does the lawyer decide if a person who had a stroke compentent to sign a will

by Hipolito Hackett 3 min read

I have had clients that I visited in the hospital after the client suffered a heart attack, or a stroke. When we are looking at signing a will, or an estate plan, under those circumstances I generally ask for medical evidence from the doctor that the person has been examined and is competent to sign a will, or estate plan of any kind.

Full Answer

Can a neurologist be a defendant in a stroke case?

Notably, failure to provide tPA (88% of cases) and delay or failure to diagnose stroke (67%) were the most common claims by plaintiff, and only 6 cases (18%) involved a neurologist as defendant.

What are the legal aspects of stroke?

Legal aspects of stroke are based on simple principles involving competency, PPR, and informed consent. These principles form the basis of physician duty to the patient. Ultimately, it is the failure of physician duty that creates the basis for medical malpractice.

Can a family member provide consent for a stroke?

For a physician facing a stroke emergency involving a patient not competent to provide informed consent, substitute consent may be obtained, that is, consent provided on behalf of the patient by a family member (next of kin) who is expected to act in the best interests of the patient.

Can a doctor sign a will or estate plan?

When we are looking at signing a will, or an estate plan, under those circumstances I generally ask for medical evidence from the doctor that the person has been examined and is competent to sign a will, or estate plan of any kind. It is better to have someone else determine competency than rely on my own opinion in those cases.


Which of the following is not necessary for a will to be valid?

A will must be voluntarily entered into and signed by the testator. A will executed by a person who was coerced into signing the will, or who signed the will under duress, is not considered to be a valid will.

What is the test generally used by courts to determine whether a person has sound mind?

To determine whether the person had a sound mind and memory at the time of the making of the will, the court will examine whether the person understood what possessions they owned, whether the person understood the relationship between them and the people receiving their possessions, and whether the person understood ...

What are the disadvantages of power of attorney?

What Are the Disadvantages of a Power of Attorney?A Power of Attorney Could Leave You Vulnerable to Abuse. ... If You Make Mistakes In Its Creation, Your Power Of Attorney Won't Grant the Expected Authority. ... A Power Of Attorney Doesn't Address What Happens to Assets After Your Death.More items...•

What is meant by testamentary capacity?

Testamentary capacity refers to the ability of a person to make a valid will. Most states have both an age requirement (usually 18 years old) and a mental capacity requirement.

How can you tell if someone is competent?

To be considered competent, individuals need to be able to:Comprehend information that is presented to them.Understand the importance of such information.Make sound decisions among provided choices.Understand the potential impact of their decisions.

What is one of the criteria used to determine a defendant's competency to stand trial?

A competent defendant must have "sufficient present ability to consult with his attorney with a reasonable degree of rational understanding and whether he has a rational as well as factual understanding of the proceedings against him".

Who can override a power of attorney?

principalA power of attorney (POA) is a legal contract that gives a person (agent) the ability to act on behalf of someone (principal) and make decisions for them. Short answer: The principal who is still of sound mind can always override a power of attorney.

Is it worth having a power of attorney?

Indeed a power of attorney is vital for anyone – regardless of age – who has money and assets to protect and/or who wants someone to act in their best interest in terms of healthcare choices should they be unable to make decisions for themselves.

What is the difference between a power of attorney and a lasting power of attorney?

An ordinary power of attorney is only valid while you have the mental capacity to make your own decisions. If you want someone to be able to act on your behalf if there comes a time when you don't have the mental capacity to make your own decisions you should consider setting up a lasting power of attorney.

What is the legal test for testamentary capacity?

Under the Succession Act (1965) “the person making the will must be of sound disposing mind”. It is important to remember that testamentary capacity is not the same as ordinary capacity, as a person requires a high level of mental function to be in a position to make a will.

Who has the burden to prove testamentary capacity?

51 The burden of proving testamentary capacity is on the party propounding the Will, but there is a presumption of capacity where the Will has been duly executed, with the requisite formalities, after having been read by or to a testator who appeared to understand it.

How do you assess capacity for a will?

Prospective assessment of testamentary capacityunderstand the nature of making a will and its effects.understand the extent of the assets they are bequeathing.comprehend and appreciate the (moral) claims to which they must give effect.More items...•

What happens if you don't have a DPOA?

