition, tribal children brought dirt from their own homes to help rebuild the mound, which had greatly reduced in size due to farming. It was an emotional moment for many Cherokees who had grown up hearing stories about the Mother Town passed down over generations.

What is the name of the first Cherokee settlement?

Kituwah, known as “the Mother Town,” was the first Cherokee settlement and is considered the place of origin for the Cherokee people. The EBCI reclaimed the land in 1996 after being forced out in the 1830s to go on the Trail of Tears.

Where is Landon French?

Right: Landon French, seen here in 2019, is a tribal member of the EBCI and a PE teacher at New Kituwah Academy Elementary, a school dedicated to teaching Cherokee language and culture. Kituwah, known as “the Mother Town,” is considered the place of origin for the Cherokee people.

Where is the Cherokee Cultural Corridor?

In August, the EBCI broke ground for an interpretive kiosk at the Nikwasi mound, part of a larger plan to create a 60-mile Cherokee cultural corridor along the Little Tennessee River in North Carolina. The tribe has also designed programs to educate younger generations of tribal members, to help them explore their culture and figure out what it means to be Native in today’s world.

Where did the Cherokee Indians live?

Now the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians is piecing back together their sacred sites. The Cherokee town of Chota once stood on this site in eastern Tennessee, seen in September, until American troops destroyed it in 1780 during the Revolutionary War.

What did Marshall say about the Cherokee?

Taking aim at removal, Marshall wrote, “Protection does not imply the destruction of the protected.”. Ross wrote to some Cherokee delegates in Washington, “ [T]here are great rejoicings throughout the [Cherokee] nation.”. But Jackson declared the ruling “stillborn.”.

What did Jackson do to the Cherokees?

Jackson had been serving as a federal Indian commissioner when he launched his first effort to remove the Cherokees en masse . In 1817, he appeared with two other agents at the Cherokees’ council in Calhoun, just northeast of what is now Cleveland, Tennessee, to inform the tribe that if it refused to move west, it would have to submit to white men’s laws, no matter what any treaties might say. The chiefs dismissed the agents without hesitation. “Brothers, we wish to remain on our land, and hold it fast,” their signed statement said. “We appeal to our father the president of the United States to do us justice. We look to him for protection in the hour of distress.”

How many Cherokees left Tennessee?

Through threats and bribery, Jackson eventually persuaded a few thousand Cherokees to leave Tennessee; Ross became the spokesman of those who remained—some 16,000 resolved to hold their ground. After years of trading land for peace, the council in 1822 passed a resolution vowing never to cede a single acre more.

Why did the Cherokee Council establish a national committee?

In a move intended to prevent local chiefs from accepting bribes to sell off Cherokee land, the Cherokee council in 1817 established a national committee to handle all tribal business. When Ross arrived at the council meeting as a spectator, Ridge led him into a private conference and told him that he would be one of 13 members of the committee. Ross was only 26—a young man in a community where leadership traditionally came with age. Just a month later, he would have to confront Andrew Jackson directly.

What happened to the Cherokees in 1830?

In February 1830, the tribe exercised its legal right to evict squatters; Ridge, then 60, led a two-day raid in which Cherokees burned settlers’ houses and outbuildings. After Georgia authorities sent a posse after the Cherokees, gunfire rang out through northern Georgia.

What did Jackson's resolve unnerve the younger Ridge?

Jackson’s resolve unnerved the younger Ridge. Gradually, he realized that court victory or not, his people were losing ground. But he could not relay that message to the tribe for fear of being branded a traitor, or killed. He was even hesitant to confide in his father, believing Major Ridge would be ashamed of him.

What did Jackson say about Indian removal?

On one hand, he had said in his inaugural address, Indian emigration “should be voluntary, for it would be as cruel as unjust to compel the aborigines to abandon the graves of their fathers and seek a home in a distant land.” On the other, he made it clear that Indians could not live as independent peoples within the United States: “surrounded by the whites with their arts of civilization” they would be doomed “to weakness and decay.” They had either to submit to state laws or go.

What act paved the way for certain tribes including the Cherokee Nation to take back their government and popularly elect tribal?

