as a lawyer how to interview a person taking the blame for a crime they didnt commit

Put together your alibi. Your attorney should be able to find out the crime you have been accused of, as well as when it happened and where. Then come up with a list of anyone who saw you at the time the crime was committed. Your attorney will get sworn written statements from them. Also, your attorney should try to videotape the interview.

Full Answer

What happens during a criminal interview?

Whenever a criminal is participating in an interview, two evaluations are occurring. The law enforcement, corrections, or mental health professional is officially in charge and posing questions to make whatever assessment is necessary. However, the criminal is conducting his own evaluation as well.

What to do if accused of a crime you did not commit?

Take Immediate Action. Those who know they are being accused of a crime that they did not commit should face the situation immediately and directly. If possible, the accused should hire an attorney before formal legal action can take place. The attorney will then advise his or her client on the following steps.

Is it legal for defense attorneys to interview prosecution witnesses?

It's perfectly legal for defense attorneys and their investigators to interview prosecution witnesses in most instances. (Among the instances in which it's not are those involving harassment or threats.)

How can a lawyer help an accused person?

Keeping dated documentation of every conversation and action that takes place is arguably the best piece of advice a lawyer will give the accused. Tape-record all telephone conversations that take place between the accused and others.

What are the two types of defamation cases?

There are the two main types of defamation cases: libel and slander. Both involve harmful, false statements that cause damage someone's reputation, but libel requires that the statement be in writing or somehow "published." With slander, all that is required is that the defamatory statement be spoken to a third party (someone other than you).

Is false accusing someone of a crime defamatory?

But in your case, it may not matter much, because under defam ation laws in most states, falsely accusing someone of having committed a crime is considered "defamatory per se" or "actionable per se.". That means harm is taken as a given in the eyes of the law, and harm to your reputation is presumed. Depending on your state's laws, you may only need ...

What does a lawyer learn from failure?

A good lawyer will learn from failure and make the necessary adjustments so it does not happen again in the future. Every lawyer will experience failure at some point . The key question is whether the lawyer can deal with it and bounce back in the future. What to look for in an answer:

What is disagreement in law?

Disagreements happen in the practice of law. Two attorneys can reach different opinions about an issue and both can be correct. It is even more difficult when one of the attorneys works for the other. Part of being a successful lawyer is learning how to make one’s voice heard without being overbearing.

When interviewing a criminal defense attorney, is it time to select one to hire?

When you are done interviewing the criminal defense attorneys, it is time to select one to hire. Your decision is easy if one clearly met all your criteria. But if youre torn between two or more, ask for the contact information for some former clients. Call them and ask about their experiences working with their lawyer.

What to do if you have been charged with a crime?

If youve been charged with a crime, you need the services of a lawyer. To find the right one, consider interviewing a couple of criminal defense lawyers. If you do not know which questions to ask, this article can help.

How do lawyers charge for their time?

Most lawyers charge for their time using one of two billing methods: Either with an hourly fee or a flat fee. It may be worth it to shop around, comparing hourly rates and flat fees.

Why do lawyers use case management?

Lawyers use the term case management to describe how a case is handled behind the scenes. Its important for you to know the logistics, so that there will be no misunderstandings. Some relevant questions to ask include:

What documents do criminal lawyers need?

Some documents that will help the criminal law lawyers understand your situation are: Your bail papers. Any documents from the court showing your charges and next court appearance date. A copy of the police report, if possible. Any paperwork you may have received if your property was searched.

What to do if your property is searched?

Any paperwork you may have received if your property was searched. Bring these with you to your first meeting with a criminal defense lawyer. Also, compile a list of any witnesses, victims, or other defendants connected to your accused crime.

Can a criminal defense lawyer meet you personally?

Some criminal defense lawyers are so busy, they may not have time to meet you personally. They may have their staff meet with you. You shouldnt eliminate them as possible candidates just because they are unable to meet you personally. Come to the meeting prepared.

3 attorney answers

I agree with Ms Gutekunst. There are a few other technicalities regarding using an accomplices testimony to convict and corroboration requirements for that to happen, but to answer your question people can and do say whatever they feel serves their best interests at the time.

Lewis Robert Rosenblum

Wow that's a lot of detail about things, but the bottom line is if you're charged with possession of an illegal item (switchblade, gun, drugs, etc.), the DA must prove that you knew about the thing and had control over it. Can they prove it in your case just based on the statement of somebody else? I don't know without all the reports and details.

Joseph Briscoe Dane

People can say anything they please. They can change their stories 5 times before trial, and deliver a 6th one at trial. The question is: how can a jury believe the person who can't keep his story straight? The driver needs to man-up and take responsibility for his own sh*t, just like you need to take responsibility for yours.

Why do criminals evaluate others?

However, a criminal evaluates others in order to avoid consequences of his own irresponsible conduct. He seeks to overcome others to pursue objectives that are self-serving and ultimately result in injury to others. The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

What is the objective of a criminal?