If the judge decides the person did not have the capacity to make the DPOA, the most recent prior DPOA will be effective. If there is no DPOA, you may need to set up a formal conservatorship. However, if the person indeed had the capacity to execute the DPOA at the time, the DPOA is valid.

What is a power of attorney?

A power of attorney is a legal document that lets you (the “principal”) appoint someone (the “agent”) to act on your behalf in financial matters. A durable power of attorney (DPOA) remains in effect even after you become incapacitated, letting your agent continue to handle your affairs when you cannot. This is enormously helpful for the family ...

What is the name of the document that designates an agent for medical decisions?

Note: To designate an agent for medical decisions you will need a separate document called an Advance Health Care Directive or “living will”. Who decides if a person is “competent” to sign a DPOA? It is quite common for children or caregivers to disagree over whether the signer was competent when signing.

Can you consult an attorney before signing a DPOA?

Many people use a standard DPOA form such as California’s Uniform Statutory Form Power of Attorney, and never consult an attorney. In that case, no one is obliged to evaluate your capacity before you sign. That is usually fine, because challenges to a DPOA are quite rare. Sometimes, however, you can predict that someone might want to challenge ...

Can you challenge DPOA after you become incapacitated?

Sometimes, however, you can predict that someone might want to challenge the DPOA after you become incapacitated. For instance, if your children do not get along, or already argue about your care and finances, they will probably continue to argue after you become incapacitated.

Can a parent sign a DPOA without the family knowing?

Sometimes, after a parent becomes incapacitated, a child or caregiver presents a new DPOA signed by a parent without the rest of the family’s knowledge. The family may be concerned that the parent was unable to understand the document, or was even tricked or coerced into signing it.

What happens if an attorney does not have capacity?

An attorney must assess capacity and if there is no capacity, then the attorney could not ethically allow the documents to be signed. In cases where capacity is tough to determine, a lawyer must be extra careful.

What does a lawyer do with dementia?

A very, very difficult question. The lawyer represents his or her client, and has a duty to do what the client wants. That means the lawyer needs to be assured that the client is able to clearly state what he or she wants. A lawyer can find him- or her-self on the edge, in the grey area, but if the client expresses the same wishes consistently, and meets certain basic criteria, the lawyer might move forward. It's all balancing dementia hits different people differently, and just because a person is diagnosed with dementia doesn't mean they automatically lose their ability (or their right) to make testamentary plans.

What is the ethical obligation of an attorney?

An attorney has an ethical obligation to make sure that his or her client is legally competent which is not always the same thing as medically competent. * This will flag comments for moderators to take action.

What happens if your parent is not competent?

If there is some indication of incompetency it raises the obligation. If there is no indication, the obligation is low. If you think your parent was not competent when they signed a document, you may want to speak with an attorney about your options. Report Abuse. Report Abuse.

What is the attorney's responsibility?

100%. It is the attorney's responsibility to determine legal competency of the person who will be signing documents. While that can be accomplished in many ways, it is the attorney's duty to make a legal determination (not judicial, although this is sometimes necessary) of competence.

Can an attorney be a doctor?

An attorney is not a doctor and therefore cannot be expected to be able to ascertain the competency of a signor. However, an attorney has to be reasonable and if he or she has knowledge of an issue at the time of the execution the question is whether the attorney believes that the signor understands what is being signed.

Can a doctor be sued for malpractice?

A lot. They can be sued for malpractice or other torts. If there is any doubt about capacity a doctor's letter should be requested that sets forth whether the client possesses testamentary and/or contractual capacity.

Is a power of attorney executed while incompetent valid?

A power of attorney executed while incompetent is not valid, but the banks, etc. have to way to know that. The power of attorney your mother signed appointing you may also not have been valid.#N#You need to contact Adult Protective Services IMMEDIATELY, and you need to...

Can a stroke victim appoint a new agent?

Yes. Stroke victim may appoint new agent after stroke if she has capacity to do so. Ability to appoint new agent, revoke previous POA depends on degree of compromised capacity. Many stroke victims continue to have sufficient capacity to create, revoke, amend their POA's after stroke...

Do you need to sign a will for an Alzheimer's patient?

All legal documents — including Wills, Trusts, and Powers of Attorney — require that the individual signing the document have the mental capacity and the ability to comprehend the significance of the document that he or she is signing. In the case of an Alzheimer’s patient, such as your father, it is essential that legal documents be signed ...