The Principal Chief’s Act of 1970 paved the way for certain tribes including the Cherokee Nation to take back their government and popularly elect tribal officials once again. In 1971, the first Cherokee Nation election in nearly 70 years was held and a new Constitution ratified in 1975. We have never looked back.

What was the Cherokee Nation promised?

The Cherokee Nation had been promised by treaty they would not be bothered in their new home and would never be removed again. Instead, the U.S. chose to create a new state and allot tribes’ land out to individual owners. With Oklahoma statehood in 1907, Cherokees suddenly became land owners and state citizens.

How long have Cherokee people been around?

According to tribal history, Cherokee people have existed since time immemorial. Our oral history extends back through the millennia. It’s recorded that our first European contact came in 1540 with Hernando DeSoto’s exploration of the southeastern portion of our continent. Trade and intermarriage with various European immigrants soon followed, most notably with the English, Scots and Irish. Treaties were made between the British and the Cherokee Nation as early as 1725, with Cherokee Nation being recognized as inherently sovereign through those nation-to-nation agreements. Cherokees took up arms in various sides of conflicts between the European factions, in hopes of staving off further predations of Cherokee land and sovereign rights.

What happened to the Cherokee Nation after the war?

Cherokee Nation barely had time to rebuild after the war before another threat loomed—allotment. Cherokees owned their land collectively and the concept of individual land ownership was foreign. By the late 1800s, sentiment in the U.S. turned towards moving Indians to reservations and opening their lands for occupation and westward expansion. The Cherokee Nation had been promised by treaty they would not be bothered in their new home and would never be removed again. Instead, the U.S. chose to create a new state and allot tribes’ land out to individual owners. With Oklahoma statehood in 1907, Cherokees suddenly became land owners and state citizens. Much of the Cherokee Nation’s infrastructure was dissolved, including schools, courts and most of its government.

What happened to the Cherokees in the 1960s?

A dark period of great poverty ensued for many Cherokees, who suddenly had a new government and laws to navigate, as non-Indians quickly acquired former tribal lands. Tribal government trickled but never halted entirely. With the 1960s civil rights movement, a resurgence in tribal efforts took hold.

How many Cherokees were forced to leave their homes?

It’s estimated that 16,000 Cherokees eventually were forced to undertake the six to seven month journey to “Indian Territory” in the land beyond Arkansas. Between the stockades, starvation and sickness, and the harsh winter conditions, some 4,000 Cherokees perished, never reaching their new land.

When did the Cherokee Nation get its Constitution?

Cherokee Nation’s government unified the Old Settlers with the Cherokees recently immigrated from the east, ratifying a new Cherokee Nation Constitution on September 6, 1839. A new Supreme Court building quickly followed in 1844, along with the resurgence of the tribe’s newspaper, schools, businesses and other entities.

Who was the Cherokee leader who asked him to take them to London?

In 1762, Ostenaco and two other Cherokee leaders, Cunneshote and Woyi, asked him to take them to London in order to meet with King George III. “The bloody tommahawke, so long lifted against our brethren the English, must now be buried deep, deep in the ground, never to be raised again,” said Ostenaco.

Why did the English want to trade with the Cherokee?

The English wanted to build a direct trading connection with the Cherokee to bypass the Occaneechi Indians, a tribe that inhabited the Piedmont Region of what is now North Carolina and Virginia and were serving as middlemen on the Trading Path . The two colonial Virginians eventually made a connection with the Cherokee.

What did Sir Alexander tell the Cherokee?

He told the Cherokee he would be returning to England and that if they would like to accompany him, he would take them to meet his King. Seven Cherokees expressed their willingness: Attakullakulla, Oukah-Ulah, Clogoittah, Kallannah, Tahtowe, Kittagusta, and Ounaconoa. They arrived at Charlestown on April 13, 1730, and on June 5th, they landed at Dover, England, on the English man-of-war, Fox. On the 22nd, they were presented to George II. Sir Alexander laid the Cherokee opossum-skin crown that the chieftains had made at his King’s feet, and the Cherokees added four scalps and eagle tail feathers to the tribute.