The criminal’s objective is to arm himself so that he can pounce on any vulnerability in the interviewer as he jockeys for advantage. Criminals are quick to pick up on cues that indicate an interviewer’s bias or theoretical orientation.

How many evaluations are there in an interview?

Two evaluations are occurring. Whenever a criminal is participating in an interview, two evaluations are occurring. The law enforcement, corrections, or mental health professional is officially in charge and posing questions to make whatever assessment is necessary.

What happens if you are wrongfully accused of a crime?

Those who have been wrongfully accused of a crime may spend thousands of dollars in court costs and legal fees. Likewise, they may lose their job which makes it difficult to pay day-to-day bills. The accused’s personal life may be affected as well.

What does it mean to be wrongfully accused?

Being wrongfully accused is a situation that no one wants or expects. Any type of accusation can catch one off guard, which can then lead to mistakes that may be personally and financially devastating. It is important to take the right steps to guard against any type of loss.

What is plea bargain in court?

These sometimes seem like the best option to speed the process along, but they seldom work in favor of those who are wrongfully accused. A plea bargain is an admission of guilt. This can affect the future:

Why are warrants important?

Just as legal representation is important to refusing wrongful accusations, warrants are vital for any property searches. If the case does go to trial, a search that is conducted with permission and a search that is done so with a warrant is treated differently.

Is it rare to know someone is wrongfully accused?

Take the Right to Remain Silent. It is unfortunately rare for people to know in advance that they are being wrongfully accused of a crime. There are instances in which police unexpectedly arrive or papers are served before the accused knows what is happening.

Should you hire an attorney if you are being accused of a crime?

If possible, the accused should hire an attorney before formal legal action can take place.

Is it cheaper to hire an attorney?

Proving innocence is not cheap, but hiring the best attorney is better than being wrongfully convicted of a crime. The best course of action is to hire an attorney with experience dealing with this particular type of crime. It is unwise to rely upon public defenders or the cheapest lawyers. However, if there simply is no money to pay for the best attorney, make sure to stay involved with the process rather than only relying on the expertise of the chosen lawyer.

Friday, June 10, 2011

A while back I did interviews with various folks involved with criminal justice, including Judge Mike Lynch and crime scene specialist Stacey Wells, but I never got around to serving up the words of the men in black hats, the people who strive to put crooks back on the streets (I'm kidding, I'm kidding).

Interview with a Criminal Defense Lawyer

A while back I did interviews with various folks involved with criminal justice, including Judge Mike Lynch and crime scene specialist Stacey Wells, but I never got around to serving up the words of the men in black hats, the people who strive to put crooks back on the streets (I'm kidding, I'm kidding).

Why do innocent people plead guilty?

Many innocent defendants plead guilty in part due to fear of what they call 'the trial penalty' -- that the punishment will be greater after trial. There’s an assumption that when someone pleads guilty to a crime, swearing to tell the truth and allocuting to all the elements, he actually committed it. But this is not necessarily true.

How many years did the defendant get after a murder trial?

In one murder case, an offer was made of 11 years on a plea. After trial, the defendant was sentenced to 40. The defendant did not take the stand, thus the prosecution could not argue that he committed perjury or obstructed justice. He was given the higher sentence merely because he refused to plead guilty.

How to avoid a trial penalty?

2) Remove the “trial penalty” entirely unless there is proof that the defendant obstructed justice during trial or lied on the stand.

Why is fear of trial important?

From Stephanie Wilkins. This fear of trial saves the prosecution from having their evidence tested for both accuracy and sufficiency. It makes them lazy, invites corruption, and coerces defendants who stand a chance of being acquitted to back off. It also creates injustices.

Do you have to share evidence on the eve of trial?

Prosecutors in most states are not required to share evidence they’ve gathered until the eve of trial. But defendants who wait till then lose the benefit of a plea bargain. It’s not uncommon for judges to tell defendants as they’re being arraigned, “If you don’t take this plea today, it’s off the table.”.

Who said no one should be required to gamble with years and often decades of their liberty to exercise their 6th Amendment right

In an excellent report issued last week by the National Association of Criminal Defense Attorneys (NACDL), former Eastern District of New York Justice John Gleeson wrote, “No one should be required to gamble with years and often decades of their liberty to exercise their Sixth Amendment right.

Can you go to jail if you lose a jury trial?

Whether the person is innocent or not, jury trials are always a crap shoot, with the verdict uncertain until rendered. If you’re offered probation pre-trial by pleading guilty but know a judge will give you jail if you lose trial, you might choose to say you did something that you didn’t do just to avoid jail.

Advantages to Be Had

• The defense can gain significant benefits from trying to interview prosecution witnesses rather than relying on their statements. These include the ability to: 1. gauge witnesses' demeanor and credibility 2. ferret out details of witnesses' stories and strategize as to how to handle their testimony at trial 3. impeach witnesses who say something on...

See more on nolo.com

Reinventing The Wheel?

Waste of time?

Forcing The Issue

Get A Lawyer