Can someone with Alzheimer's sign a will?

Many people are surprised to find out that a person with Alzheimer’s may still be legally competent to sign documents. For instance, when it comes to a Will, under the laws of most states, a person is legally competent to sign if at the time of the signing he or she meets the following tests:

Can a conservator be a power of attorney?

If a Power of Attorney can no longer be signed, you may be able to become a Conservator. Conservators can act like an Agent under a Power of Attorney, with the capability to make financial and legal decisions. But becoming a conservator takes time and involves a costly court procedure.

Can you sign a document with a mental capacity?

The mental capacity to sign the document should not be confused with the physical ability to sign one’s name. The law will permit a person to sign an “X” (or any other “mark”), that, so long as properly witnessed, will suffice just the same as a signature.

Can a parent sign a power of attorney?

In some cases, the parent may be competent to sign a Power of Attorney, but not competent to sign a Will.

Is a trust a contract?

A Trust is sometimes deemed to be more like a contract than a Will, so that the necessary mental capacity needed to sign a trust may be less than that needed to sign a Will. Recognizing that in today’s world living trusts are most often utilized as “will substitutes,” some recent state statutes have made the test for a trust the same as that set forth above for a Will.

Can a person change their will after a stroke?

The question is not can he change his will after a stroke. The question is can any person change their will and under what circumstances. The required mental capacity for executing a will is what you might say is quite low. But given his health condition it may be that he lacks capacity to do what he is doing.

Can you challenge a will after your father passes away?

The issue is whether your father has capacity. You can't challenge a will until it is offered for probate, after your father passes. Although you can't sue now, consult an attorney to discuss how to preserve evidence and to be prepared for the likely will contest to come...

How many witnesses do you need to notarize a signature?

Instead, they make an 'X' or similar mark in front of witnesses, which can then be notarized. Depending on the state, you may need one or two witnesses. If the signer wishes to use a signature by mark, make sure to follow your state’s requirements about the procedures. For example, California requires two witnesses be present if a signer wishes ...

What is a signature by mark?

If the impaired signer is alert, coherent and appears willing to sign, another option may be for the person to sign documents with an 'X' or similar mark unassisted in lieu of a signature. This is called " signature by mark ," which many states permit. For a signature by mark, the signer does not have to write out a full name.

Which states require notary to sign a representative?

Some states, such as Colorado and Nevada, require Notaries to use special certificate wording when notarizing for a representative signer. Oregon, Hawaii, Montana and Utah require the representative signer to show the Notary proof that they have the authority to sign on behalf of the person in question.

What to do if there are no options available?

If There Are No Options Available, Don't Proceed. If the requirements for alternative methods of signing cannot be met, then do not proceed with the notarization. The customer will need to contact an attorney or other agency qualified to provide legal advice on acceptable alternatives to signing the document.

Can a notary sign on behalf of a disabled person in Montana?

Montana does not allow a Notary to sign on behalf of a disabled person , but a disinterested third party may sign by proxy if the instruction is given in person by the disabled individual and in the presence of the Notary.

Can you notarize a signature in Wisconsin?

Wisconsin does not provide guidelines for notarizing a signature by mark. However, the state does provide guidelines for notarizing a signature by proxy if a person is physically unable to sign their name: “If an individual is physically unable to sign a record, the individual may direct an individual other than the notarial officer to sign ...

Can you notarize a name if you can't sign it?

If you're asked to notarize for someone unable to sign their name due to a physical condition, don't panic. Some states provide alternatives when notarizing for a physically impaired signer, including: Powers of attorney. Representative signers.

What do you need to know to make a will?

This means that three things need to be true for you to have mental capacity to make a will (or an estate plan): You must understand the nature of and consequences of executing a will; You must know the nature and extent of the property subject to the will; You must know your descendants or heirs and your relationship to them .

What does it mean when someone thinks they can make poor decisions?

There is a full spectrum of mental capacity and cognitive function, and not all decisions someone thinks are poor decisions are indications the person cannot make their own decisions. We are all allowed to make poor decisions. That is part of being human. Good, bad, or otherwise, if you can make your own decisions, that indicates mental capacity.

Can you establish mental capacity in a will?