What river did the Cherokee settle on?

In 1721, the Cherokee agreed to sell land between the Saluda, Santee, and Edisto rivers to the first Royal Governor of South Carolina. This exchange served to establish a boundary between the Cherokee territory and the colonists.

What tribe did the Cherokee fight?

They allied with the British in fighting the Shawnee Tribe (allies of the French) and battled again beside the British in 1712-1713 against the Tuscarora Tribe.

What was the Cherokee-British alliance?

The aftermath of these battles saw the beginning of a Cherokee-British alliance that endured for the majority of the 18th century, despite numerous rebellions and uprisings as the Cherokee fought to keep colonial settlers away from their ancestral lands.

Who gave the Cherokee a crown?

On the 22nd, they were presented to George II. Sir Alexander laid the Cherokee opossum-skin crown that the chieftains had made at his King’s feet, and the Cherokees added four scalps and eagle tail feathers to the tribute. After four months in England, the Indian chieftains signed a formal treaty with Great Britain.

Facts of The Case

Image
In 1802, the U.S. federal government promised Cherokee lands to Georgian settlers. The Cherokee people had historically occupied the lands in Georgia and been promised ownership through a series of treaties, including the Treaty of Holston in 1791. Between 1802 and 1828, land-hungry settlers and politicians atte…
See more on thoughtco.com

Constitutional Issues

  • Does the Supreme Court have jurisdiction? Should the Court grant an injunction against laws that would harm the Cherokee people?
See more on thoughtco.com

The Arguments

  • William Wirt focused on establishing the Court’s jurisdiction. He explained that Congress recognized the Cherokee Nation as a state in the commerce clause of the third article of the U.S. Constitution, which gives Congress the power to “regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian tribes." Wirt argued that the Court had jurisdiction …
See more on thoughtco.com

Majority Opinion

  • Article III of the U.S. Constitution gives the Court jurisdiction over cases "between a State or the citizens thereof, and foreign states, citizens, or subjects." Before making a ruling on the merit of the case, the Court needed to establish jurisdiction. In the majority opinion, it answered three questions to address this issue. 1. Is the Cherokee Nation considered a state? The Court found t…
See more on thoughtco.com

Dissenting Opinion

  • Justice Smith Thompson dissented, arguing that the Supreme Court did have jurisdiction over the case. The Cherokee Nation should be considered a foreign state, according to Justice Thompson, because the government had always dealt with the Cherokee Nation as a foreign state when entering into treaties. Justice Thompson did not agree with the Court’s interpretation of the com…
See more on thoughtco.com

The Impact

  • The Supreme Court’s refusal to acknowledge jurisdiction in Cherokee Nation v. Georgia meant that the Cherokee Nation did not have legal recourse against Georgia laws that sought to force them off their land. The Cherokee Nation did not give up and attempted to sue again in Worcester v. Georgia (1832). This time, the Court found in favor of the Cherokee people. According to the S…
See more on thoughtco.com

Sources

  1. “A Brief History of the Trail of Tears.” Cherokee Nation, www.cherokee.org/About-The-Nation/History/Trail-of-Tears/A-Brief-History-of-the-Trail-of-Tears.
  2. Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 30 U.S. 1 (1831).
  3. "Cherokee Nation v. Georgia 1831." Supreme Court Drama: Cases That Changed America. Encyclopedia.com.22 Aug. 2018. https://www.encyclopedia.com/law/legal-and-political-mag…
  1. “A Brief History of the Trail of Tears.” Cherokee Nation, www.cherokee.org/About-The-Nation/History/Trail-of-Tears/A-Brief-History-of-the-Trail-of-Tears.
  2. Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 30 U.S. 1 (1831).
  3. "Cherokee Nation v. Georgia 1831." Supreme Court Drama: Cases That Changed America. Encyclopedia.com.22 Aug. 2018. https://www.encyclopedia.com/law/legal-and-political-magazines/cherokee-nation-v-g...
  4. “Indian Treaties and the Removal Act of 1830.” U.S. Department of State, U.S. Department of State, history.state.gov/milestones/1830-1860/indian-treaties.