Sometimes establishing the mental capacity of someone who created a will can be a bit more tricky to establish. In most cases, it is easy to establish that someone who creates a will had mental capacity to do so, as no questions come up. The Colorado Statutes have a very short statement on who can make an estate plan, or a will:

Can an estate plan be established if someone has memory loss?

If a person has a recent diagnosis of memory loss, but the memory loss is minor and a person is still mentally competent, an estate plan can still be established. There is a full spectrum of mental capacity and cognitive function, and not all decisions someone thinks are poor decisions are indications the person cannot make their own decisions.

Is it better to have someone else determine competency than rely on my own opinion?

In normal cases, evidence from witnesses to the signing of a will, the attorney executing the will, notary public testimony, medical records, can show that the person had the capacity to execute a valid estate plan.

Who decides if a senior is competent and legally able to create a will, trust, or power

In many cases, an attorney must decide if a senior is deemed competent and legally able to create a will, trust or power of attorney.

What does it mean when a lawyer refuses to prepare a will?

If the attorney determines that the client is incapacitated, then they must refuse to prepare a will.

What is the competency test for a power of attorney?

With POA documents, the individual (known as the principal) must be capable of understanding and appreciating the extent and effect of the document just as if they were signing a contract. This is known as contractual capacity and is a higher level of capacity than testamentary capacity. (Keep in mind that the exact competency requirements for POA documents may vary from state to state.)

What happens if you don't preplan for elders?

Failing to preplan can have serious consequences both while an elder is still alive and after they have died. Unfortunately, once a family realizes they urgently need legal documents to help an aging loved one with cognitive issues manage their affairs ...

Can a senior sign a will?

A senior with some form of cognitive decline may experience moments of lucidity during which they could be legally competent to sign a document like a will. Furthermore, different levels of mental capacity are required to execute different legal documents and ensure their validity.

Can you sign an X mark?

Some states permit a person to sign an “X” (known as a “mark”) that will suffice in lieu of a signature . If an individual is incapable of making a mark, some states permit directing someone else, such as a notary or a disinterested third party, to sign on their behalf.

Can a person with physical disabilities sign a legal document?

Laws dictating how legal documents can be signed by individuals with physical disabilities (and how this act must be witnessed and/or notarized) vary by state. Some states permit a person to sign an “X” (known as a “mark”) that will suffice in lieu of a signature. If an individual is incapable of making a mark, some states permit directing someone else, such as a notary or a disinterested third party, to sign on their behalf.



  • It is difficult to assess whether stroke neurology is disproportionately affected by the often adversarial relations between physicians and attorneys. Nevertheless, expansion of therapeutic options for patients with stroke has created increased potential for litigation. To address this iss…
See more on

Physician–Patient Relationship

  • The physician–patient relationship(PPR) is an infrequently used term in medical circles. However, it represents an essential concept for understanding legal medicine, because it forms the basis of a legal duty (ie, obligatory conduct) that a physician has to a patient. Without this relationship, there is no legal duty and therefore no potential liability for breach of a duty. In general, a physici…
See more on

Informed Consent

  • Informed consentis perhaps the most misunderstood concept in legal medicine. This uncertainty is based on confusion between the process of informed consent and its documentation. It is critical to understand that informed consent is first and foremost a process, a process that is typically documented by either an informed consent form or by entries made by a physician in th…
See more on

Medical Malpractice

  • Medical malpractice, sometimes termed medical negligence, is a powerful presence in the minds of many physicians. Nevertheless, most physicians may be unable to articulate exactly what constitutes medical malpractice. A simple definition of malpractice is a breach of a physician’s duty that causes foreseeable injury to the patient. The terminology of this definition demands ex…
See more on

Transient Ischemic Attack, Acute Stroke, and Medical Malpractice

  • The availability for tPA as an effective treatment for acute stroke has created an entirely new area for malpractice litigation involving use or nonuse of agents for acute stroke treatment, that is, intravenous tPA and intra-arterial interventions. During the often urgent discussions in the emergency room regarding treatment of a patient with acute stroke, the issue of litigation may b…
See more on


  • Legal aspects of stroke are based on simple principles involving competency, PPR, and informed consent. These principles form the basis of physician duty to the patient. Ultimately, it is the failure of physician duty that creates the basis for medical malpractice. For the physician, medical malpractice is the most feared legal issue in stroke neurology. The risk for malpractice is largel…
See more on